How to Solve for the Value of B in a Geometric Series

In summary: B ~ 0.833333333333333...L ~ 2.12499999999999...Sorry again...L ~ 1.41666666666666...Sorry...L ~ 0.833333333333333...http://www.cut-the-knot.org/do_you_know/AllNumbers.shtmlhttp://www.cut-the-knot.org/do_you_know/AllNumbers.shtml#A043696http://www.cut-the-knot.org/Curriculum/Arithmetic/InfProdConverge.shtml
  • #1
Loren Booda
3,125
4
Can you solve analytically

[oo]
[pi] (n)1/n
n=1

or

[oo]
[pi] (n!)1/n!
n=1

or

[oo]
[sum] (1/n)n
n=1

or

[oo]
[sum] (1/n!)n!
n=1


?
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
  • #2
[oo]
&Pi n1/n = [oo]
n = 1

Proof:

Let P_k be the k-th partial product of &Pi n1/n

Then:

ln P_k = ln &Pi n1/n = &Sigma (1/n) ln n

Notice that the n-th term in this sequence is strictly greater than 1/n (for all n > 1)... so the k-th partial sum must be greater than the k-th partial sum of the harmonic series. Since the harmonic series diverges, so must this.


Hurkyl
 
  • #3
 ∞
[sum](n!)1/n! = ∞
n=1

Proof:
 ∞               ∞
[sum](n!)1/n! > [sum] 1
n=1            n=1
The right hand side obviously diverges, since the left hand side is larger then then the right hand side it diverges also.  ♦

ps: I edited this about 30 times to make it look nice and pretty, so you better all appreciate it. That line with the inequality was wicked hard to put together and make everything line up just right
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #4
Neat, Hurkyl. Although straightforward, I hadn't thought of taking the logarithm of the partial product to get a summation.

What do you mathematicians think of climbhi's "proof"?

Who can (re)evaluate the other infinite product and summations?
 
  • #5
Originally posted by Loren Booda
What do you mathematicians think of climbhi's "proof"?
Well admitidley I am not a mathemitician (or a great speller) but I think this is entirely valid. Just looking at the first few terms
  • a1 = 1 which is ≥ 1
  • a2 = √2 again ≥ 1
  • a3 = 61/6 again ≥ 1
  • a4 = 241/24 again ≥ 1
  • ...
  • an = n!1/n! since the limit of n!1/n! as n→∞ = 1 we can again say an ≥ 1

So it's obvious that our sum of n!1/n! from 1 to ∞ is greater then our sum of 1 from 1 to ∞. Now since 1 ≥ 1/n for all natural n we know the sum of 1 from 1 to ∞ is greater then the harmonic series, which diverges, so so does the sum of ones, so so does the sum of n!1/n!. I really think that this is valid and have no idea why you're questioning it. Please tell me, have I done something wrong here?
 
  • #6
Well, lim sum (1/n)^n is somewhere near 1.29128599706266...
This number looks familiar...
 
  • #7
Climbhi's proof is solid, it's just not one of the 4 you asked for, hehe.

Hurkyl
 
  • #8
I guess that lim sum (1/n)^n can't be written as a function of other constants, so it is a new constant...like lim 1+1/2+1/3+...+1/n-ln(n), which is equal to c in (0,1), Euler's constant...
The same for lim sum (1/n!)^n!...

lim sum (1/n)^n=L, 1.29<L<1.292; L ~ 1.29128599706266

lim sum (1/n!)^n!=B, 0.29<B<0.292; B ~ 0.291285997062663

L from Loren, and B from Booda...

Even though I've said these things...that 1.29128599706266 looks very, very familiar to me...it could be a physical constant...

I think you know how to prove that sum (1/n)^n is convergent...and sum (1/n!)^n!...
If not...here it is...
1 < sum (1/n)^n < sum (1/2)^(n-1) < 1.5;
Let Ak = sum (1/n)^n...sum from 1 to k...
Ak < A(k+1)...evidently...so...according to Weierstrass theorem (Ak is bounded (1,1.5) and it is raising) we obtain that the sum is convergent...the same for sum (1/n!)^n!...
 
  • #9
Originally posted by Hurkyl
Climbhi's proof is solid, it's just not one of the 4 you asked for, hehe.

Hurkyl

Oooh, Loren was looking for the infinite product, as you can see in my replies I thought it was the infinite sum of n!1/n! that he was looking for. Sorry about that!
Hurkyl, would you mind explaining you're proof to me, it looks like in the middle you suddenly jumped from an infinite product to an infinite sum. Did you do this using the properties of logarithms (i.e. ln6 = ln3 + ln2) or am I missing something. Thanks.
 
  • #10
Yes...
ln x^(1/x)=(1/x)*lnx
and ln (1^1 * 2^(1/2) * ... * k^(1/k) ) is equal to
ln 1 + (1/2)*ln2 + ... + (1/k)*lnk...
I guess the harmonic series means 1/1+1/2+1/3+...+1/n...?
(which is divergent...)
 
  • #11
bogdan
lim sum (1/n)^n=L, 1.29<L<1.292; L ~ 1.29128599706266

lim sum (1/n!)^n!=B, 0.29<B<0.292; B ~ 0.291285997062663

L from Loren, and B from Booda...
Thank you, bogdan, my appreciation for you and your numerical skills is without limit. However, with 100,000 new math proofs every year...are these numbers original? "Loren" and "Booda" seem to represent properties similar to the Golden Means', perhaps here a polynomial with irrational coefficients. Say L=B+1, where x=L and x=B so x^2+(2B+1)x+B(B+1)=0.
 
  • #12
x^2-(2B+1)x+B(B+1)=0 ...
Due to a programming error... B ~ 1.25002143347051...
Sorry...
 
Last edited:

1. What is an infinite geometric series?

An infinite geometric series is a mathematical concept that involves an infinite number of terms that are related to each other by a common ratio. Each term in the series is found by multiplying the previous term by the common ratio.

2. How is the sum of an infinite geometric series calculated?

The formula for calculating the sum of an infinite geometric series is S = a / (1 - r), where S is the sum, a is the first term, and r is the common ratio. This formula only works if the absolute value of r is less than 1.

3. What happens to an infinite geometric series if the common ratio is greater than 1?

If the common ratio is greater than 1, the series will diverge and the sum will approach infinity. This means that the terms in the series will continuously increase in value and the sum will not have a finite value.

4. Can an infinite geometric series have a finite sum?

Yes, an infinite geometric series can have a finite sum if the absolute value of the common ratio is less than 1. In this case, the series will converge and the sum will approach a specific value as more terms are added.

5. What are some real-life applications of infinite geometric series?

Infinite geometric series can be found in various fields such as finance, physics, and computer science. They are used to model compound interest, radioactive decay, and computer algorithms. They are also used to solve problems involving infinite sums in calculus and other branches of mathematics.

Similar threads

  • General Math
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
577
Replies
12
Views
900
  • General Math
Replies
33
Views
2K
Replies
15
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
286
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
274
Replies
3
Views
920
Replies
2
Views
1K
Back
Top