String theory classical limit?

In summary, the conversation discusses the possibility of recovering classical physics from string theory in various limits, similar to how it is achieved in other theories such as general relativity and Maxwell's electrodynamics. However, there is disagreement among physicists about whether this can truly be achieved and if it does, whether it would compromise certain principles of general relativity.
  • #1
cragwolf
170
0
String theory "classical" limit?

I know nothing about string theory, I'm still trying to deal with the more basic early 20th century stuff. But a question popped into my head which I hope someone can answer or point me to an answer.

In general relativity you can recover Newtonian gravitational physics by applying the field equations to a slowly varying, weak gravitational field. In Maxwell's electrodynamics you can recover Coulomb's electrostatics law (I forget exactly how). In special relativity you can recover Newtonian mechanics in the limit as velocities go to zero.

Can you do the same with string theory? Can you recover general relativity from string theory in some limit? What about quantum mechanics and quantum electrodynamics?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The string theorists say you can, but many relativitists disagree. String physics produces a graviton, and the properties of this graviton are such that, if matter particles exchange them, the resulting physics is like Einstein's general relativity, with som extra stuff that goes away at low energies.

The trouble is that in most of the string models, all of this happens within a flat Minkowski spacetime. So you lose one of the cherished parts of general relativity, once called general covariance, now realized as diffeomorphism invariance. Space is decoupled from physics, which is business as usual in quantum physics, but a big loss for GR physics.
 
  • #3


The "classical" limit in string theory refers to the scenario where the fundamental strings are assumed to be infinitely long, and their vibrations are slow compared to the speed of light. In this limit, the behavior of the strings can be described using classical equations of motion, similar to how classical mechanics can describe the behavior of particles in the limit of low velocities compared to the speed of light.

In this limit, string theory is expected to reproduce the predictions of general relativity and quantum field theory. However, it is important to note that string theory goes beyond these theories and incorporates gravity into a unified framework with the other fundamental forces of nature. So while the classical limit may recover some aspects of these theories, it also introduces new features and phenomena that are not present in them.

Furthermore, the classical limit in string theory is just one aspect of the theory and does not fully capture its complexity and richness. It is still an active area of research and there is ongoing work to understand the full implications and predictions of string theory. So while the classical limit may provide some insights, it is not the complete picture of string theory.
 

1. What is string theory's classical limit?

The classical limit of string theory refers to the behavior of strings in the theory when their length approaches zero. This is similar to how classical mechanics emerges from quantum mechanics when Planck's constant is set to zero. In the classical limit, strings are described as continuous objects rather than discrete particles.

2. How does the classical limit differ from the quantum behavior of strings?

In the classical limit, strings are described as continuous objects with definite positions and momenta, while in the quantum behavior of strings, they exhibit wave-like properties and do not have definite positions or momenta. Additionally, in the classical limit, strings do not experience quantum fluctuations and their motion can be described by classical equations of motion.

3. What is the significance of the classical limit in string theory?

The classical limit is important because it allows us to connect string theory with classical theories, such as general relativity. This allows us to make predictions and test the theory in the classical regime, where experimental data is more readily available. It also helps us understand the behavior of strings in extreme conditions, such as near black holes.

4. Is the classical limit of string theory well-understood?

While the classical limit of string theory is well-understood in certain cases, it is still an active area of research. There are ongoing efforts to better understand the behavior of strings in this limit, as well as to develop new mathematical tools and techniques for studying it.

5. Can the classical limit of string theory be tested experimentally?

Currently, there is no experimental evidence for the classical limit of string theory. However, there are ongoing efforts to test predictions of string theory in the classical regime, such as through gravitational wave observations and high energy particle collisions. It is possible that future experiments will provide evidence for the classical behavior of strings in the theory.

Similar threads

  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
26
Views
655
Replies
47
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
386
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
16
Views
2K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
0
Views
482
Back
Top