Why Does a Nickel Transfer Kinetic Energy Differently to a Penny Than to a Wall?

  • Thread starter jakeddong
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Force
In summary, force is conserved and transferred in collisions, but external forces can change the outcome. Force is not measured in N/s, but rather in N or N.s. Applying a constant force for a certain amount of time can provide an object with enough momentum or energy to break it, but the force itself does not break the object.
  • #1
jakeddong
2
0
Hi, so I am currently learning about force in my physics class in high school. I get the calculation part but I'm really confused about the whole concept.

For example: when a nickel slides on a flat surface of glass and hits a penny, the nickel stops and the penny shoots off. The nickel receives the same force it hit the penny with(normal force) and therefore cancels out its motion, proving Newton's Third Law of motion.
But when a sliding nickel hits a nonmovable object such as a wall, it bounces off. Why is it that normal force of nickel does not cancel out its motion in this case? To say more specifically, why did nickel transfer all of its kinetic energy to the penny, but not to the wall?

Another problem.
I learned that force is something that accumulates, meaning that if an object requires 100N of instantaneous force to push it across the ground at a constant speed, then when you apply a constant force 20N/s for 5 seconds, the object moves. Right? So if force accumulates over time, then does that mean everything is technically "breaking"
For example: if a chair is placed in a room of vacuum where the only force exerting on it is the normal force from the gravity. Then, would it break eventually in billions of years because of that constant normal force acting on it?

These are not homework problems, I came up with these scenarios and could not answer why they happen the way they do. So if you could please help answer these I'd really appreciate it. Thank you!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
welcome to pf!

hi jakeddong! welcome to pf! :smile:
jakeddong said:
… when a nickel slides on a flat surface of glass and hits a penny, the nickel stops and the penny shoots off. The nickel receives the same force it hit the penny with(normal force) and therefore cancels out its motion, proving Newton's Third Law of motion.

what it really proves is conservation of https://www.physicsforums.com/library.php?do=view_item&itemid=53"

(btw, the nickel will only stop dead if it has the same mass as the penny)

the momentum lost by the nickel is transferred to the penny

(and we usually talk about normal force only when the surfaces stay in contact … when there's only instantaneous contact, we don't bother with the adjective "normal", and anyway then it's not force but impulse, which is force times time)
But when a sliding nickel hits a nonmovable object such as a wall, it bounces off. Why is it that normal force of nickel does not cancel out its motion in this case?

because conservation of momentum (in a particular direction) only applies when there are no external forces (in that direction: perpendicular external forces such as gravity don't matter) …

in this case, there is an external horizontal force keeping the wall stationary, so all momentum bets are off

only the nickel can move, and since energy is (nearly) conserved, that means it has to bounce off
To say more specifically, why did nickel transfer all of its kinetic energy to the penny, but not to the wall?

basically, because it could!
I learned that force is something that accumulates, meaning that if an object requires 100N of instantaneous force to push it across the ground at a constant speed, then when you apply a constant force 20N/s for 5 seconds, the object moves. Right?

no, force is not N/s, it is always N … you apply 20 N of force for 5 s, and you get an impulse of 100 N.s, because

to get something to move, you have to supply it with momentum, or energy

momentum is force times time, and energy is force times distance …

either way, a force (eg 100 N) cannot be applied instantaneously, it needs to be applied over a time …

force times time is called https://www.physicsforums.com/library.php?do=view_item&itemid=340" (or impulsive force)

impulse is measured in Newton seconds (N.s), not Newtons … in your example, 20 N of force for 5 s is an impulse of 100 N.s, and this is not the same as 100 N
So if force accumulates over time, then does that mean everything is technically "breaking"
For example: if a chair is placed in a room of vacuum where the only force exerting on it is the normal force from the gravity. Then, would it break eventually in billions of years because of that constant normal force acting on it?

no

to take an easier example, if a string will break if you hang a weight of 20 N from it, then it requires a force of 20 N to break it

no time is involved; impulse is irrelevant

10 N for 2s or 2000000 s is still only 10 N … it won't break :wink:
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Related to Why Does a Nickel Transfer Kinetic Energy Differently to a Penny Than to a Wall?

1. What is force?

Force is a quantitative measure of the interaction between two objects. It is a vector quantity that describes the influence of an object on the motion or shape of another object.

2. How is force measured?

Force is measured in Newtons (N) using a device called a force meter or a spring scale. One Newton is equivalent to the force required to accelerate a mass of one kilogram at a rate of one meter per second squared.

3. What are the different types of forces?

There are four main types of forces: gravitational force, electromagnetic force, strong nuclear force, and weak nuclear force. These forces govern the interactions between particles, objects, and systems in the universe.

4. How does force affect motion?

Force can cause a stationary object to start moving, or it can change the speed or direction of a moving object. According to Newton's first law of motion, an object will remain at rest or continue moving in a straight line at a constant speed unless acted upon by a net force.

5. Can force be negative?

Yes, force can be negative. A negative force means that the object is being pushed or pulled in the opposite direction of a positive force. For example, when a person pulls a book with a force of 10N and another person pushes the book with a force of -5N, the net force on the book would be 5N in the direction of the person pulling the book.

Similar threads

Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
930
Replies
5
Views
777
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
986
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
867
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
32
Views
8K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
652
Back
Top