Reverse Lava Lamp Challenge: Can You Prove Me Wrong?

In summary: This is due to it's polar nature and hydrogen bonding.Originally posted by chroot In summary, all ice is less dense than liquid water (within certain limits) because the alignment of hydrogen bonds within the solid creates a more stable crystal lattice where the solid is less dense.
  • #1
CyberJay
8
0
Ok, is there any solid, liquid, or gas that becomes heavier as it gets warmer and lighter as it gets colder? Like a reverse lava lamp.

The little physics I know says no but I Know VERY little, you know?

CJ
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Originally posted by CyberJay
Ok, is there any solid, liquid, or gas that becomes heavier as it gets warmer and lighter as it gets colder? Like a reverse lava lamp.

The little physics I know says no but I Know VERY little, you know?

CJ

ice, below 4 degrees celsius, i think does this
 
  • #3
If making a "reverse lava lamp" is the primary goal, perhaps a reversed approach is more appropreiate. There are many fluid mediums that thicken when cooled and thin out when heated. An object of near-neutral buoyancee would float in the thicker medium, and sink as it thinned.

Just a thought.
 
  • #4
answers' answers so far

Hadn't thought of ice Lethe. But I would like something that doesn't change it's physical properties so radically with the change. Does mercury fit the bill? if so is there something similar?

Alas no Lurch the reverse lava lamp was just the analogy. But tell me more of this liquid.
[?]

CJ
 
  • #5
I don't see how any could increase or decrease of mass.

2 grams of H20 is 2 grams, liquid, solid or vapor.

Nautica
 
  • #6


lethe,

I think all ice is below 4 degrees Celsius. :wink: I assume you just mean water.

nautica,

I think he's using "light" and "heavy" to refer to density.

- Warren
 
  • #7
There are minerals like zirconium tungstate that have a negative coefficient of thermal expansion, but I don't know of any blobby stuff, offhand, that would do this. Surely there class of polymers somewhere that do this.
 
  • #8


Originally posted by chroot
I think all ice is below 4 degrees Celsius. :wink:

Two words: Ha Ha

I assume you just mean water.

Really?? I assumed he just meant negative 4oC.
 
  • #9
Water reaches it's maximum density at 4° C, expands, due to thermicity, in either direction, from that point.
 
  • #10
ICE

ice is only lighter because it traps air, but pure ice is the same wensity as liquid h20


nothing fits this discription as losing density as it cools.
 
  • #11
ice is only lighter because it traps air, but pure ice is the same wensity as liquid h20
Whaa...? As far as I am aware, ice is less dense than liquid water (within certain limits) because the alignment of hydrogen bonds within the solid creates a more stable crystal lattice where the solid is less dense.

eg. http://www.pa.msu.edu/~sciencet/ask_st/040694.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #12
Well, I'm certainly no expert, but I recall that purified ice(such as used in commercial ice blocks for sculptures) are very dense, and greatly depend on reducing air entrapement. Interesting. The next time we use a commercial ice block, I will save a piece and see if it floats in standard water.
 
  • #13
FZ+ posted what is, to the best of my knowledge, the right responce, 'trapped air' simply adds to ice's floatation, but even without any air at all, it will still float in water...("normal ice"...means STP and 'tapwater')

EDIT Ooops not STP as that is well above the freezing point, water reaches Max density at 4 C it expands, in either thermal direction, from there.

Water does not change 'mass' when expanding, or contracting, it changes density (mass to volume)
 
Last edited:
  • #14
Originally posted by nautica
I don't see how any could increase or decrease of mass.

2 grams of H20 is 2 grams, liquid, solid or vapor.

Agree! The answer to lehte´s question is no! (As long as we are in the NR-limit)...
 
  • #15
pure ice is still less dense than pure water. and higher temperature does mean higher mass if you take energy into account. (extremely unmeasurable)
 
  • #16
pallidin said:
Well, I'm certainly no expert, but I recall that purified ice(such as used in commercial ice blocks for sculptures) are very dense, and greatly depend on reducing air entrapement. Interesting. The next time we use a commercial ice block, I will save a piece and see if it floats in standard water.


Ice could adopt different phases that are more dense than water depending on the pressure and temperature, but most of these could not be taken out of that environment and plunked into liquid water at room temp and pressure.

Here is a very nice explanation:
http://jchemed.chem.wisc.edu/JCESoft/CCA/CCA2/MAIN/ICECUBE/CD2R1.HTM

Don't forget to check the link about deuterated water! I never thought about it but there it is before your very ice.



l
 
  • #17
The answer to your question is contained in posts by Chroot and Parsons. Water is what you need. Cool it below 4 deg C and it becomes lighter. Heat it up to 4 and it becomes heavier.

The reason for this is (perhaps) the formation of meta-stable hydrogen bonds - which are more stable in ice - that try to induce a non-close packing.
 

Related to Reverse Lava Lamp Challenge: Can You Prove Me Wrong?

1. What is the "Reverse Lava Lamp Challenge"?

The Reverse Lava Lamp Challenge is an experiment that involves reversing the traditional function of a lava lamp. Instead of heating the wax at the bottom to make it rise, the challenge is to cool the wax at the top to make it sink.

2. Why is this challenge important?

This challenge is important because it challenges our understanding of how lava lamps work and forces us to think outside the box. It also has potential implications for other scientific principles and could lead to new discoveries.

3. Can the challenge be done with any lava lamp?

Yes, the challenge can be done with any lava lamp as long as it has a clear glass bottle and the wax inside is still in good condition. However, some lava lamps may be more difficult to reverse due to their specific design and heating mechanism.

4. How do you prove someone wrong in this challenge?

To prove someone wrong in this challenge, you must successfully reverse the function of the lava lamp and make the wax sink instead of rise. This can be achieved by cooling the top of the lamp using ice or a fan, while heating the bottom of the lamp with a heat source.

5. Is this challenge safe to do at home?

As with any science experiment, it is important to follow safety precautions. The challenge itself is relatively safe, but caution should be taken when handling heat sources and using electrical devices. It is recommended to have adult supervision if attempting the challenge at home.

Similar threads

I How to know when a reversible process between end states exists?
    • Thermodynamics
Replies
12
Views
1K
After Dissolving Salt in Boiling Water, How Do You Get it Back?
    • Chemistry
Replies
18
Views
3K
I Can chatgpt accurately calculate expected lengths in Pascal's triangle?
    • General Math
2
Replies
66
Views
4K
How Can Returning Students Overcome Challenges in Online Physics Courses?
    • New Member Introductions
Replies
2
Views
150
MHB Can You Prove This Inequality Challenge?
    • General Math
Replies
2
Views
798
I Feynman's reversible and irreversible machines
    • Classical Physics
Replies
5
Views
4K
I Which stick hits harder? (one is stiff and other can be bent slightly)
    • Mechanics
Replies
6
Views
869
A Can Hamson-Linde cycle liquidize N2?
    • Thermodynamics
Replies
7
Views
1K
Adiabatic Reversible Compression of a Solid
    • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
16
Views
3K
I Pool Solar Heating - Help orienting the roof-top solar collector please
    • Thermodynamics
Replies
1
Views
714

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top