'A single molecule of H2O' vs 'a single atom of H2O'

In summary, a single molecule of H2O is the correct term as H2O is a molecule composed of 2 Hydrogen atoms and 1 Oxygen atom. The mass of 1 H2O molecule can be calculated using the molar mass of 18.02 g/mol or by dividing 18 g/mol by Avogadro's number of 6.023 x 10^23 molecules/mol, which results in a mass of 2.992 x 10^-23 grams. It is important to pay attention to the units when calculating and reporting the mass of a molecule.
  • #1
Indranil
177
11
Which one is correct below
1. a single molecule of H2O
2. a single atom of H2O (if this one is correct then what does it mean?)
 
  • Like
Likes Nelli and Ilya Furman
Chemistry news on Phys.org
  • #2
Indranil said:
Which one is correct below
1. a single molecule of H2O
2. a single atom of H2O (if this one is correct then what does it mean?)

1. would be correct because H2O (water) is a MOLECULE which is composed of 2 Hydrogen ATOMS and 1 Oxygen ATOM.
 
  • #3
Ilya Furman said:
1. would be correct because H2O (water) is a MOLECULE which is composed of 2 Hydrogen ATOMS and 1 Oxygen ATOM.
Is 'a molecule of H2O' is the same as 'a single molecule of H2O'?
 
  • Like
Likes Ilya Furman
  • #4
Indranil said:
Is 'a molecule of H2O' is the same as 'a single molecule of H2O'?
Correct!
 
  • #5
Ilya Furman said:
Correct!
Then what is the mass of 1 H2O molecule?
 
  • Like
Likes Ilya Furman
  • #6
Indranil said:
Then what is the mass of 1 H2O molecule?
You tell us. that is an easy question that you should be able to answer by now. And show your work.
 
  • Like
Likes Ilya Furman
  • #7
Mod note for other users: we are spoonfeeding this member too much. Please allow/demand s/he try to answer these questions hi/erself.
 
  • Like
Likes HAYAO, Ilya Furman, Borek and 2 others
  • #8
russ_watters said:
You tell us. that is an easy question that you should be able to answer by now. And show your work.
OK,
russ_watters said:
Mod note for other users: we are spoonfeeding this member too much. Please allow/demand s/he try to answer these questions hi/erself.
Because in a site, I found two different masses of 1 molecule of H2O
one is 18.02 grams and the another is 2.992 x 10-23 grams that's why I am confused which one should I take? because as mentioned above, 'a molecule of H2O' and 'a single molecule of H2O' are the same thing. Then why are the different masses for ''1 molecule of H2O''
Source:https://www.thoughtco.com/avogadros-number-example-chemistry-problem-609541
 
  • Like
Likes Ilya Furman
  • #9
Indranil said:
OK,

Because in a site, I found two different masses of 1 molecule of H2O
one is 18.02 grams and the another is 2.992 x 10-23 grams that's why I am confused which one should I take? because as mentioned above, 'a molecule of H2O' and 'a single molecule of H2O' are the same thing. Then why are the different masses for ''1 molecule of H2O''
Source:https://www.thoughtco.com/avogadros-number-example-chemistry-problem-609541
okay...my last hint: check the units of the two values.
 
  • Like
Likes Ilya Furman and russ_watters
  • #10
Indranil said:
OK,

Because in a site, I found two different masses of 1 molecule of H2O
one is 18.02 grams and the another is 2.992 x 10-23 grams that's why I am confused which one should I take?
You just googled the answer. I want you to CALCULATE the answer. And show your work.
 
  • Like
Likes acs860 and Ilya Furman
  • #11
russ_watters said:
Mod note for other users: we are spoonfeeding this member too much. Please allow/demand s/he try to answer these questions hi/erself.
For example, in post #2
Ilya Furman said:
1. would be correct because H2O (water) is a MOLECULE which is composed of 2 Hydrogen ATOMS and 1 Oxygen ATOM.
Our policy here is to NOT merely provide answers to posted questions.
 
  • Like
Likes Ilya Furman and russ_watters
  • #12
Indranil said:
OK,

Because in a site, I found two different masses of 1 molecule of H2O
one is 18.02 grams and the another is 2.992 x 10-23 grams that's why I am confused which one should I take? because as mentioned above, 'a molecule of H2O' and 'a single molecule of H2O' are the same thing. Then why are the different masses for ''1 molecule of H2O''
Source:https://www.thoughtco.com/avogadros-number-example-chemistry-problem-609541

18.02 grams as the mass of a water molecule snapped my head around - a US penny coin is 2.5 grams!. You may wish to read up on molar mass, what it is, and how it is calculated.
 
  • Like
Likes acs860 and Ilya Furman
  • #13
Mark44 said:
For example, in post #2
Our policy here is to NOT merely provide answers to posted questions.
I was not aware of the procedure. I just joined today. I simply explained the difference between the two possible answers.
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman
  • #14
physics loverq said:
okay...my last hint: check the units of the two values.
Mass of 1 H2O molecule is below
the first one is 18g/mol and the second one is 2.992 x 10-23 grams. Now I got it
The mass of 1H2O molecule in gram/mole unit
If I split 1 H2O molecule, we get 2H atoms and 1O atom
Mass of 1H atom is 1.01 g/mol and mass of 1O atom is 16g/mol so, the mass of 1H2O molecule is 18.02 g/mol------------------------------------ (1)
The mass of 1H2O molecule in gram unit
1H2O molecule = 18g/mol and 1H2O molecule = 6.023 X 10^23 molecules/mol
so 1H2O molecule = 18g/mol / 6.023 X10^23 molecules/mol = 2.992 x 10-23 grams
mass of 1 water molecule = 2.992 x 10-23 grams --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(2)
Please point out above where I am wrong.Thanking you
 
  • Like
Likes HAYAO, Ilya Furman and Asymptotic
  • #15
The answer is 99.9% correct. Well done.

To be a bit nitpicky, you calculated molecular weight of H2O as 18.02 g⋅mol-1 and not 18 g⋅mol-1 so you should write it as so in your equations (calculating as 18 g⋅mol-1 gives you 2.989x10-23 g). That is the remaining 0.1% that you were wrong. You should make this a habit so that you won't mess up the significant figures as well.
 
  • Like
Likes jim mcnamara, russ_watters, Ilya Furman and 1 other person
  • #16
Indranil said:
Which one is correct below
1. a single molecule of H2O
2. a single atom of H2O (if this one is correct then what does it mean?)
Big conceptual distinction. Molecule of water, YES. Single Atom of water, NO.

One mole of H2O is made of 2 moles Hydrogen and 1 mole Oxygen. Thinking down to the finest units, 2 atoms of Hydrogen and 1 atom of Oxygen would make for 1 molecule of water, not accounting for isotopes.
 
  • #17
Indranil said:
The mass of 1H2O molecule in gram/mole unit
This is not the molecular mass but the molar mass, i.e. the mass of one mole of H2O molecules.
Conceptually, a mole falls in the same category as "a dozen" or "a score".
A dozen of eggs has a higher mass than a single egg. In the same way, the mass of a mole of water molecules is much higher than the mass of a single water molecule.
 
  • #18
Indranil said:
The mass of 1H2O molecule in gram/mole unit

No, you can't express mas of a molecule in g/mol. g/mol is for molar mass, mass of a single molecule is just in grams (kilograms, or any other mass unit).
 
  • #19
Indranil said:
Please point out above where I am wrong.Thanking you
HAYAO said:
The answer is 99.9% correct. Well done.
Great job, @Indranil!
 
  • Like
Likes Indranil
  • #20
russ_watters said:
Great job, @Indranil!
Thank you sir.
 
  • #21
Borek said:
No, you can't express mas of a molecule in g/mol. g/mol is for molar mass, mass of a single molecule is just in grams (kilograms, or any other mass unit).
Let me clear my concept
1. 'O + H2 = H2O', Here do one O atom and one H2 molecule (two H atoms) and one H2O molecule express molar mass? 1O = 16g/mole, 1H2 = 2g/mole and 1H2O = 18g/mole?
2.'C + O2 = CO2' Here one C atom and one O2 molecule (two O atoms) and one CO2 molecule express molar mass? 1C = 12g/mole, 1O2 = 32g/mole and 1CO2 = 44g/mole
So what elements we see in the periodic table and elements we use in making chemical equations, are in the form of ''molar mass'' or ''gram/mole''?
Please help me clear this concept. Thanking you.
 
Last edited:
  • #22
Indranil said:
1. 'O + H2 = H2O', Here do one O atom and one H2 molecule (two H atoms) and one H2O molecule express molar mass? 1O = 16g/mole, 1H2 = 2g/mole and 1H2O = 18g/mole?

What do you mean by 'express molar mass'? Each atom and molecule have a specific mass, which we commonly give in grams per mole of the substance. Molar mass is not a property that is 'expressed'.

Indranil said:
So what elements we see in the periodic table and elements we use in making chemical equations, are in the form of ''gram/mole''?

All the elements have a molar mass. This is because molar mass is just the amount of mass per mole of the substance. It's like giving the mass of eggs as grams per dozen eggs. It's used because it is convenient for us.
 
  • #23
Indranil said:
Please help me understand this correctly:

1. "O + H2 → H2O", Here, are one O atom, one H2 molecule (two H atoms), and one H2O molecule expressed in molar mass units? That is, 1O = 16 g⋅mol-1, 1H2 = 2 g⋅mol-1, and 1H2O = 18 g⋅mol-1?

2. "C + O2 → CO2" Here, are one C atom, one O2 molecule (two O atoms), and one CO2 molecule express molar mass? That is, 1C = 12 g⋅mol-1, 1O2 = 32 g⋅mol-1, and 1CO2 = 44 g⋅mol-1?

What elemental symbol we see in the periodic table and in chemical reaction equations are in the form of ''molar mass'' or ''gram/mole'' units?
Thank you.

Proofread for clarity.Forget about the elements for now. Let's say we have some random stuff named A and another random but a different stuff named B. Combining one A and two B will give us one C:
A + 2B → C​
The reaction equation simply states that combining one A with two Bs will give you one C. Nothing more and nothing less. Same thing with elements. The elemental symbols itself are merely symbols to represent what element we are looking at.The numbers on the elements simply represent the ratio of each species in a reaction. They are certainly not in the units of molar mass. There are no units.
 
  • Like
Likes DrDu
  • #24
Indranil said:
Let me clear my concept
1. 'O + H2 = H2O', Here do one O atom and one H2 molecule (two H atoms) and one H2O molecule express molar mass? 1O = 16g/mole, 1H2 = 2g/mole and 1H2O = 18g/mole?
2.'C + O2 = CO2' Here one C atom and one O2 molecule (two O atoms) and one CO2 molecule express molar mass? 1C = 12g/mole, 1O2 = 32g/mole and 1CO2 = 44g/mole
So what elements we see in the periodic table and elements we use in making chemical equations, are in the form of ''molar mass'' or ''gram/mole''?
Please help me clear this concept. Thanking you.
Not the way you are saying.

(1)
One oxygen is bonded to TWO hydrogens. Separate bond for each.

(2)
One carbon is bonded to TWO oxygens. Separate bond for each.
 
  • #25
HAYAO said:
Proofread for clarity.Forget about the elements for now. Let's say we have some random stuff named A and another random but a different stuff named B. Combining one A and two B will give us one C:
A + 2B → C​
The reaction equation simply states that combining one A with two Bs will give you one C. Nothing more and nothing less. Same thing with elements. The elemental symbols itself are merely symbols to represent what element we are looking at.The numbers on the elements simply represent the ratio of each species in a reaction. They are certainly not in the units of molar mass. There are no units.

I can only agree strongly. Formulas like ##\mathrm{H_2O}## were written long before it was known or widely accepted, that matter is made up of molecules and atoms. Even today when working in preparative chemistry, you can live well without even knowing about Avogadro's constant.
 
  • #26
symbolipoint said:
Not the way you are saying.

(1)
One oxygen is bonded to TWO hydrogens. Separate bond for each.

(2)
One carbon is bonded to TWO oxygens. Separate bond for each.
This is not my question. My question is simple. What should I say from the equations below?
1. H2 + O = H2O
My first question is
What should I say from this equation? I think we say one H2 molecule(two H atoms) and one O atom combines to form one molecule H2O. Here one H2 molecule means what? two H atoms which weigh 2.014g/mole ( molar mass of two H atoms) and one O atom means what? molar mass of one O atom is 16g/mole. So my question is one H atom means 1.007g H atom and one O atom means 16g O atom which represents the molar mass of one H atom and one O atom.
And
My second question is If we look at the periodic table and find the mass of H. We find the mass of H is 1.007. Here my question what does 1.007 mean? it means 1.007 g/mole, the molar mass of one H atom?
 
  • #27
What should I say from this equation? I think we say one H2 molecule(two H atoms) and one O atom combines to form one molecule H2O.
No, it doesn't, at least not only so.

Let me start differently: Let's look at a simple equation, e.g. ##E=1/2 m v^2##. Wenn we write E for energy here, we do not say nothing about it's units. It could be Joules, mJ or kcal, or some atomic unit like eV (electron Volt). The same with chemical equations. If we write ## \mathrm{2H_2 + O_2 \to 2H_2O}##, ##\mathrm{H_2}## stands for Hydrogen in its molecular form, but not necessarily for 1 molecule of hydrogen. It can stand for one mole, 1 kilomole, or one atom or one dozen atoms.
 
  • Like
Likes symbolipoint
  • #28
+1

The equation tells you the ratio of the constituents.

The periodic table gives the mass in grams of one mole of the element (Molar mass).

If you want to calculate the mass of one molecule (eg it's molecular mass) you normally calculate the mass of one mole (it's molar mass) by adding up the molar masses from the periodic table in the right ratios and then divide by the number of molecules in a mole (Avogadro's number).
 
  • #29
DrDu said:
No, it doesn't, at least not only so.

Let me start differently: Let's look at a simple equation, e.g. ##E=1/2 m v^2##. Wenn we write E for energy here, we do not say nothing about it's units. It could be Joules, mJ or kcal, or some atomic unit like eV (electron Volt). The same with chemical equations. If we write ## \mathrm{2H_2 + O_2 \to 2H_2O}##, ##\mathrm{H_2}## stands for Hydrogen in its molecular form, but not necessarily for 1 molecule of hydrogen. It can stand for one mole, 1 kilomole, or one atom or one dozen atoms.
I got your point but here I have a question below
''It can stand for one mole, 1 kilomole, or one atom or one dozen atoms''
Does it always (one atom, one mole, one molecule etc in an equation) give the mass in gram of one mole of the element (molar mass)?
 
  • #30
This is basic maths. If you multiply one side of an equation by 1000 you must also multiply the other. The units must also balance.

So if one side is in "grams per mole (molar mass)" then so is the other side. If one side is in "atoms" then the other side must also be in "atoms". If one side is in "kg" then so is the other side. If one side is in "elephants," then so is the other. You can't have 3 elephants + 2 elephants = 5 horses.
 
  • #31
Indranil said:
This is not my question. My question is simple. What should I say from the equations below?
1. H2 + O = H2O
My first question is
What should I say from this equation? I think we say one H2 molecule(two H atoms) and one O atom combines to form one molecule H2O. Here one H2 molecule means what? two H atoms which weigh 2.014g/mole ( molar mass of two H atoms) and one O atom means what? molar mass of one O atom is 16g/mole. So my question is one H atom means 1.007g H atom and one O atom means 16g O atom which represents the molar mass of one H atom and one O atom.
And
My second question is If we look at the periodic table and find the mass of H. We find the mass of H is 1.007. Here my question what does 1.007 mean? it means 1.007 g/mole, the molar mass of one H atom?

There are a few things I would like to comment on here.

When you look at the periodic table, what is given is the molar mass of the atoms, which includes relative isotopic abundance. Take hydrogen, for instance. You will find that the number is 1.007 97 g/mol. That means that if you collect 1/2 mole of hydrogen gas (H2), which is the natural form for that element, such that you have a total of 1 mole of H atoms, that sample is going to have a mass of 1.007 97 g.

But if you divide that mass by Avogadro's number, you get 1.67377×10-24 g, which is not the mass of one hydrogen atom. The mass of the most common isotope of hydrogen, 1H, is actually 1.007 825 032 23 g/mol, or 1.67353×10-24 g for one atom. This is because 0.0115% of hydrogen atoms are the deuterium isotope, 2H.

While the difference is small for hydrogen, it is not far all elements. A good example is chlorine. The periodic table will give a molar mass of 35.453 g/mol, but an actual sodium atom will either have a mass of 34.969 g/mol (35Cl) or 36.966 g/mol (37Cl). A sample of naturally occurring chlorine will be 75.8% 35Cl and 24.2% 37Cl.
 
  • #32
DrClaude said:
There are a few things I would like to comment on here.

When you look at the periodic table, what is given is the molar mass of the atoms, which includes relative isotopic abundance. Take hydrogen, for instance. You will find that the number is 1.007 97 g/mol. That means that if you collect 1/2 mole of hydrogen gas (H2), which is the natural form for that element, such that you have a total of 1 mole of H atoms, that sample is going to have a mass of 1.007 97 g.

But if you divide that mass by Avogadro's number, you get 1.67377×10-24 g, which is not the mass of one hydrogen atom. The mass of the most common isotope of hydrogen, 1H, is actually 1.007 825 032 23 g/mol, or 1.67353×10-24 g for one atom. This is because 0.0115% of hydrogen atoms are the deuterium isotope, 2H.

While the difference is small for hydrogen, it is not far all elements. A good example is chlorine. The periodic table will give a molar mass of 35.453 g/mol, but an actual sodium atom will either have a mass of 34.969 g/mol (35Cl) or 36.966 g/mol (37Cl). A sample of naturally occurring chlorine will be 75.8% 35Cl and 24.2% 37Cl.
'1.67353×10-24 g for one H atom or one H proton'?
 
  • #33
Indranil said:
'1.67353×10-24 g for one H atom or one H proton'?
Atom. The mass of the proton is 1.6726219 × 10-24 g. The atom is heavier because of the presence of the electron.
 
  • #34
DrClaude said:
Atom. The mass of the proton is 1.6726219 × 10-24 g. The atom is heavier because of the presence of the electron.
I knew that mass of an atom means the mass of protons and neutrons. So the H atom has one proton and one electron. So one proton weighs 1.6726219 × 10-24 g But you mentioned the difference value for mass for one H atom. Then the mass of one H atom does not mean mass of one proton of H atom?
 
  • #35
Indranil said:
Then the mass of one H atom does not mean mass of one proton of H atom?
What is "one proton of H atom"?

The mass of the hydrogen atom is the mass of the entire atom, namely the proton, the electron, and the mass equivalent to the binding energy (a hydrogen atom weighs less than the sum of the mass of a lone proton and a lone electron).
 

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
6K
Replies
1
Views
517
Replies
23
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
578
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Chemistry
Replies
34
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Back
Top