How Does Relativistic Doppler Effect Impact Perception in Space Travel?

In summary: However, this is just a visual effect and does not accurately represent the actual time dilation that occurs in the moving frame. So, while there is a visual analogy for time dilation, it is not an accurate representation and does not have the same level of symmetry as length contraction.
  • #1
sodaMay
4
0
An outside observer will perceive my spaceship as being shorter, but what will i see of my outside surroundings? Will they be longer?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2


sodaMay said:
An outside observer will perceive my spaceship as being shorter, but what will i see of my outside surroundings? Will they be longer?
Depends what you mean by perceive. He certainly will not actually see it shorter. Only when he draws a choordinate chart he will conclude it is shorter.

Roger Penrose and James Terrell are the folks who thought a bit deeper about length contraction than others who just parrot the dogma that it is directly observable. :smile:
 
  • #3


sodaMay said:
An outside observer will perceive my spaceship as being shorter, but what will i see of my outside surroundings? Will they be longer?
In relativity there's a difference between what you see visually and what you measure in your own rest frame. What you see is affected by the fact that light from different events (or different parts of a single object) takes different amounts of time to reach you; the coordinates you assign to events are based on compensating for such delays, the usual method being for each observer to use a network of rulers and synchronized clocks at rest relative to himself, and defining the coordinates of events purely in terms of local measurements on this system (for example, if I see an explosion happen next to the 12-meter mark on my x-axis ruler, and the clock sitting on that mark reads 5 seconds at the moment the explosion happens next to it, then I assign that event coordinates x=12 meters, t=5 seconds in my frame).

When people talk about length contraction, they are talking about what's measured in your frame, not what you see visually (the visual size is influenced by something called the Penrose-Terrell effect which MeJennifer mentioned). But as far as how length contracts in different frames, the effect is completely symmetrical--if you are moving at 0.95c relative to an observer on a space station, then in the station's frame your ship's length will appear shrunk, but in your frame the ship's length will be normal and the length the station will be shrunk, by exactly the same factor (keep in mind that in your frame, your ship is at rest while it is the station that is moving at 0.95c away from you, and in relativity there is no objective physical truth about how fast any object is 'really' moving, all speeds are relative to your frame of reference).
 
  • #4


sodaMay said:
An outside observer will perceive my spaceship as being shorter, but what will i see of my outside surroundings? Will they be longer?
The visual effects are symmetric. The 'distortion' seen by the outside observer as he looks at your spaceship will be the same as the 'distortion' seen by you as you look outside.

As to precisely what the distortion is, is complicated; I haven't worked it out myself. There will surely be some shortening involved, but I've heard that, visually, the distortion looks more like a rotation.
 
  • #5


Wikipedia has a decent description, in part :

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrell_rotation

Terrell's paper pointed out that although special relativity appeared to describe an "observed contraction" in moving objects, these interpreted "observations" were not to be confused with the theory's literal predictions for the visible appearance of a moving object. Thanks to the differential timelag effects in signals reaching the observer from the object's different parts, a receding object would appear contracted, an approaching object would appear elongated (even under special relativity) and the geometry of a passing object would appear skewed.

I had forgotton reading about this for the first time about a month or so ago and never got to post the obvious question: Is there an analogous effect for time dilation? Why?
 
  • #6


Naty1 said:
I had forgotton reading about this for the first time about a month or so ago and never got to post the obvious question: Is there an analogous effect for time dilation? Why?
I'd say the relativistic Doppler effect is the closest analogy; because of this effect, a clock moving towards you will visually appear sped up rather than slowed down, and a clock moving away from you will visually appear slowed down by a factor greater than the time dilation factor.
 

Related to How Does Relativistic Doppler Effect Impact Perception in Space Travel?

1. What kind of technology is used for journeying in a spaceship?

Spaceships use advanced technology such as rocket propulsion, navigation systems, and life support systems to travel through space.

2. Can you see stars and planets while journeying in a spaceship?

Yes, you can see stars and planets while journeying in a spaceship. However, the view may be different from what you see on Earth due to the lack of atmosphere and other factors.

3. How long does it take to reach different destinations in a spaceship?

The time it takes to reach a destination in a spaceship varies depending on the distance and speed of the spaceship. It can take anywhere from a few days to several years to reach a destination.

4. Is it safe to journey in a spaceship?

Journeying in a spaceship can be risky and requires extensive training and precautions. However, with advanced technology and proper safety measures, it can be relatively safe.

5. What are some of the challenges of journeying in a spaceship?

Some of the challenges of journeying in a spaceship include exposure to radiation, potential equipment malfunctions, and the physical and psychological effects of being in a confined space for an extended period.

Similar threads

  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
14
Views
764
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
65
Views
5K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
18
Views
463
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
24
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
24
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
4
Views
870
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
36
Views
2K
Back
Top