Is there an easy way to convert $$ tags to [tex][/tex]?

In summary, The conversation is about creating a regular expression (regexp) for converting strings with dollar signs into [tex] tags for a program. The discussion covers different approaches, such as using Perl or Javascript, and potential issues with greedy matching and extra dollar signs. One of the participants suggests using the tags <xet> to avoid conflicts with the forum's code. The conversation also mentions the possibility of creating a converter script or posting sample regexp expressions on the forum's help threads.
  • #1
Simfish
Gold Member
823
2
I know that there's probably a way to do this with regexp, but I don't know regexp (yet). So does anyone have any tips on how to create the regexp expression for it? (and what other ways are there?)
 
Technology news on Phys.org
  • #2
Simfish said:
I know that there's probably a way to do this with regexp, but I don't know regexp (yet). So does anyone have any tips on how to create the regexp expression for it? (and what other ways are there?)

What language are you using? Do you have an example of a string you'd like to convert from and what you'd like to convert it to?

DaveE
 
  • #3
regexp would be sufficient enough (regexp works with lots of languages). Just a search-replace string that I could use for a program that uses regexp.

So convert $x^2$ into [tex] x^2[/ tex]
 
  • #4
perl -e 'undef $/; $_ = <>; @a = split /\$/; while (@a) { print(shift @a); print("[tex]".(shift @a)."[/tex]") if (@a); }'

(This will choke if there are stray dollar signs.)

A pure regexp solution is likely to run into greedy-match problems if there is more than one $$ pair in the string.

EDIT: It wants to interpret my TEX tags as actual tex tags. Hit quote if you want to see the actual source.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
Yeah, Perl-wise, I think I'd do:

Code:
$string =~ s/\$([^$]*)\$/\[xet\]$1\[\/xet\]/gs;

As pointed out, this won't always work if there are any extra $ signs floating around. So if you got a string of:

Code:
I paid $3 to Tim to get the answer $x^2$, but Bob only charged $2.

That obviously wouldn't work. It would change it into:

Code:
I paid [xet]3 to Tim to get the answer [/xet]x^2[xet], but Bob only charged [/xet]2.

But you REALLY wanted:

Code:
I paid $3 to Tim to get the answer [xet]x^2[/xet], but Bob only charged $2.

If there are rules about what can go inside the $$, you can write that into the regexp to make it more fool-proof, but I'm not sure what the rules might be. For instance, if there is no whitespace allowed within the $$, you could use the regexp:

Code:
$string =~ s/\$([^$\s]*)\$/\[xet\]$1\[\/xet\]/gs;

And that'd work on the above string.

[edit]Fought with IP board code about recognizing tags-- just pretend that "xet" is "tex", in the above.[/edit]

DaveE
 
Last edited:
  • #6
davee123 said:
Yeah, Perl-wise, I think I'd do:

Code:
$string =~ s/\$([^$]*)\$/\[xet\]$1\[\/xet\]/gs;

As pointed out, this won't always work if there are any extra $ signs floating around.

I think you can get around this by using perl's ridiculous ?<! operator ("zero-length negative look-behind"!), something like:

Code:
$string =~ s/(?<!\\)\$([^\$]*[^\\])\$/\[xet\]$1\[\/xet\]/gs;

This should refuse to match $s that are preceded by a \, either inside or outside tex areas. So like you'd be able to write "I gave steve \$3" and it would safely understand this is not a tex delimiter.

I was worried greedy matching would mess you up (ie "I think $x^2$ is a better equation than $2^x$" and it tries to match "is a better equation than" as the tex area) but when I tested this actually wasn't a problem! So there's your solution. Although I'd take advantage of perl -p:

Code:
perl -pe 's/(?<!\\)\$([^\$]*[^\\])\$/\[xet\]$1\[\/xet\]/gs;'
 
  • #7
Simfish: Try this substitute (s) command.

:set magic
:s;$\([^$]*\)\$;[noparse][tex]\1[/tex][/noparse];g

If you want it to change only the first occurrence of $$ in the line, remove the "g" character. (The colon shown above just represents the command mode prompt, and is not part of the commands.)
 
Last edited:
  • #8
To all of you fighting tags recognition by forum software - try [noparse][noparse][/noparse][/noparse] tags.
 
  • #9
Thanks for all the replies, everyone! :) Based on the input, I've created my own regexp expression (for the JGSoft software that I use). Which is basically this:

search: \$([^$]*)\$

replace: [xet]$1[/xet]

===

It actually might be helpful to put sample regexp expressions on the PF Help threads about LaTeX (since it makes it much easier for people to convert their tags from their documents to the LaTeX demanded by PF).
 
  • #10
Borek, thanks, is that documented somewhere?

Simfish said:
Thanks for all the replies, everyone! :) Based on the input, I've created my own regexp expression (for the JGSoft software that I use). Which is basically this:

search: \$([^$]*)\$

replace: [xet]$1[/xet]

===

It actually might be helpful to put sample regexp expressions on the PF Help threads about LaTeX (since it makes it much easier for people to convert their tags from their documents to the LaTeX demanded by PF).

Or maybe just post a converter script somewhere.

Actually, I'm pretty sure you could do this particular regexp in Javascript. If I submit a "convert $tex$ to [xet] tags" javascript to will physicsforums post it somewhere?
 

Related to Is there an easy way to convert $$ tags to [tex][/tex]?

1. Can I use a simple find and replace method to convert $$ tags to [tex][/tex]?

No, simply replacing the $$ tags with [tex][/tex] will not work as it may cause formatting issues. A more systematic approach is needed.

2. Is there a code or software that can automatically convert $$ tags to [tex][/tex]?

Yes, there are several programs and scripts available online that can help with this conversion. However, it is important to double-check the converted equations for accuracy.

3. Do I need any special knowledge or skills to convert $$ tags to [tex][/tex]?

Some basic understanding of coding and regular expressions may be helpful, but there are also user-friendly tools available for those without extensive technical knowledge.

4. Are there any drawbacks to converting $$ tags to [tex][/tex]?

One downside is that not all platforms and software support the [tex][/tex] format, so the equations may not be visible to all users. Additionally, the conversion process may not be 100% accurate.

5. Can I convert other types of mathematical tags to [tex][/tex] using the same method?

Yes, the method used for converting $$ tags to [tex][/tex] can also be applied to other types of mathematical tags, such as \( \) and \[ \]. However, it is important to test and make sure the converted equations are correct.

Similar threads

  • Programming and Computer Science
Replies
1
Views
408
  • Programming and Computer Science
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
Replies
28
Views
1K
  • Programming and Computer Science
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
774
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
196
  • Chemistry
Replies
2
Views
885
  • Programming and Computer Science
Replies
33
Views
2K
  • Programming and Computer Science
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
483
Back
Top