- #1
rhody
Gold Member
- 681
- 3
In the course of reading the "Quark and the Jaguar", http://www.osti.gov/accomplishments/gellmann.html" relates a moment of insight that applies not only to elementary particle physicists, but to artists, musicians and all creative people. In attempting to explain the behavior of new "strange particles", produced in great numbers as though strongly interacting, yet decaying slowly as though weekly interacting, conventional wisdom at the time said the fermions should have fractional spin angular momentum values, like 1/2, 3/2, etc... while bosonic strongly interacting particles should have whole integer spin values.
In a speech given at the Institute of Advanced Study at Princeton, excerpt from page 263, Gell-Mann writes, "By a slip of the tongue I said "I=1" instead of "I=5/2". Immediately I stopped dead, realizing the I=1 would do the job. Electromagnetism could not change I=1 into I=3/2, or 1/2, and so the behavior of the strange particles could now be explained by means of conservation of I".
He realized the alleged rule that fermionic strongly interacting states was a superstition, an unnecessary baggage that came with the concept of isotropic spin I. Isotropic spin now has a wider application than was thought possible at the time.
Gell-Mann credits the insight to three stages of problem solving:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hermann_von_Helmholtz" , a noteworthy german physician and physicist, who classified this activity over a century earlier.
The last stage, Verification, is credited to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henri_Poincar%C3%A9" ", by Morton Hunt.
There is some disagreement about what actually happens at the "moment of illumination", Gell-Mann is inclined to believe that somehow the "preconscious mind" just outside awareness is responsible. However, some psychologists believe that real creative thinking occurs just before the moment of insight.
Now to the heart of this thread:
At what moment do you remember an insight or important breakthrough in trying to solve a difficult problem ?
Was your experience similar to what Gell-Mann presents, or different, and if different, how so ?
Finally, what was the time period after stages 1 and 2 where the important insight suddenly came, hours, days, months, weeks, years ?
Rhody...
Below are other links to Gell-Mann's contributions that may be useful.
These can be found by using the Gell-Mann's link at the top of the page as well.
BTW... Merry Christmas...
http://www.osti.gov/accomplishments/gellmann.html"
http://prola.aps.org/abstract/PR/v125/i3/p1067_1?qid=cb679a695b397b47&qseq=25&show=30"
http://www.osti.gov/cgi-bin/rd_accomplishments/display_biblio.cgi?id=ACC0114&numPages=10&fp=N"
In a speech given at the Institute of Advanced Study at Princeton, excerpt from page 263, Gell-Mann writes, "By a slip of the tongue I said "I=1" instead of "I=5/2". Immediately I stopped dead, realizing the I=1 would do the job. Electromagnetism could not change I=1 into I=3/2, or 1/2, and so the behavior of the strange particles could now be explained by means of conservation of I".
He realized the alleged rule that fermionic strongly interacting states was a superstition, an unnecessary baggage that came with the concept of isotropic spin I. Isotropic spin now has a wider application than was thought possible at the time.
Gell-Mann credits the insight to three stages of problem solving:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hermann_von_Helmholtz" , a noteworthy german physician and physicist, who classified this activity over a century earlier.
The last stage, Verification, is credited to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henri_Poincar%C3%A9" ", by Morton Hunt.
Saturation Period: Extended period where one confronts/examines/studies sources needed to solve a problem.
Incubation Period: Period of time when further conscious thought is useless, but you continue to carry the problem around with you.
Moment of Illumination: Suddenly, when not engaged in thinking about the problem, a crucial idea or insight comes.
Verification: Documenting or proving the solution to the problem.
There is some disagreement about what actually happens at the "moment of illumination", Gell-Mann is inclined to believe that somehow the "preconscious mind" just outside awareness is responsible. However, some psychologists believe that real creative thinking occurs just before the moment of insight.
Now to the heart of this thread:
At what moment do you remember an insight or important breakthrough in trying to solve a difficult problem ?
Was your experience similar to what Gell-Mann presents, or different, and if different, how so ?
Finally, what was the time period after stages 1 and 2 where the important insight suddenly came, hours, days, months, weeks, years ?
Rhody...
Below are other links to Gell-Mann's contributions that may be useful.
These can be found by using the Gell-Mann's link at the top of the page as well.
BTW... Merry Christmas...
http://www.osti.gov/accomplishments/gellmann.html"
http://prola.aps.org/abstract/PR/v125/i3/p1067_1?qid=cb679a695b397b47&qseq=25&show=30"
http://www.osti.gov/cgi-bin/rd_accomplishments/display_biblio.cgi?id=ACC0114&numPages=10&fp=N"
Last edited by a moderator: