How throttling is a steady flow process?

In summary: Then the mass flow rate upstream and downstream of the valve should be constant.Yes but for a set valve position, mass flow doesn't change between the upstream and downstream side of the valve, yet it has still reduced the maximum flow rate that the system can attain. If you change the valve position while it is running there will be a brief transient period but then it settles into a steady state with lower mass flow.Yes but for a set valve position, mass flow doesn't change between the upstream and downstream side of the valve, yet it has still reduced the maximum flow rate that the system can attain. If you change the valve position while it is running there will be a brief transient period but then it settles into a steady state with lower mass flow
  • #1
Signature
19
0
If throttling reduces mass flow rate then how can we say it as steady flow process where the mass flow rate is constant?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
It doesn't reduce mass flow rate (at least not dynamically). It may limit the mass flow rate so that for a fixed throttling valve position, you have less mass flow than for a different, more open position, but mass flow doesn't change for a fixed valve position.
 
  • #3
Let's take a pump which is pumping water. In the discharge side there is a flow control valve(throttling) so that it reduces the flow rate. Since water is a incompressible substance if the volume flow rate gets reduced then mass flow rate will also reduce.

But for a steady flow process, the mass flow rate upstream and downstream of the valve should be constant.
 
  • #4
Yes but for a set valve position, mass flow doesn't change between the upstream and downstream side of the valve, yet it has still reduced the maximum flow rate that the system can attain. If you change the valve position while it is running there will be a brief transient period but then it settles into a steady state with lower mass flow.
 
  • #5
If the mass flow rate was higher before the valve than if was after the valve then mass would accumulate in the valve!
 
  • #6
boneh3ad said:
Yes but for a set valve position, mass flow doesn't change between the upstream and downstream side of the valve, yet it has still reduced the maximum flow rate that the system can attain. If you change the valve position while it is running there will be a brief transient period but then it settles into a steady state with lower mass flow.

If my pump's rated capacity is 100 Cu.m/hr and i adjusted the valve position to get only 50 Cu.m/hr. How the pump's capacity will reduce according to the valve position?
 
  • #7
Signature said:
If my pump's rated capacity is 100 Cu.m/hr and i adjusted the valve position to get only 50 Cu.m/hr. How the pump's capacity will reduce according to the valve position?
What kind of pump is it?
 
  • #8
Chestermiller said:
What kind of pump is it?
Just for example I quoted, Centrifugal
 
  • #9
CWatters said:
If the mass flow rate was higher before the valve than if was after the valve then mass would accumulate in the valve!
I couldn't get your point. How mass would accumulate in valve?
 
  • #10
Signature said:
I couldn't get your point. How mass would accumulate in valve?
(Rate of Flow in) - (Rate of Flow out) = (Rate of Accumulation). According to what you have been saying, this has to be what is happening in the valve.
 
  • #11
Chestermiller said:
(Rate of Flow in) - (Rate of Flow out) = (Rate of Accumulation). According to what you have been saying, this has to be what is happening in the valve.

So in a pipeline if there is a flow rate of 50 Cu.m/hr upstream of the valve and 40 Cu.m/hr flow rate downstream of the valve (incompressible fluid), then the fluid entering the valve is only 40 Cu.m/hr. Is that right?
 
  • #12
Chestermiller said:
(Rate of Flow in) - (Rate of Flow out) = (Rate of Accumulation). According to what you have been saying, this has to be what is happening in the valve.
But in steady flow process Mass flow rate in and out should be equal. So there won't be any mass accumulation in valve, but may be in pipeline upstream of the valve
 
  • #13
Signature said:
If my pump's rated capacity is 100 Cu.m/hr and i adjusted the valve position to get only 50 Cu.m/hr. How the pump's capacity will reduce according to the valve position?

This is the equivalent of an irresistible force applied to an immovable object. They both cannot "win".

Either

a) The valve wins, restricting the flow to 50. eg by causing an increase in back pressure that slows down the pump.
or
b) The pump wins and delivers 100. The valve is unable to restrict the flow.
or
c) Something in between a and b. For example the valve partially manages to slow the pump and you get somewhere between 50 and 100.
 
  • #14
Signature said:
I couldn't get your point. How mass would accumulate in valve?

My point was it cannot accumulate in the valve - so the mass flow rate MUST be the same through the pump and the valve.

The only way it could be different is if the valve was a three port device that diverted 50 to one port and 50 to another (or 60/40 etc) making 100 in total.
 
  • #15
Signature said:
So in a pipeline if there is a flow rate of 50 Cu.m/hr upstream of the valve and 40 Cu.m/hr flow rate downstream of the valve (incompressible fluid), then the fluid entering the valve is only 40 Cu.m/hr. Is that right?

No. That would imply 10 vanished somewhere. It's not possible to have 50 going into the valve and 40 coming out. That would imply 10 Cu.m/hr is accumulating in the valve which isn't possible. If it was a three port valve then you could have..

50 going into port 1
40 leaving port 2
10 leaving port 3
 
Last edited:
  • #16
You stated that the pump had a "capacity of 100 Cu.m/hr" however that is insufficient to fully specify the pump. Real world pumps will only deliver 100 Cu.m/hr with a certain head/pressure. If the pressure downstream is increased (by restricting the flow with a valve) then the pump will deliver less than 100 Cu.m/hr.

If I remember correctly you can work out what will actually happen by plotting separate pressure vs flow rate curves for both the pump and the valve on the same graph. Where the two lines cross is your answer for both.
 
  • #17
CWatters said:
This is the equivalent of an irresistible force applied to an immovable object. They both cannot "win".

Either

a) The valve wins, restricting the flow to 50. eg by causing an increase in back pressure that slows down the pump.
or
b) The pump wins and delivers 100. The valve is unable to restrict the flow.
or
c) Something in between a and b. For example the valve partially manages to slow the pump and you get somewhere between 50 and 100.
Thanks a lot...
 

Related to How throttling is a steady flow process?

1. What is throttling?

Throttling is a process in which the flow rate of a fluid is controlled by restricting its cross-sectional area. This results in a decrease in the fluid's velocity and an increase in its pressure.

2. How does throttling affect the flow of a fluid?

Throttling causes a decrease in the velocity of the fluid, which leads to an increase in its pressure. This is due to the conservation of mass and energy principles, where the decrease in velocity results in an increase in pressure.

3. Is throttling a steady flow process?

Yes, throttling is considered a steady flow process because the flow rate remains constant throughout the process. This means that the fluid properties, such as velocity and pressure, do not change with time.

4. What factors affect throttling?

The main factor that affects throttling is the size of the restriction or valve used to control the flow rate. Other factors that may affect throttling include the properties of the fluid, such as density and viscosity, and the initial pressure and temperature of the fluid.

5. What are the applications of throttling in science and engineering?

Throttling is commonly used in various engineering and scientific applications, such as in engines to control the flow of fuel, in refrigeration systems to regulate the flow of refrigerant, and in industrial processes to control the flow of fluids. It is also used in hydraulic systems, turbines, and many other devices that require precise control of fluid flow.

Similar threads

  • Thermodynamics
Replies
2
Views
922
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
2
Replies
38
Views
740
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
883
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
27
Views
3K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
31
Views
2K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
9
Views
297
Back
Top