Speed of photons through dual slit.

In summary: The HUP is not violated, but it is modified by the presence of the slits.In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of using a source that emits a single photon and detecting its movement through a double slit setup. The length of the path taken by the photon can affect its speed and cause interference patterns. However, this only applies to coherent light sources and the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle is still applicable. The analysis provided further explains the role of slits as a position-measuring device and how it affects the probability function.
  • #1
yuiop
3,962
20
Let us say we have source that can emit a single photon. We can in principle detect when the photon leaves the source due to the momentum kick. Now let us say this single photon passes through both slits and forms a dot on the far right of the screen. Now if we draw paths through the two slits, the path going through the left slit to the dot on the screen is longer than the path through the right slit due to simple geometry. If the path through the right slit is consistent with the speed of light, then anything traversing the path from the left slit must be traveling faster than the speed of light to arrive at the same time as the photon that passed through the right slit and constructively interfere with it. Alternatively, if the longer path through the left slit is consistent with the speed of light, then the photon going through the right slit must have been delayed somewhat to arrive at the back screen at the same time as the part that followed the left path. What is though to happen here? Is the answer neither, because quantum particles are not precisely located in space at any given time?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
yuiop said:
Let us say we have source that can emit a single photon. We can in principle detect when the photon leaves the source due to the momentum kick.

For most real light sources you cannot do that. The momentum kick is pretty tiny and might be (depending on the source) so small that it is even unmeasurable in principle due to uncertainty. However, if you manage to realize such a situation, the light emitted is pretty incoherent. As you need light with a coherence volume large enough such that both slits are within it, incoherent light will not show any interference in a double slit setup. This is also the reason, why Young used a single slit in front of the double slit. Sunlight is too incoherent to show interference unless you use slits placed really close to each other. Placing a single slit in front of the double slit increases (spatial) coherence significantly.
 
  • #3
You may enjoy this analysis:

Quantum interference with slits, Thomas V Marcella (2007)

"In the experiments considered here, we measure the y-component of momentum for a particle passing through a system of slits. The source-slit system is the preparation apparatus that determines the state vector. Recognizing that a system of slits is a position-measuring device allows us to ascertain that the state vector is a position state. Then, writing the state vector in momentum space provides a straightforward calculation for the probability amplitude and its corresponding probability function. Interference effects, if any, are inherent in the probability function We determine the statistical distribution of scattered particles for four different slit systems. The results are in agreement with the well-known interference patterns obtained in classical wave optics."

In essence, this is an analysis of how the HUP applies.
 

Related to Speed of photons through dual slit.

1. What is the dual-slit experiment and why is it important?

The dual-slit experiment is a classic experiment in physics that demonstrates the wave-particle duality of light. It involves shining a beam of light through two closely spaced slits and observing the resulting interference pattern on a screen. This experiment is important because it provides evidence that light behaves both as a wave and as a particle, which has profound implications for our understanding of the nature of light and matter.

2. How does the speed of photons through the dual slit compare to their speed in a vacuum?

The speed of photons through the dual slit is the same as their speed in a vacuum, which is approximately 299,792,458 meters per second. This is because the speed of light is a constant, and it does not change based on the medium through which it is traveling. However, the path of the photons through the dual slit may be affected by the presence of the slits, causing them to diffract and interfere with each other, which can affect the overall speed of the light waves.

3. Can the speed of photons through the dual slit be measured?

Yes, the speed of photons through the dual slit can be measured by using a variety of methods, such as using a high-speed camera to capture the interference pattern on the screen or using a spectrometer to analyze the wavelength of the light passing through the slits. However, due to the extremely high speed of light, these measurements require very precise and sensitive instruments.

4. Does the speed of photons through the dual slit change depending on the wavelength of light?

No, the speed of photons through the dual slit is the same for all wavelengths of light. This is because the speed of light is a fundamental constant that does not vary with the wavelength of light. However, the wavelength of light can affect how the photons interact with the slits, which can in turn affect the resulting interference pattern on the screen.

5. How does the speed of photons through the dual slit relate to the uncertainty principle?

The uncertainty principle, a fundamental principle in quantum mechanics, states that it is impossible to accurately measure both the position and momentum of a particle at the same time. This means that it is not possible to precisely measure the speed of photons through the dual slit, as doing so would require knowing both their position and momentum simultaneously. Instead, we can only measure the speed of light as an average over a large number of photons, which is not affected by the uncertainty principle.

Similar threads

  • Quantum Physics
3
Replies
81
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
419
Replies
19
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
28
Views
692
Replies
3
Views
737
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
1
Views
531
  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
36
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
681
Replies
32
Views
1K
Back
Top