Is World Jump Day Real? A Closer Look at This Controversial Event

[TuRbOxChAz]

I would really like to know if this is really true.

Please also read by the [more info]

 

[Pengwuino]

no

tomatooooo

 

[Mk]

Wow that's one of the craziest things I've ever seen.

Even if everybody in the world jumped up and down at the same time the orbit wouldn't change.

 

[russ_watters]

Conservation of energy says nothing at all happens to the Earth's orbit when you jump.

 

[DaveC426913]

Of course nothing would change in the larger sense.

But it would be interesting to see if it showed up on seismic readings...

 

[Tony11235]

Thats crazy. These people can't be serious.

 

[Andre]

Well I predict that if you react you will get an e-mail on 31 March stating that tomorrow is world jumping day.

That would be great.

 

[Pengwuino]

Well I predict that if you react you will get an e-mail on 31 March stating that tomorrow is world jumping day.
That would be great.

http://www.museumofhoaxes.com/tacobell.html

The Ford Lincoln Mercury Memorial

 

[JMAC]

Simple Conservation of Energy

Conservation of energy is the only issue here. Observing the Earth (and all of its inhabitants and atmoshphere) as one mass, the only way to change the orbit is if it is acted upon by an outside force. So either external gravity/impact/force could change the orbit, or the Earth mass would change by expelling matter. If all of these people would jump off into space, never to return, then that would change the orbit minutely. If so many people believe this, perhaps that's the best option...

 

[Serpo]

Okay... bare with me. When there is a massive earthquake (such as the tsunami in December of '04) It can alter the Earth's orbit slightly... so why not everyone jumping up and down at exactly the same time? You really think that would cause NO rumbling at all? 6.5 billion people is a lot of weight. This gets me to questioning "what exactly an earthquake is and how it is caused?"... and why it can change the orbit of the Earth. Someone talk with me :)

 

[russ_watters]

You misread/hear: earthquakes alter the Earth's rotation, not it's orbit.

 

[russ_watters]

If all of these people would jump off into space, never to return, then that would change the orbit minutely. If so many people believe this, perhaps that's the best option...

Yeah, but that would be the end of basketball as we know it...

 

[matthyaouw]

This gets me to questioning "what exactly an earthquake is and how it is caused

An Earthquake is the sudden release of pressure along a crack known as a fault. Movement along these faults is not steady due to frictional force. When stress builds up enough, it will overcome friction and a section of rock will slide over another up to a few metres in distance. This releases massive shockwaves which causes shaking at the surface.

 

[JMAC]

Rotation changed, not the orbit. WORLD SUCK/BLOW DAY

Russ is right, the rotation of the Earth is affected by these quakes. We can control the rotation of the earth, but not the orbital path, because the Earth mass as a whole is still traveling in the same path even though the rotational path changes.

WORLD SUCK/BLOW DAY (This one would actually work.)
Needed: 2,500,000,000 Registered: 1

Everyone would face west then SUCK in a huge breath of air.
Turn east and BLOW it out hard.

This will slow the Earth's rotation, extend the length of an Earth day.

(And according to the World Jump Day experts, bring back Elvis and the Easter Bunny)

 

[Pengwuino]

=
Needed: 2,500,000,000

I have no doubts that 2.5 billion people on this Earth really suck.

 

[Serpo]

Thanks guys. I guess what I was asking for was a bit deeper, and a bit of a misunderstanding about orbit and rotation. That's funny pengwuino :P

 

[Facial]

The situation might be more complex than a simple analysis with conservation of momentum.

Imagine two containers in free space connected by a spring.
One consists of viscoelastic tissue like human tissue and the other consists of cold tar, like Earth's magma. Which direction would the system shift if it were to oscillate? That's the real question here.

 

[russ_watters]

Are you meaning to imply that an oscillation can cause a net displacement of the center of gravity of the system by dampening one side?

No.

 

[Facial]

Yes. I meant to imply that.

How come it doesn't work?

 

[russ_watters]

There is no outside force to move the system.

 

[Shahil]

One really interesting thing though. These guys are selling stickers and t-shirts (which look quite cool i must add) to make a quick buck out of there non-sensical jumping er, thingy! I take my hat off to them for there creative business sense.

BTW, how many people will actually jump at that exact time. It is an impossibilty, it'll NEVER happen and you can all be happy that the Earth's rotation, orbit or the Earth's secret plan to go on a low-carb diet in the year 30156 will all be unchanged.

 

[fasterthanjoao]

people believe things when it looks official. See Stanely Milgram. :)

 

[vabamyyr]

But let's say many nuclear bombs explode in a specific place. Doesn't that change the Earth's orbit?

 

[SGT]

In The Ultimate Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy there is a story about a planet which would be destroyed by a cataclysm. So the inhabitants build three large ships to transport the whole population to another suitable planet.
In ship A would go all the brilliant leaders, the scientists, the great artists. In ship C would go all the people who did the actual work, who made things and did things and in ship B everybody else.
The B ship was the first and only one to take off. The elite of the planet had made up the story of the cataclysm to get rid of the undesirables.
If someday we have the technology for that, we can send people who believe in such nonsense as The Earth Jumping Day to leave the planet.

 

[Evo]

In The Ultimate Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy there is a story about a planet which would be destroyed by a cataclysm. So the inhabitants build three large ships to transport the whole population to another suitable planet.
In ship A would go all the brilliant leaders, the scientists, the great artists. In ship C would go all the people who did the actual work, who made things and did things and in ship B everybody else.
The B ship was the first and only one to take off. The elite of the planet had made up the story of the cataclysm to get rid of the undesirables.
If someday we have the technology for that, we can send people who believe in such nonsense as The Earth Jumping Day to leave the planet.

I want to help make the list of who goes on ship B.

 

[russ_watters]

But let's say many nuclear bombs explode in a specific place. Doesn't that change the Earth's orbit?

Yes, it would. If you're looking to compare that with "World Jump Day", the difference is that the energy of the bombs starts as nuclear energy, not mechanical energy. So there is a net input of mechanical energy.

 

[Aether]

Yes, it would. If you're looking to compare that with "World Jump Day", the difference is that the energy of the bombs starts as nuclear energy, not mechanical energy. So there is a net input of mechanical energy.

Are you sure about this?

 

[Aether]

But let's say many nuclear bombs explode in a specific place. Doesn't that change the Earth's orbit?

Not by much. The Earth's orbit is determined by the total mass-energy (also their momentums and even their shapes!) of the earth, Sun, and other objects in the solar system to a lesser extent. A nuclear bomb converts a little bit of nuclear mass, [tex]m[/tex], into a lot ([tex]E=mc^2[/tex]) of thermal kinetic energy and electromagnetic radiation, [tex]E[/tex]. That part of the electromagnetic radiation which leaves the Earth for good does reduce the mass-energy of the Earth a little bit, and therefore it does change the Earth's orbit a little bit (so does shining a flashlight into space ), but AFAIK the force of the explosion per se can not change the Earth's orbit unless it propels some object(s) to escape velocity and they actually leave the Earth so that they aren't part of it anymore.

 

[Pythagorean]

My professor of physics once said that a better idea would be world 'walke east' day. If everyone in the world walked east at once, there would be a change in the rotational velocity of the Earth, due to us pushing the ground as we walk.

Unfortuntaely, I don't know if the Earth spins east or west, so I don't know if this would speed us up, or slow us down. I imagine once we all stopped, we would return (or take back) the momentum from the Earth and it would continue with its original speed. But did we just cheat the day some frame of time?

 

[Aether]

My professor of physics once said that a better idea would be world 'walke east' day. If everyone in the world walked east at once, there would be a change in the rotational velocity of the Earth, due to us pushing the ground as we walk.

Unfortuntaely, I don't know if the Earth spins east or west, so I don't know if this would speed us up, or slow us down.

The Sun generally appears to rise in the east, and to set in the west. So, which way is the Earth spinning?

I imagine once we all stopped, we would return (or take back) the momentum from the Earth and it would continue with its original speed.

Yes.

But did we just cheat the day some frame of time?

Yes, but only if you don't count yourself as a part of the earth. Also, if you ever walk back to the place where you started then you would completely un-do the effect (unless you go the long way round).

 

[BobG]

The Sun generally appears to rise in the east, and to set in the west. So, which way is the Earth spinning?

Where the heck do you live? In Alaska in the summertime, the Sun rises in the North and sets in the North. So which way is the Earth spinning?

Hmmm, I guess your reply isn't any sillier than the original comment. When I was in Alaska for a year, I did find it odd that when I wanted to look homeward towards Omaha, I had to look due East. Directions are kind of funny when you're so close to the poles.

 

[Aether]

The Sun generally appears to rise in the east, and to set in the west. So, which way is the Earth spinning?

Where the heck do you live? In Alaska in the summertime, the Sun rises in the North and sets in the North. So which way is the Earth spinning?

Ha ha, I said "generally".

 

[SGT]

You misread/hear: earthquakes alter the Earth's rotation, not it's orbit.

The total momentum of the Earth cannot be changed by internal forces. If the rotation of the planet is altered, so is its angular momentum. In order to conserve the total momentum, the orbital speed must be altered.
Something similar has being happening in the last 4 billion years or so. The Moon was closer to Earth and both bodies had a faster rotation.
Friction caused by tides has slowed both rotations in such a way that now the Moon always faces the Earth with the same side. The conservation of momentum of the Earth-Moon system has made the satellite move farther from the planet.

 

[Aether]

You misread/hear: earthquakes alter the Earth's rotation, not it's orbit.

If the rotation of the planet is altered, so is its angular momentum. In order to conserve the total momentum, the orbital speed must be altered.

Incorrect. Angular momentum is a product of rotational inertia and angular speed. The rotational inertia of the Earth decreased significantly as a result of the earthquake that caused the tsunami in Dec. 2004 for example. To conserve angular momentum, the angular speed of the Earth's rotation had to increase proportionally.

 

[russ_watters]

Are you sure about this?

Am I sure about what? Where the energy comes from or what the effect is?

If you are simply saying the effect will be small, I never said it wouldn't be. But it won't be zero, unlike the net effect of the World Jump Day scenario.

nuclear bomb converts a little bit of nuclear mass, , into a lot () of thermal kinetic energy and electromagnetic radiation, . That part of the electromagnetic radiation which leaves the Earth for good does reduce the mass-energy of the Earth a little bit, and therefore it does change the Earth's orbit a little bit (so does shining a flashlight into space ), but AFAIK the force of the explosion per se can not change the Earth's orbit unless it propels some object(s) to escape velocity and they actually leave the Earth so that they aren't part of it anymore.

A flashlight still has a nonzero effect (unlike the World Jump Day effect which is exactly zero), but the image that puts in ones head is a little misleading. Radiation pressure is significant enough that a there have been number of different means of harnessing it proposed to propel spacecraft .