- #1
kenn2010
- 3
- 0
twin paradox alone kills special relativity:
the story:
A stays on the planet, B round-travels by spaceship;
when back, based on spectral relativity, B youngs.
analysis:
when special relativity is be applied, the property difference between planet and spaceship is never used; so, first let's simplify the paradox, to avoid confusions to some easily confused minds, that:
A stays in the spaceship 1, B round-travels by spaceship 2;
when back, based on special relativity, B youngs.
Now, the above judgement based on special relativity is made from the standpoint of A & spaceship 1, that B & spaceship 2 experience acceleration & decceleration and so on.
however, if from the standpoint of B, then A & spaceship 1 experience acceleration & decceleration and so on; then, also based on the great theory of einstein's special relativity, we conclude A will be younger.
So...
Based on the same the great theory of einstein's special relativity, we could conclude B to be younger when they meet again, and we can conclude A to be younger when they meet again.
So...
the great theory of einstein's special relativity is fundamentally flawed;
and any theory or theorem or equation building on this foundation, must be re-examinated.
As a matter of fact, borrowing the spirit of "relativity", A and B are completely symmetric,
so...
of course, when back, A and B must be of the same age. any theory predict one of the twin younger than the other must the wrong.
the story:
A stays on the planet, B round-travels by spaceship;
when back, based on spectral relativity, B youngs.
analysis:
when special relativity is be applied, the property difference between planet and spaceship is never used; so, first let's simplify the paradox, to avoid confusions to some easily confused minds, that:
A stays in the spaceship 1, B round-travels by spaceship 2;
when back, based on special relativity, B youngs.
Now, the above judgement based on special relativity is made from the standpoint of A & spaceship 1, that B & spaceship 2 experience acceleration & decceleration and so on.
however, if from the standpoint of B, then A & spaceship 1 experience acceleration & decceleration and so on; then, also based on the great theory of einstein's special relativity, we conclude A will be younger.
So...
Based on the same the great theory of einstein's special relativity, we could conclude B to be younger when they meet again, and we can conclude A to be younger when they meet again.
So...
the great theory of einstein's special relativity is fundamentally flawed;
and any theory or theorem or equation building on this foundation, must be re-examinated.
As a matter of fact, borrowing the spirit of "relativity", A and B are completely symmetric,
so...
of course, when back, A and B must be of the same age. any theory predict one of the twin younger than the other must the wrong.