Trouble with cubical cavity radiation

In summary, the conversation discussed the concept of quantization in quantum physics applied to a cubic cavity. The system of coordinates is aligned with the edges of the box and only x, y, and z components of the radiation need to satisfy the quantization condition. The values of nx, ny, and nz can be any integer, but the equation 2a/λ=√(nx2+ny2+nz2) does not necessarily have to be an integer. Each x, y, z component can have a different n value, allowing for various combinations and restricting the possible direction of propagation.
  • #1
GhostLoveScore
149
9
Hi everyone

I have some trouble understanding quantum physics. Here is a scan from the book from Eisberg and Resnick
Here is how much I understand. This is radiation inside cubical cavity, λx/2 is distance from two nodes of component x of the radiation.
Same goes for y and z components. In the picture they've connected the nodes together to make a plane. I understand that.
Next if you could take a look at the equation below, that I marked in red.
2a/λ should be an integer number, isn't it? If that's so, how can we have nx, ny, nz also integers?What is the reason that we didn't choose 2a/λx, 2a/λy, 2a/λz to be integer value instead of 2a/λ?
240847

240848
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
GhostLoveScore said:
2a/λ should be an integer number, isn't it? If that's so, how can we have nx, ny, nz also integers?
The system of coordinates is aligned with the edges of the box. The fact that it is a cubic box with conducting walls results in a quantisation condition in x, y and z, hence x, ny, and nz are integers. For an arbitrary direction, not all values of 2a/λ are allowed, but 2a/λ is not necessarily an integer.
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71
  • #3
DrClaude said:
The system of coordinates is aligned with the edges of the box. The fact that it is a cubic box with conducting walls results in a quantisation condition in x, y and z, hence x, ny, and nz are integers. For an arbitrary direction, not all values of 2a/λ are allowed, but 2a/λ is not necessarily an integer.

OK, I just want to confirm if I understand this correctly.

For some radiation propagating inside the cavity, only its x, y and z components need to satisfy the requirement

2a/λx=nx
2a/λy=ny
2a/λz=nz

where nx, ny, nz is 1, 2, 3...

and then
2a/λ=√(nx2+ny2+nz2)
doesn't have to be integer?Can each x, y, z component have different n (different wavelength)? Or are nx=ny= nz?
 
  • #4
GhostLoveScore said:
For some radiation propagating inside the cavity, only its x, y and z components need to satisfy the requirement

2a/λx=nx
2a/λy=ny
2a/λz=nz

where nx, ny, nz is 1, 2, 3...

and then
2a/λ=√(nx2+ny2+nz2)
doesn't have to be integer?
Correct.

GhostLoveScore said:
Can each x, y, z component have different n (different wavelength)? Or are nx=ny= nz?
Any combination is allowed. Note that this restricts the possible direction of propagation of the radiation, as the n's also affect the angles.
 
  • Like
Likes GhostLoveScore

Related to Trouble with cubical cavity radiation

What is cubical cavity radiation?

Cubical cavity radiation refers to the emission of electromagnetic radiation from a small, enclosed space, such as a cube-shaped cavity. This phenomenon is a result of the thermal energy of the particles within the cavity, which causes them to emit radiation in the form of photons.

Why is there trouble with cubical cavity radiation?

The trouble with cubical cavity radiation arises from the fact that the theoretical predictions for the amount of radiation emitted from a cubical cavity do not match experimental observations. This discrepancy is known as the "ultraviolet catastrophe" and has been a major problem in the field of thermodynamics.

What causes the ultraviolet catastrophe?

The ultraviolet catastrophe is caused by the assumption that the energy levels of particles within a cavity are continuous, rather than quantized. This leads to a prediction of infinite energy and radiation at high frequencies, which is not observed in reality.

How was the ultraviolet catastrophe resolved?

The ultraviolet catastrophe was resolved by the development of quantum mechanics, which introduced the concept of quantized energy levels. This allowed for a more accurate prediction of the amount of radiation emitted from a cubical cavity and resolved the discrepancy between theory and experiment.

What are the practical applications of studying cubical cavity radiation?

Studying cubical cavity radiation has led to a better understanding of thermodynamics and quantum mechanics, which has numerous practical applications. These include the development of new materials for thermal insulation, advancements in energy production and storage, and the development of new technologies such as lasers and photovoltaic cells.

Similar threads

Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
5K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • Programming and Computer Science
Replies
9
Views
8K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
3K
Back
Top