When to use P=I^2R, P=VI, P=V^2/R?

  • Thread starter FaroukYasser
  • Start date
In summary, the three variables are convenient to measure and there are many ways to calculate the third depending on what you want to do with it.
  • #1
FaroukYasser
62
3
When to use P=I^2R, P=VI, P=V^2/R??

Hi,
I know that P = I^2R is to find heat loss. but can we use P = V^2/R or P = IV to find the heat loss? simply when do we use which?? (or can we use all anytime?)

The question said to find 1) the power GENERATED by a dc voltage source and to find the 2) Power dissipated in the power source
Should I multiply the voltage difference of the voltage source by the current passing through it to get the power generated and multiply current squared by its internal resistance to get the heat dissipated through it?
Thanks a lot :))
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
FaroukYasser said:
Hi,
I know that P = I^2R is to find heat loss. but can we use P = V^2/R or P = IV to find the heat loss? simply when do we use which?? (or can we use all anytime?)
##P=\frac{V^2}{R}## is derived from ##V=IR## and ##P=IV##
You get ##P=\frac{V^2}{R}## because ##P=IV=\frac{V}{R}V##

I solved the equation ##V=IR## for ##I## and plugged it into that Power equation ##P=IV##
Do the same for ##P=I^2R##

For the first equation if you don't know V , find it.Then you can use P=IV.
You can do the same for the second equation too.
You can use anyone of these anytime.

FaroukYasser said:
The question said to find 1) the power GENERATED by a dc voltage source and to find the 2) Power dissipated in the power source
Should I multiply the voltage difference of the voltage source by the current passing through it to get the power generated and multiply current squared by its internal resistance to get the heat dissipated through it?
Thanks a lot :))
Yes you are correct.
Note that heat is not the same thing as power.
 
  • #3
adjacent said:
For the first equation if you don't know V , find it.Then you can use P=IV.
You can do the same for the second equation too.
You can use anyone of these anytime.
I don't understand this part :)) would you be kind enough to elaborate? Thanks for the reply :))
 
  • #4
FaroukYasser said:
I don't understand this part :)) would you be kind enough to elaborate? Thanks for the reply :))

The first equation in your first post is this:##P=I^2R##
Here you have no variable for ##V##.
So you can use ##V=IR## and plug in I and R from the first equation to it and find V.
Then you can use ##P=IV##.

This is the same as using ##P=I^2R## as I mentioned in my previous post.

Then you have ##P=\frac{V^2}{R}##
There you can again use ##V=IR## to find the current and then you can use ##P=IV##
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #5
adjacent said:
The first equation in your first post is this:##P=I^2R##
Here you have no variable for ##V##.
So you can use ##V=IR## and plug in I and R from the first equation to it and find V.
Then you can use ##P=IV##.

This is the same as using ##P=I^2R## as I mentioned in my previous post.

Then you have ##P=\frac{V^2}{R}##
There you can again use ##V=IR## to find the current and then you can use ##P=IV##
Ohhhhhhhhh So I guess it is kind of related to each others, You just sort of save a step in the middle :)) Thanks a TON :)))
 
  • #6
Yes they are interdependent. Functionally, it matters a great deal in understanding and measuring what occurs in a system, since it may be considerably easier to get 2 functions but difficult to get the third. For example, because voltage is a differential it is very easy to measure that difference from one part of a system to another. Resistance is a little bit harder since some circuits create an effective resistance because of interaction. In AC circuits or some pulsed DC circuits, we must add impedance, frequency dependent resistance. Current is theoretically very easy because we can insert a known small resistance and measure the voltage drop and translate that as current flow. It is harder to measure directly. Also some circuits are difficult or even dangerous to interrupt to insert any metering.

So, ultimately it means in real life, that you measure any 2 that's convenient and accurate to measure, and you can derive the third and calculate any expression of it you need.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person

Related to When to use P=I^2R, P=VI, P=V^2/R?

1. When should I use the formula P=I^2R?

The formula P=I^2R should be used when you know the current (I) and resistance (R) in a circuit and want to calculate the power (P) dissipated in that circuit. This formula is commonly used in Ohm's Law calculations.

2. In what situations would I use the formula P=VI?

The formula P=VI should be used when you know the voltage (V) and current (I) in a circuit and want to calculate the power (P) dissipated in that circuit. This formula is commonly used in calculating the power supplied by a voltage source in a circuit.

3. When is it appropriate to use the formula P=V^2/R?

The formula P=V^2/R should be used when you know the voltage (V) and resistance (R) in a circuit and want to calculate the power (P) dissipated in that circuit. This formula is commonly used in calculating the power dissipated in a resistor in a circuit.

4. Can I use any of these formulas interchangeably?

No, these formulas are specific to different situations and should not be used interchangeably. P=I^2R is used when calculating power in a circuit with known current and resistance, while P=VI is used for calculating power in a circuit with known voltage and current. P=V^2/R is used for calculating power in a circuit with known voltage and resistance.

5. Are there any limitations to these power formulas?

These power formulas are based on ideal conditions and do not take into account factors such as non-linear components, temperature, and other external factors. Therefore, they may not always provide accurate results in real-world situations. Additionally, these formulas assume DC circuits and may not be applicable to AC circuits.

Similar threads

  • Classical Physics
Replies
15
Views
760
  • Classical Physics
2
Replies
41
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
666
  • Classical Physics
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
667
Replies
18
Views
1K
Replies
27
Views
2K
Replies
21
Views
1K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
0
Views
313
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
842
Back
Top