Is Psychology Becoming More Scientific?

In summary, Richard Feynman says that psychological experiments must be repeated in order to verify results, and that this is still the policy of the field.
  • #1
Zefram
147
0
How scientific is it? What I mean is I just read Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman! and in the very last section on "cargo cult science" he says:

Other kinds of errors are more characteristic of poor science. When I was at Cornell, I often talked to the people in the psychology department. One of the students told me she wanted to do an experiment that went something like this--it had been found by others that under certain circumstances, X, rats did something, A. She was curious as to whether, if she changed the circumstances to Y, they would still do A. So her proposal was to do the experiment under circumstances Y and see if they still did A.

I explained to her that it was necessary first to repeat in her laboratory the experiment of the other person--to do it under condition X to see if she could also get result A, and then change to Y and see if A changed. Then she would know that the real difference was the thing she thought she had under control.

She was very delighted with this new idea, and went to her professor. And his reply was, no, you cannot do that, because the experiment has already been done and you would be wasting time. This was in about 1947 or so, and it seems to have been the general policy then to not try to repeat psychological experiments, but only to change the conditions and see what happens.

He goes on later to talk about a psychology experiment with rats which he says "discovered all the things you have to do to discover something about rats" that was largely ignored by other researchers.

So has it changed in the last 50 years or so? Has it become more scientific, have the experiments become more repeatable (or rather, do they repeat them more now)?

Or is it still pretty cargo-cultish at times?
 
Last edited:
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #2
I just read Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!

Is that a good book? What's it about?
 
  • #3
It's a book of Richard Feynman's anecdotes; I love it.

As such, psychology has taken incredible leaps in the effectiveness of its methodologies since the 40's and 50's since we now not only repeat endlessly experiments with minute and subtle variations each time, but utilize experiment results used in and from other sciences to validate and ensure precision.

I'd be interested in hearing more about its methodologies and experiments.
 

What is psychology?

Psychology is the scientific study of the human mind and behavior. It seeks to understand how people think, feel, and behave in different situations and environments.

Why is psychology important?

Psychology is important because it helps us better understand ourselves and others. By studying psychology, we can gain insight into human behavior and use this knowledge to improve relationships, solve problems, and promote mental health and well-being.

What are the main branches of psychology?

The main branches of psychology are cognitive psychology, developmental psychology, social psychology, personality psychology, and clinical psychology. Other branches include biopsychology, educational psychology, and industrial-organizational psychology, among others.

What career opportunities are available in psychology?

There are many career opportunities in psychology, including clinical psychologists, counselors, therapists, researchers, and professors. Other potential career paths include working in mental health facilities, hospitals, schools, and businesses.

How does psychology differ from other sciences?

Psychology differs from other sciences in that it focuses on the study of human behavior and mental processes. Unlike natural sciences, such as biology or chemistry, psychology cannot be studied in a controlled laboratory setting and relies heavily on observation and experimentation. Additionally, psychology is an interdisciplinary field, drawing on knowledge and theories from other disciplines such as biology, sociology, and philosophy.

Similar threads

  • Biology and Medical
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
4
Views
592
  • Art, Music, History, and Linguistics
Replies
1
Views
795
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
567
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
14
Views
653
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
31
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
14
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
885
Back
Top