Double slit experiment in a Bubble Chamber

In summary, the idea of using a smoked environment in the double slit experiment to observe interference patterns is not feasible because the photons passing through the smoke would not have interacted with it and would still exhibit interference. Additionally, any attempt to measure which path the particles are taking would destroy the entanglement information necessary for interference to occur. This type of experiment has not been performed.
  • #1
JK423
Gold Member
394
7
Has this type of experiment ever been performed?
Firing electrons one at a time we can easily get the which-path information and see if interference dissapears or not. What actually happens?

Also, if we do the double slit experiment with a usual laser but in a smoked environment (in order to see the tracks before and after the slits) what would then happen?
But for this i actually got an idea. The tracks of the photons in the smoke are not equivalent to the tracks of the electrons in a bubble chamber because in the first case the photons are either absorbed or scattered by the atoms. So the photons that actually reach the wall after the slits haven't interacted with the smoke ==> we will observe the interference pattern. Is the idea correct?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
JK423 said:
Has this type of experiment ever been performed?
Firing electrons one at a time we can easily get the which-path information and see if interference dissapears or not. What actually happens?

Also, if we do the double slit experiment with a usual laser but in a smoked environment (in order to see the tracks before and after the slits) what would then happen?
But for this i actually got an idea. The tracks of the photons in the smoke are not equivalent to the tracks of the electrons in a bubble chamber because in the first case the photons are either absorbed or scattered by the atoms. So the photons that actually reach the wall after the slits haven't interacted with the smoke ==> we will observe the interference pattern. Is the idea correct?

The pattern would not be there in either case, if you measure which way the particle is going at all it destroys entanglement information. Also, the particles that made it through the smoke undisturbed would in itself have been measured to NOT be in the areas of the smoke particles, which is measurement enough so they to would lose their entanglement information.
 
Last edited:
  • #3


I can say that the double slit experiment has been performed in various forms, including in a bubble chamber. In fact, the bubble chamber is a type of particle detector that has been used extensively in high energy physics experiments, including the famous double slit experiment with electrons.

In the bubble chamber experiment, a beam of electrons is fired one at a time through a chamber filled with superheated liquid. As the electrons pass through the chamber, they leave a trail of bubbles in their wake, allowing scientists to observe their paths and interactions with the environment.

When firing electrons one at a time through the double slits in the bubble chamber, scientists can indeed determine the which-path information and see if interference disappears. This is due to the fact that the electrons, as individual particles, still exhibit wave-like behavior and can interfere with themselves, creating an interference pattern on the detector.

Regarding the idea of performing the double slit experiment with a laser in a smoked environment, it is important to consider the nature of the particles being used. Photons, being massless particles, do not leave a trail of bubbles like electrons do in the bubble chamber. Therefore, the tracks of the photons in the smoke would not be equivalent to the tracks of the electrons in the bubble chamber.

Furthermore, as the idea suggests, the photons that reach the wall after passing through the slits have not interacted with the smoke and therefore would not be affected by it. This means that the interference pattern would still be observed, as the photons have not been scattered or absorbed by the smoke.

In conclusion, the idea is correct in that the tracks of photons in a smoked environment would not be equivalent to the tracks of electrons in a bubble chamber. However, this does not affect the observation of interference in the double slit experiment, as the photons are not affected by the smoke in the same way as electrons are in the bubble chamber.
 

Related to Double slit experiment in a Bubble Chamber

1. What is a double slit experiment in a bubble chamber?

A double slit experiment in a bubble chamber is a scientific experiment used to study the behavior of subatomic particles. It involves sending a beam of particles through two parallel slits and observing the resulting pattern of bubbles in a chamber filled with a superheated liquid.

2. How does a bubble chamber work in a double slit experiment?

A bubble chamber works by creating a superheated liquid, typically a mixture of alcohol and water, in a chamber. When a charged particle passes through the liquid, it ionizes the atoms and creates a track of bubbles. By using a double slit, scientists can observe the interference patterns created by the particles as they pass through the slits.

3. What is the significance of the double slit experiment in a bubble chamber?

The double slit experiment in a bubble chamber has significant implications in the field of quantum mechanics. It demonstrates the wave-particle duality of subatomic particles, showing that they can act as both waves and particles. It also shows evidence of particle interference, which suggests that particles can interact with themselves.

4. How does the double slit experiment in a bubble chamber relate to the uncertainty principle?

The double slit experiment in a bubble chamber is closely related to the uncertainty principle, which states that it is impossible to know both the position and momentum of a particle with absolute certainty. This experiment shows that the path of a subatomic particle can be altered by its own observation, making it impossible to determine its exact path.

5. What are some real-world applications of the double slit experiment in a bubble chamber?

The double slit experiment in a bubble chamber has been used in various fields, including particle physics, quantum mechanics, and even medical imaging. It has helped scientists understand the behavior of subatomic particles and has also been used to study cosmic rays and other high-energy particles. Additionally, it has been used to develop advanced imaging techniques, such as positron emission tomography (PET) scans, which can detect and track particles in the body.

Similar threads

  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
36
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
18
Views
1K
Replies
32
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
232
Replies
18
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
49
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
680
Replies
26
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
803
Back
Top