How do we know that the universe is three dimensional?

  • Thread starter Fiziqs
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Universe
In summary, there are three dimensions that we can perceive, and there may be more that we cannot perceive.
  • #1
Fiziqs
134
0
When we look at the world around us our minds create a three dimensional representation of the world based upon our sensory input, but how do we know that there aren't in fact more dimensions from which we either receive no sensory input, or from which we receive input, but our brains and our mathematics have evolved to interpret three dimensionally? Or perhaps there are only two dimensions, from which our minds extrapolate three dimensions. Or taken to the extreme, how do we know that there are any actual dimensions at all?

How do we know that what we see and interpret as being three dimensional, actually is?
 
Space news on Phys.org
  • #2
Fiziqs said:
How do we know that what we see and interpret as being three dimensional, actually is?

think about the difference between a 2 dimensional photo of a room and the real 3 dimensionality of that room
think about what you can and cannot do in the photo Vs in the actual room

consider depth of field implied and real
 
  • #3
And consider parallax.
 
  • #4
If you follow any popular modern science, you'll hear about how string theory predicts 10 or more space dimensions, and we can't see these dimensions because they are small and curled up. But there's no evidence for extra dimensions and there's plenty of evidence for 3 (space) dimensions.
On the other hand, you'll hear about holographic theory which suggests that there might only be two dimensions, but none of the details are worked out, so it can't really be called a theory.
Ultimately, science is about experiment, and all our experiences seem to show us a 3D universe, so unless we can come up with better experiments which show the contrary, we should go along with the preponderance of evidence and our intuition and simply accept 3D. "know" is too strong a word here.
 
  • Like
Likes Thewindyfan
  • #5
Are holograms necessarily 2D? I can envision interference patterns in higher dimessions.
 
  • #6
anorlunda said:
Are holograms necessarily 2D? I can envision interference patterns in higher dimessions.
In fact, all (near field) interference patterns are 3D. It's just that we normally observe them by putting a screen (2D) in the way.
The interference pattern that's produced by an rf transmitting array over a hilly terrain is demonstrably 3D because the maxes and mins vary as the receiver is moved in 3D. It would be possible to have a photographic or electronic light sensing array that extends in 3D as long as the receptor cells were very small.
 

Related to How do we know that the universe is three dimensional?

1. How do we know that the universe is three dimensional?

Scientists have determined that the universe is three dimensional through various observations and experiments. One key piece of evidence is the fact that objects in our universe have length, width, and height, which are all characteristics of three-dimensional objects. Additionally, the laws of physics, such as gravity and motion, only make sense in a three-dimensional space.

2. Can we physically see or measure the third dimension?

No, we cannot physically see or measure the third dimension. Our eyes can only perceive two dimensions, but our brain is able to interpret depth and create a three-dimensional perception. We can also use tools and technology, such as telescopes and satellites, to observe and measure objects in three dimensions.

3. How do we know that there aren't more than three dimensions?

While it is possible that there could be more than three dimensions, scientists have not found any evidence to support this idea. The laws of physics and the behavior of objects in our universe can be fully explained and understood in a three-dimensional space. Additionally, experiments such as the Large Hadron Collider have not shown any signs of additional dimensions.

4. Are there any theories or concepts that support the idea of a multidimensional universe?

Yes, there are several theories and concepts that propose the existence of a multidimensional universe. One of the most well-known is string theory, which suggests that there are 10 or 11 dimensions in our universe. However, these theories are still being explored and have not been proven.

5. Could technology advance to a point where we can physically experience the third dimension?

It is possible that technology could advance to a point where we can physically experience the third dimension, but it is currently beyond our capabilities. Virtual reality and other immersive technologies give us a sense of three-dimensional space, but they are still limited by our physical bodies and senses. It is uncertain if we will ever be able to fully experience the third dimension in a physical sense.

Similar threads

Replies
22
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
35
Views
3K
  • Cosmology
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Cosmology
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Cosmology
2
Replies
57
Views
3K
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • Cosmology
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Back
Top