Is there a fundamental connection between energy, momentum, and mass in physics?

In summary: There is thus a sense in which mass-energy and momentum are sort of "opposite sides of the same coin".In summary, mass-energy equivalence is fundamental in relativity and energy and momentum are different aspects of the same thing. They each have important conservation laws and in special relativity, the space coordinates of the four-momentum give the momentum while the time coordinate gives energy. In quantum mechanics, momentum and energy are operators and can be expressed as P=h/wavelength and E=h/period. This suggests that momentum is to space as (mass-) energy is to time. The symmetry between mass-energy and momentum is due to the Lorentz transform and the principle of "least action" in physics. This also explains why p=
  • #1
StatusX
Homework Helper
2,570
2
Mass-energy equivalence is fundamental in relativity, but it seems like energy and momentum are also different aspects of the same thing. They've each got very important conservation laws. In SR, the space coordinates of the four-momentum give the momentum while the time coordinate gives energy. In QM, -ih d/dx is the momentum operator, and ih d/dt is the energy operator. P=h/wavelength and E=h/period. It seems that what momentum is to space, (mass-) energy is to time. What is behind this symmetry? Is there a mass-energy-momentum equivalence principal?

Also, I notice that p=mv classically, where v is in units of distance/time. It almost looks like v is a conversion from time units to space units, where mass-energy is the time unit and momentum is the space unit. Is this a valid way of looking at it?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
StatusX said:
Mass-energy equivalence is fundamental in relativity, but it seems like energy and momentum are also different aspects of the same thing. They've each got very important conservation laws. In SR, the space coordinates of the four-momentum give the momentum while the time coordinate gives energy. In QM, -ih d/dx is the momentum operator, and ih d/dt is the energy operator. P=h/wavelength and E=h/period. It seems that what momentum is to space, (mass-) energy is to time. What is behind this symmetry? Is there a mass-energy-momentum equivalence principal?

Also, I notice that p=mv classically, where v is in units of distance/time. It almost looks like v is a conversion from time units to space units, where mass-energy is the time unit and momentum is the space unit. Is this a valid way of looking at it?

You are on the right general track. You might want to look at Wikipedia's article on theorem[/URL]

The derivation of Noether's theorem requires that one use the Lagrangian or Hamiltonian formulation of physics - one way of describing this is that physics is described by the principle of "least action". There is a much more formal definition on the wikipedia web page - it's formal to the point of unintelligibility to the non-Phd, unfortunately.

Anyway, given this basic formulation, one can say that energy conservation is associated with time translation symmetry, and that momentum conservation is associated with space translation symmetry.

Because the Lorentz transform "mixes" time and space together, it also "mixes" momentum and energy together.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #3


I can confirm that there is indeed a fundamental connection between energy, momentum, and mass in physics. This connection is described by the famous equation E=mc^2, which is known as the mass-energy equivalence principle. This principle states that mass and energy are two forms of the same physical quantity and can be converted into one another.

In classical mechanics, momentum is defined as the product of an object's mass and velocity. This is represented by the equation p=mv, where p is momentum, m is mass, and v is velocity. In this context, mass and momentum are two separate quantities, but they are closely related through the object's velocity.

However, in relativity and quantum mechanics, we see that momentum and energy are intimately connected. In special relativity, the four-momentum vector includes both spatial momentum and energy, with the time coordinate representing energy. This symmetry between momentum and energy is also seen in quantum mechanics, where the momentum operator and energy operator are related by the same constant, Planck's constant (h).

The idea of v being a conversion between time and space units is an interesting way of looking at it, but it may not be entirely accurate. Velocity is a fundamental quantity that describes an object's motion in space and time, and it is not necessarily a conversion factor between time and space units. However, the concept of mass-energy and momentum being two different aspects of the same thing is valid and reflects the underlying symmetry in nature.

In conclusion, the fundamental connection between energy, momentum, and mass is a key concept in physics and is described by the mass-energy equivalence principle. This principle highlights the deep connections between seemingly separate physical quantities and helps us understand the underlying symmetries in the universe.
 

Related to Is there a fundamental connection between energy, momentum, and mass in physics?

1. What is energy-momentum symmetry?

Energy-momentum symmetry is a fundamental concept in physics that states that the total energy of a system is conserved, and the total momentum of a system is also conserved. This means that energy can be converted into different forms, but the total amount remains constant, and the same applies to momentum.

2. How is energy-momentum symmetry related to the laws of motion?

The laws of motion, specifically Newton's laws, are based on the principle of energy-momentum symmetry. Newton's first law states that an object at rest will remain at rest unless acted upon by a force, which is essentially a conservation of momentum. Newton's second law involves the conservation of energy, stating that the change in an object's velocity is directly proportional to the force applied to it.

3. Can energy-momentum symmetry be violated?

Energy-momentum symmetry is a fundamental law of physics and has been observed to hold true in all physical systems. However, some theories, such as quantum mechanics, suggest that energy-momentum symmetry may be violated at a very small scale or under extreme conditions, but this has not been confirmed experimentally.

4. How is energy-momentum symmetry applied in practical applications?

Energy-momentum symmetry is applied in various practical applications, such as in the design of engines and motors, which convert energy into mechanical work. It is also essential in understanding and predicting the motion and behavior of objects in fields such as astrophysics and particle physics.

5. What is the relationship between energy-momentum symmetry and the conservation of mass?

Energy-momentum symmetry is closely related to the conservation of mass. In classical physics, mass is considered to be a measure of an object's energy, and the two are interchangeable according to Einstein's famous equation, E=mc². This means that the conservation of mass is a direct consequence of energy-momentum symmetry.

Similar threads

  • Mechanics
2
Replies
43
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
816
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
990
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
21
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
842
  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
7
Views
969
Replies
5
Views
1K
Back
Top