Uniqueness and origin of physics theorems

In summary, the conversation discusses concerns about the uniqueness of certain physics equations and theorems, particularly in relation to their proofs and assumptions. Two examples are given, one involving the removal of an integral and the other involving the removal of a cross product. The conversation also mentions the potential failure of current theorems if uniqueness is not achieved, and the possibility of deriving Gauss' Law using Maxwell's fourth equation and the continuity equation.
  • #1
simoncks
29
0
After studying some of the proofs of equations, worries arises about their uniqueness.
1.Removal of integral
∫∇.Edτ = ∫(ρ/ε)dτ
→∇.E = Q/ε

2.Removal of (∇X)
∇XE = ∂B/∂t = ∂(∇XA)/∂t
→∇X(E+∂A/∂t)=0
→E+∂A/∂t=-∇V
→E=-∇V-∂A/∂t

Origin -
Certain physics equations/theorems have no (discrete physical/mathematical) proof, or my knowledge is not board enough.
1.F = dp/dt
2.E = F.s
3.Wave-particle duality
4.c (speed of light) is ALWAYS the same for ALL observers

Wouldn't the current theorems fail if the uniqueness fails/assumptions are not correct?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
you can derive gauss law using maxwell fourth eqn and continuity eqn.
c2(∇×B)=j/ε0+∂E/∂t
taking the divergence of it and using ∇.j=-∂ρ/∂t one gets
∇.E=ρ/ε0
 

Related to Uniqueness and origin of physics theorems

1. What makes a physics theorem unique?

A physics theorem is considered unique if it offers a new insight or explanation into a phenomenon, or if it is derived from a novel or previously unexplored approach. The novelty and originality of the theorem are what sets it apart from other existing theorems.

2. How are physics theorems discovered?

Physics theorems are discovered through a combination of experimentation, observation, and mathematical reasoning. Scientists often start with an observation or a problem to be solved, and then use mathematical equations and models to come up with a theorem that can explain the phenomenon or provide a solution.

3. What is the role of mathematics in physics theorems?

Mathematics plays a crucial role in the development of physics theorems. It provides a formal and logical framework for describing and predicting the behavior of physical systems. The use of mathematical equations and models allows scientists to make precise and accurate predictions about the behavior of the physical world.

4. How do physicists determine the origin of a physics theorem?

The origin of a physics theorem can be determined by tracing its development back to its creator or by examining the relevant scientific literature. The first appearance of a theorem in scientific publications or conferences can also provide clues to its origin.

5. Can physics theorems change over time?

Yes, physics theorems can change over time as our understanding of the physical world evolves. New evidence, experimental data, and technological advancements can lead to revisions or modifications of existing theorems. Additionally, as new theories and frameworks are developed, they may challenge or replace previously accepted theorems.

Similar threads

  • Classical Physics
Replies
0
Views
259
  • Classical Physics
Replies
4
Views
749
Replies
1
Views
646
Replies
31
Views
2K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
239
Replies
19
Views
3K
Replies
45
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Differential Equations
Replies
3
Views
2K
Back
Top