What is the work done to move this Charge?

In summary, the conversation discusses two formulas for calculating the work done in moving a charge from point A to point B in an electric field. The first formula involves a path integral and the second formula involves a change in potential energy. The distances r_A and r_B can be found by using the length of the vectors OA and OB, respectively. It is noted that following an equipotential line (such as the path CB) requires no work to be done. The conversation also addresses the importance of getting the correct sign for the work and offers support for the individual's limited knowledge in physics.
  • #1
Reneee
4
2
Homework Statement
A charge Q in point O=(0,0) and a test charge q in point A=(4,1) lie in a plane.
How much work W needs to be done to move q to point B=(2,2).
Q always stays at (0,0).
Q=q= 2*10^-4. One unit here equals 1 meter.
Relevant Equations
no equations.
phis1.png


I found two formulas to calculate the work done. One is with this path integral:
## W_{AB}## = W(## r_A,r_B ##)=q* ## \int_{r_A}^{r_B} E*dr ##
but here is the one I tried to use:
## W_{AB}## = q*Δ U = q*(## \frac {kQ} {r_A} ## - ## \frac {kQ} {r_B} ## )
Now here's my problem, what are the distances## r_A ##and ##r_B ## that i have to plug in?
Can I just use: the length ##r_A ##=## | \vec {OA} |## = ## \sqrt 17## ## r_B ## = ##| \vec {OB} | ## = ##\sqrt 8 ##.

Or do I have to do something else, like do I maybe need to follow the equipotential lines(please say no x) ) like this?:
phis2.png

If so ,then how can I put this into mathematics, especially the path ##\vec {BC}##, so I can use it in one of the equations?

~note: for all intents and purposes I didn't knew anything about physics until last week ,when we covered physics for 2 lessons in my cs-course, please excuse me if i am missing some of the very basics.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Reneee said:
I found two formulas to calculate the work done. One is with this path integral:
## W_{AB}## = W(## r_A,r_B ##)=q* ## \int_{r_A}^{r_B} E*dr ##
but here is the one I tried to use:
## W_{AB}## = q*Δ U = q*(## \frac {kQ} {r_A} ## - ## \frac {kQ} {r_B} ## )
The second formula comes from the first formula after evaluating the integral. You can just use the second formula. However, the formula gives the work done by the electric force acting on q as the charge is moved from A to B. You are asked to find the work that "needs to be done" to move the charge from A to B. That is, how much work is done by your force if you move the charge from A to B? Can you see how the works done by these two different forces are related to one another?

Now here's my problem, what are the distances## r_A ##and ##r_B ## that i have to plug in?
Can I just use: the length ##r_A ##=## | \vec {OA} |## = ## \sqrt 17## ## r_B ## = ##| \vec {OB} | ## = ##\sqrt 8 ##.
Yes, just use these values for ##r_A## and ##r_B##. These are the initial and final distances between the two charges. The work is independent of the particular path, so you don't need to pick a path. (That's an important thing to keep in mind.) The work depends only on the initial and final positions, as indicated by the formula for ##W_{AB}## where you only need to know the initial and final ##r##'s.
 
  • Like
Likes Reneee
  • #3
Reneee said:
I found two formulas to calculate the work done. One is with this path integral:
## W_{AB}## = W(## r_A,r_B ##)=q* ## \int_{r_A}^{r_B} E*dr ##
but here is the one I tried to use:
## W_{AB}## = q*Δ U = q*(## \frac {kQ} {r_A} ## - ## \frac {kQ} {r_B} ## )
Now here's my problem, what are the distances## r_A ##and ##r_B ## that i have to plug in?
Can I just use: the length ##r_A ##=## | \vec {OA} |## = ## \sqrt 17## ## r_B ## = ##| \vec {OB} | ## = ##\sqrt 8 ##.
Yes you can!
Or do I have to do something else, like do I maybe need to follow the equipotential lines(please say no x) ) like this?:
View attachment 255607
If so ,then how can I put this into mathematics, especially the path ##\vec {BC}##, so I can use it in one of the equations?
Note that moving a charge along an equipotential line requires no work. So the path CB requires no work to be done. You just have to get the particle from A to C, which just happens to be the change in radial distance (from Q) from A to that equipotential surface. So that's just moving from ##r_A## to ##r_B##.

Make sure that you get the correct sign for the work. Since both charges have the same sign, moving q closer to Q will require positive work.
~note: for all intents and purposes I didn't knew anything about physics until last week ,when we covered physics for 2 lessons in my cs-course, please excuse me if i am missing some of the very basics.
No worries there. We're here to help you. While we won't teach you an entire introductory physics course, we can help to point out misconceptions, spot errors, fill in the gaps in your understanding and so forth. Good luck!

Edit: Ha! TSny beat me to it!
 
  • Like
Likes Reneee
  • #4
ah thanks guys I did it with point c and just like you said I got the same solution ,√8.
 

Related to What is the work done to move this Charge?

1. How is the work done to move a charge calculated?

The work done to move a charge is calculated by multiplying the magnitude of the charge by the potential difference it moves through. This is represented by the equation W = qV, where W is the work done, q is the charge, and V is the potential difference.

2. What is the unit of measurement for work done on a charge?

The unit of measurement for work done on a charge is joules (J). This is the same unit used for other forms of energy, such as kinetic energy and potential energy.

3. Does the direction of the charge's movement affect the work done?

Yes, the direction of the charge's movement does affect the work done. If the charge is moving in the same direction as the potential difference, positive work is done. If the charge is moving in the opposite direction, negative work is done.

4. How does the distance traveled by the charge affect the work done?

The distance traveled by the charge affects the work done because the potential difference is directly proportional to the distance. This means that the longer the distance traveled, the greater the potential difference and therefore, the greater the work done.

5. Is the work done to move a charge affected by the presence of other charges?

Yes, the work done to move a charge can be affected by the presence of other charges. This is because the electric field created by other charges can influence the movement of the charge and therefore, the work done on it.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
28
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
718
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
3
Replies
94
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
656
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
1K
Back
Top