- #71
Hurkyl
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 14,981
- 26
No, it isn't.
It isn't?
(a) You made a comment about me.
(b) You were not responding to any argument I was making.
Isn't that, by definition, an ad hominem attack?
You assert that someone should lose freedom, unless they can prove they should have it.
Where did I assert that? Zero, stop posting lies about me.
If you want to take away someone's freedom then you have to provide a good reason to.
Okay. So?
(a) I have not argued that anyone's freedom should be taken away.
(b) Taking away freedom isn't even the topic; it's taking away a restriction.
(c) I have not argued that any restrictions should not be taken away.
Last edited: