- #1
mtkirwan
- 1
- 0
Is every human action motivated by self-interest? Even when we help a complete stranger do we do it becuase it makes us feel good (and hence we are doing it out of self interest)? What do you think?
Originally posted by mtkirwan
Is every human action motivated by self-interest? Even when we help a complete stranger do we do it becuase it makes us feel good (and hence we are doing it out of self interest)? What do you think?
Originally posted by the_truth
Yes. We are ruled by self interest, constantly striving to think of new ways to achieve our ambitions and protect our interests. The only conceivable way to get someone to not spend their lives as a machiavellian deceitful power zealot would be to persuade them that by not constantly striving for more power and pleasure they will enjoy an eternity in heaven.
Originally posted by cookiemonster
The concept of "self-interest" can be expanded to include, either directly or indirectly, just about any reason behind one's actions. Consequently, everybody can be said to be motivated by self-interest if so desired.
cookiemonster
Originally posted by selfAdjoint
Well there are cases where people have given up their lives for others. Soldiers falling on hand grenades to save their buddies, passers-by rushing in front of cars or trains to push a child to safety. This kind of thing does happen. And it's very difficult to see what self interest is gratified by a painful death.
Originally posted by cookiemonster
Which statement?
cookiemonster
On the other hand if everyone acted according to what they could get out of things wouldn't it make it harder for them to see the things the might stand to benefit everyone and not just themselves?
Also, doesn't the burden of proof lie on those claiming that all actions are greed-motivated?
Originally posted by Kerrie
not necessarily...think of the sacrifices parents (human or animal) will make for their young...
Originally posted by elibol
this can also be of self interest thru the belief of the parents living on as their children.
complicated matters these are =]
Originally posted by mtkirwan
Is every human action motivated by self-interest? Even when we help a complete stranger do we do it becuase it makes us feel good (and hence we are doing it out of self interest)? What do you think?
Just what I was thinking about (not food): How can one consider actions of gratitude to be selfish?Originally posted by b11ngoo
But to tell the cook his stew or pizza is tops. :)