Wavefunction Collapse: Measuring Electron Spin

In summary, the conversation discusses whether measuring an electron's spin will also cause the collapse of its position wavefunction. It is stated that measuring spin does not necessarily collapse the position wavefunction, but any realistic measurement will likely collapse it. The specific setup, such as the Stern-Gerlach device, can also impact the collapse of the position wavefunction. There have been theoretical arguments and experiments done to test this concept, including experiments with entangled pairs and Young's double slit experiment with a polarizer. Overall, the correlation between spin collapse and position collapse is complex and depends on the specific setups and measurements.
  • #1
dEdt
288
2
If you were to measure an electron's spin, for example, will the wavefunction associated with its position also collapse?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Those two ('measurement' and 'collapse') are virtually synonyms.
 
  • #3
dEdt said:
If you were to measure an electron's spin, for example, will the wavefunction associated with its position also collapse?

That is not a requirement of a measurement (or collapse). In other words, measuring one does not collapse all.
 
  • #4
You have to be more specific. If your measurement is equivalent to spin operator, it does not collapse the spatial components of the wave function. But any realistic measurement will probably collapse the spatial wave function to something. Really, it depends on how you measure the spin in the first place. Stern–Gerlach, for example, obviously collapses the spatial wave function as well as the spin wave function.
 
  • #5
K^2 said:
You have to be more specific. If your measurement is equivalent to spin operator, it does not collapse the spatial components of the wave function. But any realistic measurement will probably collapse the spatial wave function to something. Really, it depends on how you measure the spin in the first place. Stern–Gerlach, for example, obviously collapses the spatial wave function as well as the spin wave function.

I would not have thought an S-G outcome would contain much position information.
 
  • #6
DrChinese said:
I would not have thought an S-G outcome would contain much position information.

I think an S-G device also gives an indication of what path the object took inside the device itself. Wouldn't that collapse the wavefunction?

At any rate, have there been any experiments done to check that say spin collapse doesn't cause position collapse? Or is this based on theoretical arguments?
 
  • #7
dEdt said:
I think an S-G device also gives an indication of what path the object took inside the device itself. Wouldn't that collapse the wavefunction?

At any rate, have there been any experiments done to check that say spin collapse doesn't cause position collapse? Or is this based on theoretical arguments?

As K^2 says, it depends on the specific setups. Mostly this is based on theoretical considerations as it is quite difficult to actually test. However, there have been actual experiments done on entangled pairs which show that entanglement on one basis can survive collapse on another.

http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0406148

Abstract: "We report on the the experimental realization of hyper-entangled two photon states, entangled in polarization and momentum."
 
  • #8
dEdt said:
At any rate, have there been any experiments done to check that say spin collapse doesn't cause position collapse?
You can make it yourself. Prepare Young's double slit experiment putting polariser at slits (the same polarisation in both of them). Spin gets collapsed, but you still see fringe pattern.
 
  • #9
DrChinese said:
I would not have thought an S-G outcome would contain much position information.
You are effectively measuring position and use it to determine the spin. You can't really do that without collapsing the position wave function.
 

Related to Wavefunction Collapse: Measuring Electron Spin

1. What is wavefunction collapse?

Wavefunction collapse is a phenomenon in quantum mechanics where the probability wave associated with a particle's position or properties becomes localized or "collapses" into a single definite value upon measurement or observation.

2. How does wavefunction collapse occur?

Wavefunction collapse occurs when a physical interaction with the particle, such as measurement or observation, causes the superposition of possible states to collapse into a single definite state. This happens due to the nature of quantum mechanics, where particles can exist in multiple states simultaneously until they are observed.

3. What is electron spin?

Electron spin is an intrinsic property of subatomic particles, including electrons, that causes them to behave as if they were spinning on their own axis. This spin can be either "up" or "down" and is a fundamental component of an electron's overall quantum state.

4. How is electron spin measured?

Electron spin can be measured using a variety of methods, including Stern-Gerlach experiments, where a magnetic field is used to deflect the path of electron beams based on their spin orientation. Another common method is electron spin resonance, which uses radio waves to measure the energy difference between the two spin states.

5. How does measuring electron spin result in wavefunction collapse?

When an electron's spin is measured, it causes the superposition of possible spin states to collapse into a single definite state. This is because the act of measurement or observation interacts with the electron and forces it to take on a specific spin orientation, eliminating the possibility of other spin states. This is an example of wavefunction collapse in action.

Similar threads

Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
450
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
2
Views
874
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
44
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
967
Replies
6
Views
798
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
2
Views
446
Back
Top