Understanding the Path Integral for Photons - Vince's Q&A

In summary, the path integral for photons is a mathematical tool used in quantum field theory to calculate the probability of a photon traveling from one point to another, taking into account all possible paths. It is a comprehensive and intuitive approach that differs from other methods of calculating photon behavior, and it is fundamental for understanding quantum mechanics. The path integral is applied in various areas of physics and has practical applications. Some common misconceptions include thinking it only applies to photons, that the paths represent physical trajectories, and that it provides a complete understanding of quantum mechanics.
  • #1
Pants
7
0
I'm a bit confused about how the path integral for, say, a spin-0 photon is calculated. My understanding of quantum mechanics is somewhere above Feynman's book QED, but somewhere below actually figuring out what every part of the technical definition means. Right now the main sticking point for me is grokking the Hamiltonian, but I don't think I have to figure that out in detail just yet to get the concept.

Anyways, as Feynman describes it in the first chapter of QED, the path integral represents each path that's possible from the source to the detector, and the phase of that path is determined by the energy of the photon and how long it takes to get from source to detector. (Please correct me if I'm misinterpreting this). Here's what I don't get: if the particle is emitted at time 0, and measurement occurs at time T, do we only look at paths that take T seconds to get to the detector traveling at velocity c, or are superluminal paths included in the calculation as well?

Thanks!

-Vince
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2


Dear Vince,

Thank you for your question. Understanding the path integral for a spin-0 photon can be quite tricky, so it's great that you're seeking clarification. Let me break down a few key points that may help you understand the calculation better.

First, you are correct in your understanding that the path integral represents all possible paths that a photon can take from the source to the detector. This includes paths that take T seconds to travel at the speed of light (c), as well as superluminal paths. In fact, the path integral includes all possible paths, regardless of their velocity.

Next, the phase of each path is determined by the energy of the photon and the time it takes to travel along that path. This means that the phase of each path will be different, depending on the energy of the photon and the length of the path. This is where the Hamiltonian comes into play - it is a mathematical operator that represents the total energy of the system, including the energy of the photon.

Now, you may be wondering how we actually calculate the path integral. This is where the technical definition of the Hamiltonian comes into play - it involves a lot of complex mathematical concepts, such as Fourier transforms, Green's functions, and perturbation theory. Without going into too much detail, the basic idea is that we break down the path into small segments and calculate the contribution of each segment to the overall path integral. This is done using the Hamiltonian and other mathematical techniques.

I hope this helps clarify some of your confusion about the path integral for a spin-0 photon. It's a complex topic, so don't be discouraged if you don't fully understand it yet. Keep studying and asking questions, and you'll continue to deepen your understanding. Good luck!
 

Related to Understanding the Path Integral for Photons - Vince's Q&A

What is the path integral for photons?

The path integral for photons is a mathematical tool used in quantum field theory to describe the behavior of photons, which are the particles that make up electromagnetic radiation (such as light). It allows us to calculate the probability of a photon traveling from one point to another in space and time, taking into account all possible paths that the photon could take.

How does the path integral differ from other methods of calculating photon behavior?

The path integral is a more comprehensive and intuitive approach compared to other methods, such as perturbation theory. It takes into account all possible paths of the photon, including those that may seem unlikely or impossible based on classical physics. This allows for a more accurate description of quantum phenomena.

What is the significance of the path integral for understanding quantum mechanics?

The path integral is a fundamental concept in quantum mechanics, as it allows us to understand the probabilistic nature of quantum particles and their behavior. It also helps bridge the gap between classical and quantum mechanics, as it incorporates elements of both theories.

How is the path integral applied in practical situations?

The path integral is used in various areas of physics, such as quantum electrodynamics, quantum field theory, and condensed matter physics. It is also used in practical applications, such as calculating the scattering of particles in accelerators and understanding the behavior of materials at the nanoscale.

What are some common misconceptions about the path integral for photons?

One common misconception is that the path integral only applies to photons, when in fact it can be applied to any quantum particle. Another misconception is that the paths in the path integral represent actual physical trajectories, when in reality they are mathematical tools used to calculate probabilities. Additionally, some people may mistakenly think that the path integral provides a complete understanding of quantum mechanics, when it is just one aspect of the theory.

Similar threads

  • Quantum Physics
Replies
13
Views
808
Replies
3
Views
735
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
18
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
664
Replies
1
Views
648
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
57
Views
3K
Replies
33
Views
3K
Back
Top