What is Quantum gravity: Definition and 481 Discussions

Quantum gravity (QG) is a field of theoretical physics that seeks to describe gravity according to the principles of quantum mechanics, and where quantum effects cannot be ignored, such as in the vicinity of black holes or similar compact astrophysical objects where the effects of gravity are strong, such as neutron stars.
Three of the four fundamental forces of physics are described within the framework of quantum mechanics and quantum field theory. The current understanding of the fourth force, gravity, is based on Albert Einstein's general theory of relativity, which is formulated within the entirely different framework of classical physics. However, that description is incomplete: describing the gravitational field of a black hole in the general theory of relativity, physical quantities such as the spacetime curvature diverge at the center of the black hole.
This signals the breakdown of the general theory of relativity and the need for a theory that goes beyond general relativity into the quantum. At distances very close to the center of the black hole (closer than the Planck length), quantum fluctuations of spacetime are expected to play an important role. To describe these quantum effects a theory of quantum gravity is needed. Such a theory should allow the description to be extended closer to the center and might even allow an understanding of physics at the center of a black hole. On more formal grounds, one can argue that a classical system cannot consistently be coupled to a quantum one.The field of quantum gravity is actively developing, and theorists are exploring a variety of approaches to the problem of quantum gravity, the most popular being M-theory and loop quantum gravity.
All of these approaches aim to describe the quantum behavior of the gravitational field. This does not necessarily include unifying all fundamental interactions into a single mathematical framework. However, many approaches to quantum gravity, such as string theory, try to develop a framework that describes all fundamental forces. Such theories are often referred to as a theory of everything. Others, such as loop quantum gravity, make no such attempt; instead, they make an effort to quantize the gravitational field while it is kept separate from the other forces.
One of the difficulties of formulating a quantum gravity theory is that quantum gravitational effects only appear at length scales near the Planck scale, around 10−35 meters, a scale far smaller, and hence only accessible with far higher energies, than those currently available in high energy particle accelerators. Therefore, physicists lack experimental data which could distinguish between the competing theories which have been proposed and thus thought experiment approaches are suggested as a testing tool for these theories.

View More On Wikipedia.org
  1. N

    I What approaches to quantum gravity are QFT's?

    What are the different approaches to solving quantum gravity that are in the framework of quantum field theory?
  2. K

    I Asymptotic safety and loop quantum gravity

    this paper https://arxiv.org/abs/1701.02311 Hypercuboidal renormalization in spin foam quantum gravity Benjamin Bahr, Sebastian Steinhaus (Submitted on 9 Jan 2017) In this article we apply background-independent renormalization group methods to spin foam quantum gravity. It is aimed at...
  3. N

    A Can asymptotic safety in quantum gravity be right?

    Asymptotic safety in quantum gravity is a local QFT. According to many people, local quantum field theories cannot be correct in terms of being a quantum gravity theory. Lubos Motl outlines 4 reasons why they can't be right. "Quantum gravity cannot be described as a local field theory in the...
  4. N

    I Are there any linear quantum gravity theories?

    Are there any linear quantum gravity theories out there with respect to the wave function?
  5. N

    A Many worlds interpretation incompatible with quantum gravity

    On wikipedia, I found one of the objections to MWI. "We cannot be sure that the universe is a quantum multiverse until we have a theory of everything and, in particular, a successful theory of quantum gravity.[73] If the final theory of everything is non-linear with respect to wavefunctions then...
  6. N

    A Loop Quantum Gravity proven wrong?

    https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.1935 This paper says LQG does not produce the Unruh effect effect, and therefore must be wrong. What do you guys think. You can click into the PDF to see the entire paper.
  7. J

    A The de Sitter group and minmal length?

    The de Sitter group is often used as an extension of the Poincaré group, because its a simple group and preserves, in addition to a velocity c, a length L. A natural candidate for this length scale is the Planck length. Thus it seems to make sense to think about the invariant Planck length as...
  8. Narasoma

    I Quantizing Fluid Mechanics & Gravity: A Debate

    I ever read that there is no meaning for quantizing fluid mechanics. While left hand side of Einstein field equation used fluid-like approximation for matter (momentum-energy tensor). Therefore, if the first statement is correct then there is no meaning for quantizing gravity, right?
  9. K

    I Tensor networks, spin networks and loop quantum gravity

    Loop Quantum Gravity, Exact Holographic Mapping, and Holographic Entanglement Entropy Muxin Han, Ling-Yan Hung (Submitted on 7 Oct 2016) The relation between Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG) and tensor network is explored from the perspectives of bulk-boundary duality and holographic entanglement...
  10. K

    I MOND as a purely quantum gravity effect

    Four principles for quantum gravity Lee Smolin (Submitted on 6 Oct 2016) Four principles are proposed to underlie the quantum theory of gravity. We show that these suffice to recover the Einstein equations. We also suggest that MOND results from a modification of the classical equivalence...
  11. B

    B What Approach Tries to Resolve the Quantum Superposition Issue in Gravity?

    What is the second paragraph referring to in quantum gravity? specific name for it (like asymptotic gravity, etc.).. http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2016_09_01_archive.html "Just combining quantum field theory with general relativity doesn’t work because, as confirmed by countless...
  12. A

    I Spin Foam models in Loop Quantum Gravity

    Hi all, I fairly basic question about spin foam models in loop quantum gravity. I just want to verify that spin foams represent effectively represent all of spacetime (in a quantum form), and that the idea is that general relativity can be obtained in the classical limit? Not sure if that's...
  13. S

    Schools Top schools in North America in strings and quantum gravity

    Hi, the question is obvious from the title. I am looking for the names of the top 30 schools in North America for research work in string theory and quantum gravity. Any feedback will be very helpful.
  14. K

    I Recent paper Asymptotic safety in quantum gravity

    http://arxiv.org/abs/1609.04813 Quantum gravity on foliated spacetime - asymptotically safe and sound Jorn Biemans, Alessia Platania, Frank Saueressig (Submitted on 15 Sep 2016) Asymptotic Safety provides a mechanism for constructing a consistent and predictive quantum theory of gravity valid on...
  15. CrackerMcGinger

    B Is the Universe grainy below the Planck Scale?

    What is quantum gravity and how do you calculate the probability of where the particle is? I probably phrased the second half of that question wrong.
  16. J

    I Loop Quantum Gravity and Virtual Particles....

    Hi all, Following up on another post - for a layman, can someone describe the status of virtual particles in Loop Quantum Gravity models? Since LQG avoid UV divergences, and has a different structure from field-based theories, are virtual particles still talked about? (in the context of closed...
  17. A

    B How do I calculate electron acceleration by gravitational waves

    If the amplitude of gravitational waves, frequency of gravitational waves and the vector potential of magnetic field in surrounding of such waves are known then what would be the easiest way to calculate resultant acceleration of electrons? My above question is based on the various researches...
  18. Chronos

    I A new road to quantum gravity?

    This paper offers a potentially important observational test for quantum gravity http://arxiv.org/abs/1608.04228, Quantum Gravity in the Sky: Interplay between fundamental theory and observations.
  19. K

    A Can an event horizon telescope observe quantum gravity effects

    its commonly stated that no particle accelerator will ever be built that can probe the Planck scale. what about an can an event horizon telescope observe quantum gravity effects near a black hole, such as Sagittarius A* do the various candidates of QG such as string theory LQG asf gravity...
  20. JeJe

    What is the Connection Between Quantum Field Theory and Cosmology?

    I'm interested in all discussions but particularly those concerning the areas of QFT and cosmology. I've done much studying on the concept of quantum gravity over the past couple years and I want to learn more :)
  21. Sachin_Vaidya

    B Does quantum gravity inside brain change perception of time

    Does quantum gravity play role inside brain in ever changing perception of time?
  22. E

    Schools What school is good for my undergrad?

    I live in Texas, and I'm going on my senior year of high school. I've come to a problem, I don't know what college/university I should continue my education at. I've already decided what I hope to do when I'm older- qft and quantum gravity, but I don't know what place is good to further ones...
  23. D

    Going into theoretical physics with a screw-up undergrad deg

    Hello every one I am from Hong Kong. I am in my mid-twenties and I have a very bad result in my undergraduate degree in physics and it hinders me a lot in applying for a graduate degree. Theoretical physics (gravitation, quantum field, strings) is the field that I want to do research in for my...
  24. Ken Gallock

    B What kind of experiment is needed to quantize gravity?

    Hi everyone. I heard that there are several theories or hypotheses to quantize gravity such as superstring theory, loop quantum gravity, etc., and I believe none of them are conclusive (that's what I heard). So, here is my question. 1) Is it because there are no experimental results which prove...
  25. A. Neumaier

    A Loop quantum gravity and diffeomorphism group

    How is loop quantum gravity related to the principle of relativity, in particular to the diffeomorphism invariance of general relativity?
  26. Peter25samaha

    B Where Do Quantum Gravity and Cosomology Fit in Physics?

    In which branch of physics we can put Quantum Gravity and Cosmology ? -astrophysics ? -relativity ? -quantum mechanics ? -classical mechanics? Or other ?
  27. C

    B Is Gravitational Quantization Supported by the Stability of Orbital Electrons?

    Does the fact that orbital electrons are stable suggest that gravitation is quantized, analagous to the observation that the stability of orbital electrons suggested that electromagnetic energy was quantized?
  28. M

    B Why wouldn't quantum gravity work this way?

    First of all, I would like to point out that I have zero background in general relativity, but due to my overwhelming curiosity I will post this question anyway. So, what's wrong actually with applying the correspondence principle, which is typical in quantum mechanics, to quantum gravity...
  29. B

    I Exploring the Popularity of Loop Quantum Gravity in Current Physics Research

    is Loop Quantum Gravity as popular as String Theory in current physics research?
  30. E

    Seizmic Activity & Quantum Gravity: LIGO Info & Plans

    1. Does LIGO give also any information about seizmic activity? (I think as aspect intended primary to seizmic activity, not in connection with gravitational waves.) 2. Will measurement of gravitational wave give any information about quantum gravity? Is here any plan for this usage?
  31. ohwilleke

    What do the gravity waves seen by LIGO imply for QG?

    LIGO will apparently announce on February 11, the detection at five plus sigma of gravity waves (3 solar masses of energy worth in about 100 seconds) emitted as two medium sized black holes of about 65 solar masses combined spiral into each other and merge into a single Kerr (i.e. spinning)...
  32. arupel

    Reconciling Quantum Field Theory and General Relativity: Progress and Challenges

    I speak as an novice in this matter. Has progress been made in reconciling quantum field theory with general relativity? I know that there are theories which show reconciliation but none that seem to be verifiable empirically. Gravitons seem, from a practical viewpoint, impossible to detect...
  33. K

    Does Loop quantum gravity have an effective UV fixed point?

    loop quantum gravity and loop quantum cosmology gravity becomes weaker then repulsive instead of stronger, towards the Planck regime, due to the onset of quantum effects. gravity near Planck energies and densities, LQG/LQC becomes repulsive. at the inflection point where LQG gravity strength...
  34. F

    Can Quantum Gravity Serve as a Theory of Everything?

    I'm wondering if Quantum Gravity is expected to be a Theory Of Everything (TOE)? Can we expect that if we combine QFT with GR to get Quantum Gravity, will that be a TOE that explains GR and QFT?
  35. K

    Towards self dual Loop Quantum Gravity Jibril Ben Achour

    interesting new paper on possible new research direction for LQG http://arxiv.org/abs/1511.07332 Towards self dual Loop Quantum Gravity Jibril Ben Achour (Submitted on 23 Nov 2015) In this PhD thesis, we introduced a new strategy to investigate the kinematical and physical predictions of self...
  36. I

    Applied Math or Theoretical Physics?

    Hello everyone, as those of you who have helped with my other threads know I'm currently a high school student and an aspiring physicist. I'd like to start out my post by saying that I completely understand that I am very early to be thinking this far ahead, especially when I haven't experienced...
  37. K

    Confusion Related to Planck Mass

    Hi all, According to quantum mechanics, the graviton is the measure of the smallest amount of curvature possible in space-time. I read that the mass which would be required to create this curvature is Planck Mass which is close to the value 10^-5g. But the elementary particles, like electrons...
  38. wolram

    B Proving Quantum Gravity: Observable or Formula?

    How would one prove quantum gravity, would there be some thing observable or would it just be a mathematical formula.
  39. W

    Very precise Michelson-Morley experiments

    I have read that very high precision attempts to confirm the constant speed of light in all directions have been successful. For example in 2009, Stephan Schiller's lab was able to achieve a precision level that was one hundred millions times more precise than the original Michelson Morley...
  40. K

    Spacetime scaling invariance and quantum gravity

    Neil Turok, Director of the Perimeter Institute of Theoretical Physics in Ontario, Canada suggests scaling invariance is a fundamental property of nature, including spacetime. that nature does not recognize any kind of scale, including Planck scale. if true how would this affect the leading...
  41. K

    Where can I study (research) Loop Quantum Gravity?

    Thank you for opening this Thread I am kind of new here and this is my first time to post so I apologize if I did something wrong So my question is where can I study/ research Loop Quantum Gravity I have checked fair amount of grad school websites and compared to Super String, I have not yet...
  42. P

    What is the new Hamiltonian constraint operator for loop quantum gravity?

    A critique of LQG here: "The next step in the construction of LQG is to decide what the dynamics are. Technically, this is done either (A) by choosing a "Hamiltonian constraint" in parallel with the Hamiltonian formulation of GR, or (B) in the spin-foam formalism, by postulating some sort of...
  43. S

    Modified Newtonian Dynamics vs. Quantum Gravity

    OK. I'm sure this is probably been considered before but it is my musings coming off a recent attempt to photograph the Andromeda Galaxy. I did a few two minutes or so shots of Andromeda and stacked them for a total of about 14 minutes. Fairly nice. There is some structure to be seen but...
  44. D

    Does quantum gravity argue that space is not singularly....

    Does quantum gravity argue that space is not singularly occupied by rectilinear motion?I am reading a general relativity intro sort of thing and this inquiry popped up in my mind. The text was explicating space being occupied by only rectilinear motion and I wondered if quantum gravity could be...
  45. Q

    Is Loop Quantum Gravity a Machian theory?

    Hi All! I have heard that loop quantum gravity is a "background independent" theory, in that there is no preferred coordinate system. Is LQG also a Machian theory?
  46. K

    Do Black Holes End up as Quark Stars? and quantum gravity

    this paper Do Black Holes End up as Quark Stars ? R.K.Thakur (Submitted on 25 Feb 2007) The possibility of the existence of quark stars has been discussed by several authors since 1970. Recently, it has been pointed out that two putative neutron stars, RXJ 1856.5 - 3754 in Corona Australis...
  47. Georges Simenon

    Linear simplicity constraint in Loop Quantum Gravity

    Homework Statement Hi, I am studying covariant LQG from the recent book by Rovelli & Vidotto, and i am struggling with the linear simplicity constraint. My problems are not with its proof, that i understand, but rather with the physical interpretation in terms of boost generators. I will try to...
  48. L

    What is the right theory of quantum gravity?

    This question, at the moment, is ridiculously difficult or even impossible to answer. Some prefer string theory, and some think that it is overly speculative and LQG may be a better fit, and some say the opposite. I would like to ask; In your opinion, what could be the right theory of quantum...
  49. S.Daedalus

    Einstein Equation of State vs Gravity from Entanglement

    There's a somehow related set of issues I find myself pondering time and again: In 1995, Ted Jacobson derived Einstein's equations from thermodynamics across a horizon. Roughly, he showed that if the horizon's entropy is given by the Bekenstein-Hawking formula, then the second law of...
Back
Top