Why does superfluid helium in a spinning bucket have angular momentum?

In summary, superfluid helium in a spinning bucket has angular momentum because the rotation of the bucket causes the helium atoms to form a vortex, which gives the helium a net angular momentum. This phenomenon is known as the "vortex state" and is unique to superfluids due to their lack of viscosity and ability to flow without resistance. The angular momentum of the helium is conserved and can be observed through the rotation of the bucket, making it a valuable tool for studying quantum mechanics and superfluidity.
  • #1
SunSmellsLoud
3
0
Suppose you have a bucket filled with superfluid Helium-4 and you spin it with a large angular velocity Ω, the bucket obviously has angular momentum.

Spinning fast enough, the fluid develops irrotational vortex lines which carry quanta of angular momentum, while leaving the curl of the ∇xv 0, as it should be (with v the microscopic velocity field).

My question is, supposing you start with the bucket at rest, it's obvious that the fluid has no angular momentum, but considering the fact there is no friction between the bucket and the fluid, how does the superfluid get the angular momentum needed to produce vortex lines?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I may be missing something, but since when has the presence of friction been necessary for angular momentum to be present in a body, even one composed of a superfluid?
 
  • #3
He's asking how does spinning the bucket impart angular momentum to the fluid. If you spin a bucket containing water it is the prescence of viscous /frictional forces that result in the water gaining angular momentum. Is there an analogous situation between the events in the water filled bucket and the superfluid filled bucket?
 
  • #4
The superfluid consists of a superfluid component as well as a normal component. The normal component starts to rotate because it has nonzero viscocity and nonzero friction against the bucket wall. Then the interaction between the normal component and the superfluid component causes the vortices to appear.
 
  • #5
I'm an undergrad in physics so don't think I'm a surprised expert. Could you show me the evidence for this phenomenon? It seems pretty interesting...
 
  • #6
When you calculate the circulation of the momentum around a closed loop, you can show that it is equal to the variation of the phase of the wave function along the loop. Moreover, only the coherent part of the fluid can contribute to this circulation. Since the loop is closed, this implies that this variation is a multiple of 2π. As a result, the circulation of the coherent part of the fluid is quantized. This is by definition the superfluid. The superfluid can totally decouple from the normal fluid.

Find more details about this in this preprint,

http://arxiv.org/abs/1403.5472

Or if you have access to APS journals, the published version of this article is Phys. Rev. B 90, 134503 (2014).

http://journals.aps.org/prb/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevB.90.134503
 
  • Like
Likes Greg Bernhardt

Related to Why does superfluid helium in a spinning bucket have angular momentum?

1. Why does superfluid helium have angular momentum in a spinning bucket?

Superfluid helium is a unique state of matter in which the atoms are able to flow without any resistance. This flow is caused by the particles forming a quantum-mechanical state known as Bose-Einstein condensate, which gives them the ability to behave as a single entity. When the bucket is spun, the superfluid helium responds by forming a vortex, which is a rotating column of atoms. This vortex has angular momentum, as it is rotating around a central axis, similar to a spinning top.

2. How does the angular momentum of superfluid helium differ from that of a regular fluid?

In a regular fluid, such as water, the molecules are constantly colliding with each other, causing resistance and dissipating energy. This means that when the bucket is spun, the water will eventually come to rest and the angular momentum will be lost. However, in superfluid helium, there is no resistance, so the angular momentum can be maintained for much longer periods of time.

3. What is the significance of superfluid helium having angular momentum?

The fact that superfluid helium can maintain angular momentum for extended periods of time makes it a valuable tool for studying quantum mechanics. It allows scientists to observe the effects of quantum mechanics on a macroscopic scale, which is not possible with regular fluids. Additionally, the behavior of superfluid helium can also offer insights into other phenomena, such as superconductivity.

4. Can the angular momentum of superfluid helium be controlled?

Yes, the angular momentum of superfluid helium can be controlled by changing the rotational speed of the bucket. As the speed increases, more vortices will form, and the angular momentum will also increase. Conversely, decreasing the rotational speed will cause the vortices to dissipate, reducing the angular momentum.

5. How does the temperature of superfluid helium affect its angular momentum?

The temperature of superfluid helium does not have a significant impact on its angular momentum. As long as the temperature is below the critical temperature of 2.17 Kelvin, where superfluidity occurs, the helium will exhibit the same behavior and maintain its angular momentum. However, at temperatures above the critical temperature, the helium will transition into a regular fluid and the angular momentum will dissipate.

Similar threads

  • Mechanics
Replies
15
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
999
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Mechanics
Replies
11
Views
3K
Back
Top