Does Observing an Entangled Particle Affect Its Superposition?

In summary, you cannot keep virtual particles in boxes and observation isn't a continuous process that we start and stop.
  • #1
Allen_Wolf
48
4
Consider two virtual entangled particles (+ve & -ve particles) which emerged out of nothing.
We keep +ve and -ve in two different boxes. If the box containing +ve particle is closed and we do not observe the particle, then it is said to be in a superposition of +ve and -ve, Right? After some time, we open the box and observe the particle. We then again keep the particle back in the box and close it i.e. stop observing it. Will it again be back into a state of superposition of +ve and -ve?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Allen_Wolf said:
Consider two virtual entangled particles (+ve & -ve particles) which emerged out of nothing.

There is no such thing, so it's hard to consider it.
 
  • #3
Simply, can an already observed particle return to superposition when we stop observing it?
 
  • #4
Allen_Wolf said:
Simply, can an already observed particle return to superposition when we stop observing it?

It doesn't need to "return" to it. Whatever its state after the observation, it will be a superposition in some base.
 
  • #5
Allen_Wolf said:
Simply, can an already observed particle return to superposition when we stop observing it?
You seem to be confusing entanglement and superposition. Do you understand what these terms mean?
 
  • Like
Likes Vanadium 50
  • #6
Allen_Wolf said:
Consider two virtual entangled particles (+ve & -ve particles) which emerged out of nothing.
We keep +ve and -ve in two different boxes. If the box containing +ve particle is closed and we do not observe the particle, then it is said to be in a superposition of +ve and -ve, Right? After some time, we open the box and observe the particle. We then again keep the particle back in the box and close it i.e. stop observing it. Will it again be back into a state of superposition of +ve and -ve?
Measurement is not reversible. Once the superposition is destroyed by measurement, stopping observation will not restore the superposition.
 
  • Like
Likes Derek P and Allen_Wolf
  • #7
PeroK is right. It seems like you don't understand what a lot of the terms mean: at least virtual, superposition, entanglement. It might make more sense for you to re-pose your question, carefully checking to see that the words you use are the words you mean.

To answer the question you asked - which I suspect is not the question you intended to ask - if I measure a partcle's angular momentum along the z-direction, it's in a superposition of states along the x-direction.
 
  • Like
Likes Allen_Wolf
  • #8
Allen_Wolf said:
Consider two virtual entangled particles (+ve & -ve particles) which emerged out of nothing.
We keep +ve and -ve in two different boxes.

You can't keep virtual particles in boxes.
 
  • #9
Allen_Wolf said:
Consider two virtual entangled particles (+ve & -ve particles) which emerged out of nothing.
We keep +ve and -ve in two different boxes. If the box containing +ve particle is closed and we do not observe the particle, then it is said to be in a superposition of +ve and -ve, Right? After some time, we open the box and observe the particle. We then again keep the particle back in the box and close it i.e. stop observing it. Will it again be back into a state of superposition of +ve and -ve?
If you prepare a particle as a member of an entangled pair you cannot ascribe a state to it at all, you have to specify the other particle and talk about the state of the two together. Of course if you cleanly ignore the other particle you can talk about the one you still have but then it is simply a probability distribution - it might be +ve or it might be -ve.

I can see what you are trying to do. You want to specify a scenario where the particle is unambiguously in superposition. Far better to prepare your superposition by taking a single particle, putting it into a known state and then, if necessary, forcing it into a superposition of the two states you want. Doing this with charge is next to impossible, but with spin or polarisation it is quite easy.

Also, quantum states are nothing to do with opening boxes - Schroedinger's cat has a lot to answer for!

And observation isn't a continuous process that we start and stop. It's an interaction.

So let's re-cast your question:
Consider a particle in superposition. After some time, we observe the particle. After observation (assuming it is kept safe from other interactions) will it be back in superposition?
No, it will remain in the state you observed it to be in. That's kind of what observation means.
 

Related to Does Observing an Entangled Particle Affect Its Superposition?

1. What is entangled particle superposition?

Entangled particle superposition is a phenomenon in quantum mechanics where two or more particles become intertwined and share a quantum state, even when separated by a large distance. This means that any changes made to one particle will also affect the other, regardless of the distance between them.

2. How do particles become entangled?

Particles can become entangled through a process called quantum entanglement, where two particles interact and form a superposition of states. This can occur naturally or can be created in a laboratory setting.

3. What is the significance of entangled particle superposition?

Entangled particle superposition is significant because it challenges our understanding of classical physics and has potential applications in quantum computing, cryptography, and communication. It also provides insight into the interconnectedness of the universe at a fundamental level.

4. Can entangled particles be used for faster communication?

While entangled particles can transmit information instantly, they cannot be used for faster-than-light communication. This is because the actual information being transmitted is random and cannot be controlled or manipulated.

5. How is entangled particle superposition different from classical superposition?

Classical superposition refers to a physical system being in multiple states simultaneously, whereas entangled particle superposition involves two or more particles sharing a quantum state. In classical superposition, the states can be measured independently, but in entangled particle superposition, the states are correlated and cannot be measured separately.

Similar threads

  • Quantum Physics
Replies
27
Views
874
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
18
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
685
Replies
12
Views
273
  • Quantum Physics
5
Replies
143
Views
6K
  • Quantum Physics
3
Replies
99
Views
4K
Back
Top