How can we visualize the movement of Photons on the water?

In summary, electromagnetic radiation is a type of wave that is created when objects change their energy levels, but photons are not involved. The frequencies are all wrong for this type of radiation.
  • #1
Doruk Y
4
0
We all know that the photons have a wave-like motion,if the waves on the water form because of the motion of the particles inside the air(oxygen+nitrogen gas and %1 another gasses) so in the beginnig of this process,photons hit the air and make particles jiggle and that make air jiggle and air jiggles on the water and that motion we can wave? can we define like this? or any other suggestions please?
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
Photons do not have a wave-like motion, and are not what you're thinking they are.

Electromagnetic radiation is a type of wave, but this is a classical phenomenon, no quantum mechanics or photons involved. We have a number of threads about EM waves work; the quick summary is that nothing is physically moving back and forth, but the electrical and magnetic fields are changing.
 
  • #3
What do you mean by nothing is moving back and forth or up and down? so you mean when the light comes out from a flashlight the only thing happening is the changing electro-magnetic fields in the area which light passes?
 
  • #4
Doruk Y said:
so you mean when the light comes out from a flashlight the only thing happening is the changing electro-magnetic fields in the area which light passes?
Yes.
 
  • #5
Doruk Y said:
photons hit the air and make particles jiggle and that make air jiggle and air jiggles on the water and that motion we can wave? can we define like this?
In addition to the comments by @Nugatory and @jtbell the frequencies are all wrong for this. Light is in the terahertz range, sound is in the kilohertz range, and water waves are less than a hertz.
 
  • #6
Doruk Y said:
What do you mean by nothing is moving back and forth or up and down? so you mean when the light comes out from a flashlight the only thing happening is the changing electro-magnetic fields in the area which light passes?

That's right. Specifically it is the electric and magnetic field vectors that are changing. It is these field vectors which define the direction and magnitude of the EM field at every point in space.
 
  • #7
So the (atoms)are producing this EM radiation when they oscillating by other atoms around them?
 
  • #8
Doruk Y said:
So the (atoms)are producing this EM radiation when they oscillating by other atoms around them?

That's one way to produce EM radiation. You can also accelerate charges instead of entire atoms, like what happens in a transmitting antenna. Electronic transitions, which are when electrons drop from higher energy levels in atoms/molecules to lower energy levels, also produce EM radiation.
 
  • #9
How can we visualize the movement of Photons on the water?
Doruk Y said:
photons hit the air and make particles jiggle and that make air jiggle and air jiggles on the water and that motion we can wave?
Yes, it is very much like photons and smoke on the water...

 
  • Like
Likes pinball1970 and davenn
  • #10
Drakkith said:
That's one way to produce EM radiation. You can also accelerate charges instead of entire atoms, like what happens in a transmitting antenna. Electronic transitions, which are when electrons drop from higher energy levels in atoms/molecules to lower energy levels, also produce EM radiation.
So if i shake my hand up and down, i accelarete my atoms in my hand and their electrons jump a higher state and when they turns back to normal state they give off photons and that photons give the energy to the air and that process happens same like my hand in the oxygen and nitrogen atoms in the air?
 
  • #11
Doruk Y said:
So if i shake my hand up and down, i accelarete my atoms in my hand and their electrons jump a higher state and when they turns back to normal state they give off photons and that photons give the energy to the air and that process happens same like my hand in the oxygen and nitrogen atoms in the air?
All light is electromagnetic radiation.

When you accelerate changed objects they give off electromagnetic radiation. This is a classical phenomenon that has very little to do with photons or electron energy levels. However, your hand is for all practical purposes electrically neutral so shaking it up and down does not produce any electromagnetic radiation.

Photons are not what you're thinking they are; it might be best to forget that you ever heard the word "photon" until you have a clear understanding of the classical model of light as electromagnetic waves.
 
Last edited:
  • #12
Doruk Y said:
and their electrons jump a higher state
There have been some very strong hints to you that the 'photon' approach is not fruitful here. Your hand is neutrally charged so any vertical motion of the electrons is precisely balanced by the motion of the protons. What "change of state' are you proposing we should be considering?
Nugatory said:
it might be best to forget that you ever heard the word "photon" until you have a clear understanding of the classical model of light as electromagnetic waves.
Agreed. Don't try to run before you can walk; you risk falling over.
 

Related to How can we visualize the movement of Photons on the water?

1. How do Photons move on water?

Photons move on water in a straight line until they are absorbed, reflected, or refracted by the water molecules.

2. Can we physically see the movement of Photons on water?

No, we cannot physically see the movement of Photons on water as they are invisible to the naked eye. However, we can use special equipment and techniques to visualize their movement.

3. What techniques can be used to visualize the movement of Photons on water?

Some techniques that can be used to visualize the movement of Photons on water include laser scattering, fluorescence excitation, and spectroscopy.

4. What information can we gain from visualizing the movement of Photons on water?

By visualizing the movement of Photons on water, we can gain a better understanding of how light behaves and interacts with water molecules. This can also provide insights into the properties of water and its role in various processes such as photosynthesis and atmospheric phenomena.

5. How can visualizing the movement of Photons on water help in scientific research?

Visualizing the movement of Photons on water can help in various fields of scientific research, such as optics, chemistry, and biology. It can aid in the development of new technologies and techniques, as well as provide a better understanding of natural phenomena and processes.

Similar threads

  • Thermodynamics
Replies
14
Views
894
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
486
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
3
Views
886
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
18
Views
3K
Replies
25
Views
2K
Back
Top