- #1
- 6,724
- 429
I came across this very interesting podcast interview with Robert Paxton on the parallels and non-parallels between Donald Trump and 20s/30s fascism. This is a topic on which we've had some previous discussion here. Paxton was a historian of fascism at Columbia, is now emeritus. The following notes are an outline of what Paxton said.
parallels
portrays US as in decline, needs strong leader
revival of the nation
nationalism
aggressive foreign policy
attack on enemies inside and out without regard to due process; obsession with enemies such as jews
faltering liberal order
depersonalize and attach negative images
prescribe measures that are brutal and illegal
fascism doesn't fit on left-right spectrum;
non-parallels
Trump is impulsive, aggressive personality; opportunist; not as politically aware as Hitler and Mussolini
better examples of US fascism: Huey Long, George Lincoln Rockwell, Father Coughlan
30s fascism had strong state, uniforms, fascist salute
followers would reject "fascism;" it's the worst epithet we can think of; so stop retweeting Mussolini
relationship to Republican establishment
parties traditionally had patronage, could choose candidates; this changed in 1960s with caucuses and primaries
if Rep establishment find they're wrong, and Trump is a viable candidate, they'll flock to him
parallels
portrays US as in decline, needs strong leader
revival of the nation
nationalism
aggressive foreign policy
attack on enemies inside and out without regard to due process; obsession with enemies such as jews
faltering liberal order
US: 2 unnecessary wars, severe econ recession
unease at black man in white house
blaming troubles on internal and external enemiesunease at black man in white house
depersonalize and attach negative images
prescribe measures that are brutal and illegal
fascism doesn't fit on left-right spectrum;
Germany: 1932: nationalist party and communist party;
Hitler offered a new way
fascism isn't about truthHitler offered a new way
is about mystical union with historic destiny of his people
it's not about substance, it's about style
Hitler radiated force -- visceral appeal based on style and image; "I'll fix it"
it's not about substance, it's about style
Hitler radiated force -- visceral appeal based on style and image; "I'll fix it"
non-parallels
Trump is impulsive, aggressive personality; opportunist; not as politically aware as Hitler and Mussolini
better examples of US fascism: Huey Long, George Lincoln Rockwell, Father Coughlan
30s fascism had strong state, uniforms, fascist salute
followers would reject "fascism;" it's the worst epithet we can think of; so stop retweeting Mussolini
relationship to Republican establishment
parties traditionally had patronage, could choose candidates; this changed in 1960s with caucuses and primaries
if Rep establishment find they're wrong, and Trump is a viable candidate, they'll flock to him