- Thread starter
- Admin
- #1
- Feb 14, 2012
- 3,909
Find all solutions to $(m^2+k)(m+k^2)=(m-k)^3$, where $m$ and $k$ are non-zero integers.
Welcome to our community
Be a part of something great, join today!
Find all pairs (m,k) of integer solutions
- Thread starter anemone
- Start date
- Moderator
- #2
- Feb 7, 2012
- 2,785
Multiply out the brackets: \(\displaystyle m^3 + m^2k^2 + mk + k^3 = m^3 -3m^2k + 3mk^2 - k^3\), which (after dividing by the non-zero $k$) simplifies to $2k^2 + (m^2-3m)k + (m+3m^2) = 0.$ The discriminant of that quadratic in $k$ is $(m^2-3m)^2 - 8(m+3m^2)$, and that has to be a square, say $n^2$. So \(\displaystyle n^2 = (m^2-3m)^2 - 8(m+3m^2) = m^4 - 6m^3 - 15m^2 - 8m = m(m-8)(m+1)^2\) and therefore $m(m-8) = (m-4)^2 - 16$ must also be a square. The only way that can happen is if $m-4 = \pm5$. Thus $m = 9$ or $-1$. If $m=9$ then the quadratic for $k$ has solutions $k= -21$ and $k=-6$. If $m=-1$ then the only solution for $k$ is $k=-1$.
That gives three possible solutions, $(m,k) = (9,-21),\ (9,-6),\ (-1,-1)$.
That gives three possible solutions, $(m,k) = (9,-21),\ (9,-6),\ (-1,-1)$.
- Admin
- #3
- Mar 5, 2012
- 9,416
Why is that?
- Moderator
- #4
- Feb 7, 2012
- 2,785
If $x^2-16 = y^2$ then $16 = x^2-y^2 = (x+y)(x-y)$. The only factorisation of $16$ giving positive integer values for $x$ and $y$ is $x+y=8$, $x-y=2$, so that $x=5$ and $y=3$.
- Thread starter
- Admin
- #5
- Feb 14, 2012
- 3,909
Thank you so much for participating, Opalg! And welcome back to the forum as well!
But Opalg, I am sorry to tell you that you missed another solution set, which is $(m, k)=(8, -10)$.
My solution:
By expanding and simplifying the given equation, we get
\(\displaystyle m^3+m^2k^2+mk+k^3=m^3-3m^2k+3mk^2-k^3\)
\(\displaystyle 2k^3+(m^2-3m)k^2+mk+3m^2k=0\)
Since $k \ne 0$, divide through the equation above by $k$, we have
\(\displaystyle 2k^2+(m^2-3m)k+m+3m^2=0\)
and solve for $k$ using the quadratic formula yields
\(\displaystyle k=\frac{-(m^2-3m) \pm \sqrt{(m^2-3m)^2-4(2)(m+3m^2)}}{2(2)}\)
\(\displaystyle \;\;\;=\frac{3m-m^2 \pm \sqrt{(m+1)^2(m(m-8))}}{4}\)
\(\displaystyle \;\;\;=\frac{3m-m^2 \pm (m+1)\sqrt{m(m-8)}}{4}\)
Recall that the expression inside the radical must be greater than or equal to zero, thus, \(\displaystyle m(m-8)\ge 0\) and this gives
$m\le 0$ and $m \ge 8$.
Also, bear in mind that we're told $m, k$ are both integer values, so, $m(m-8)$ has to be a squre.
But if we apply the AM-GM inequality to the terms $m$ and $m-8$, we find
\(\displaystyle \frac{m+m-8}{2} \ge \sqrt{m(m-8)}\)
\(\displaystyle m-4 \ge \sqrt{m(m-8)}\)
$m\ge 8$ implies $m-4 \ge 4$ and this further implies $\sqrt{m(m-8)} \le 4$ and now, we will solve for $m$ by considering $\sqrt{m(m-8)}=0$ or $1$ or $2$ or $3$or $4$ and we will take whichever solution that gives the integer values of $m$.
\(\displaystyle \sqrt{m(m-8)}= 4\) gives irrational $m$ values.
\(\displaystyle \sqrt{m(m-8)}= 3\) gives $m=-1, 9$.
\(\displaystyle \sqrt{m(m-8)}= 2\) gives irrational $m$ values.
\(\displaystyle \sqrt{m(m-8)}= 1\) gives irrational $m$ values.
\(\displaystyle \sqrt{m(m-8)}= 0\) gives irrational $m=0, 8$ values but $m>0$, hence $m=8$.
Thus, by substituting each of the value of $m$ to the equation (*) above to find for its corresponding $k$ value, we end up with the following 4 solution sets, namely
$(m, k)=(-1, -1), (8, -10), (9, -6), (9, -21)$
But Opalg, I am sorry to tell you that you missed another solution set, which is $(m, k)=(8, -10)$.My solution:
By expanding and simplifying the given equation, we get
\(\displaystyle m^3+m^2k^2+mk+k^3=m^3-3m^2k+3mk^2-k^3\)
\(\displaystyle 2k^3+(m^2-3m)k^2+mk+3m^2k=0\)
Since $k \ne 0$, divide through the equation above by $k$, we have
\(\displaystyle 2k^2+(m^2-3m)k+m+3m^2=0\)
and solve for $k$ using the quadratic formula yields
\(\displaystyle k=\frac{-(m^2-3m) \pm \sqrt{(m^2-3m)^2-4(2)(m+3m^2)}}{2(2)}\)
\(\displaystyle \;\;\;=\frac{3m-m^2 \pm \sqrt{(m+1)^2(m(m-8))}}{4}\)
\(\displaystyle \;\;\;=\frac{3m-m^2 \pm (m+1)\sqrt{m(m-8)}}{4}\)
Recall that the expression inside the radical must be greater than or equal to zero, thus, \(\displaystyle m(m-8)\ge 0\) and this gives
$m\le 0$ and $m \ge 8$.
Also, bear in mind that we're told $m, k$ are both integer values, so, $m(m-8)$ has to be a squre.
But if we apply the AM-GM inequality to the terms $m$ and $m-8$, we find
\(\displaystyle \frac{m+m-8}{2} \ge \sqrt{m(m-8)}\)
\(\displaystyle m-4 \ge \sqrt{m(m-8)}\)
$m\ge 8$ implies $m-4 \ge 4$ and this further implies $\sqrt{m(m-8)} \le 4$ and now, we will solve for $m$ by considering $\sqrt{m(m-8)}=0$ or $1$ or $2$ or $3$or $4$ and we will take whichever solution that gives the integer values of $m$.
\(\displaystyle \sqrt{m(m-8)}= 4\) gives irrational $m$ values.
\(\displaystyle \sqrt{m(m-8)}= 3\) gives $m=-1, 9$.
\(\displaystyle \sqrt{m(m-8)}= 2\) gives irrational $m$ values.
\(\displaystyle \sqrt{m(m-8)}= 1\) gives irrational $m$ values.
\(\displaystyle \sqrt{m(m-8)}= 0\) gives irrational $m=0, 8$ values but $m>0$, hence $m=8$.
Thus, by substituting each of the value of $m$ to the equation (*) above to find for its corresponding $k$ value, we end up with the following 4 solution sets, namely
$(m, k)=(-1, -1), (8, -10), (9, -6), (9, -21)$
- Moderator
- #6
- Feb 7, 2012
- 2,785
Oops, I should have taken I like Serena's query more seriously. I was thinking that the only way you could have $x^2-16 = y^2$ was in the situation $5^2 - 4^2 = 3^2$. But in the solution to this problem, the situation $4^2 - 4^2 = 0^2$ is also possible. That leads to the solution $m=8$ and $k=-10$.