How Does Light Interact with Different Media According to Quantum Mechanics?

In summary, Feynman explains that when light travels from air to a denser medium, it will take the shortest time to reach its destination by going more in air and less in the denser medium. This is because light has both wave and ray properties, and the waves travel along all possible paths. Those that are not minimal will interfere destructively, while the minimal path will result in constructive interference. This means that any light waves traveling along a non-minimal path will cancel each other out. As for the question of how light knows about the denser medium, it is explained that there is only one photon which interferes with itself, and the "wave" is just a probability to find the photon at a given point. The
  • #1
feynmann
156
1
In Feynman lectures, Feynman says if light goes from air to denser medium,light goes more in air and less in denser medium so that it takes shortest time to reach its destination.

My question are

How light knows that there is a denser medium ahead in its path?

Does light get information about the denser medium?

what is information?
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
The light doesn't "know" which path/time is the shortest...The fact is that light has wave characteristics as well as ray properties. The light waves propagate along ALL paths...the waves that are traveling along paths that are not minimized will reach the point exactly out of phase and undergo destructive interference, while the waves on the minimal path will interfere constructively. So basically any light waves traveling along a path that does not represent minimal time will cancel each other out.
 
  • #3
destro47 said:
The light doesn't "know" which path/time is the shortest...The fact is that light has wave characteristics as well as ray properties. The light waves propagate along ALL paths...the waves that are traveling along paths that are not minimized will reach the point exactly out of phase and undergo destructive interference, while the waves on the minimal path will interfere constructively. So basically any light waves traveling along a path that does not represent minimal time will cancel each other out.

So what happens to the energy of the photons when they destructively interfere? Doesn't this go against the law of conservation of energy?
 
  • #4
mn4j said:
So what happens to the energy of the photons when they destructively interfere? Doesn't this go against the law of conservation of energy?

There's only one photon and it interferes with itself. As such, the "wave" which interferes with itself is just a probability to find the photon at a given point. The photon is either found at a point or not found at a point. The photon never splits up. But if you make a measurement along one of the paths to find out which way it went, you'll destroy the interference effect. The question of "what happens to the photon in between its emission from a source and its detection" is the subject of the so-called interpretations of quantum mechanics. i.e. quantum theory doesn't tell us anything apart from measurable phenomena.

Edit: The wave itself is not directly the probability. If you've done complex valued functions, the square of the amplitude of the wave gives the probability density.
 

Related to How Does Light Interact with Different Media According to Quantum Mechanics?

What is the Fermat principle?

The Fermat principle, also known as the principle of least time, states that light travels between two points along the path that takes the least amount of time.

How does the Fermat principle explain the behavior of light?

The Fermat principle explains the behavior of light by stating that light always takes the path that requires the least amount of time to travel between two points. This can be seen in the law of reflection and the law of refraction.

What is the significance of the Fermat principle in optics?

The Fermat principle is significant in optics because it helps us understand the behavior of light and how it interacts with different materials. It is also the basis for many optical laws and equations, making it an important concept in the field of optics.

Are there any exceptions to the Fermat principle?

While the Fermat principle is a fundamental concept in optics, there are some situations where it may not apply. For example, in the case of diffraction or when light travels through materials with varying refractive indices, the path that takes the least time may not always be the straightest path.

How is the Fermat principle related to the principle of least action?

The Fermat principle is closely related to the principle of least action, which states that a system will always take the path that requires the least amount of action. In the case of light, action is equivalent to time, so the Fermat principle can be seen as a specific application of the principle of least action in optics.

Similar threads

Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
4K
Replies
8
Views
9K
Replies
19
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
982
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
13K
Back
Top