Do moons always get more attention than the gas giant planets they orbit?

In summary, people are more excited about moons than gas giants due to their familiarity and potential for colonization. The moons of Saturn and Jupiter receive more attention, with Titan being particularly intriguing due to its terrestrial features and potential for life. The pressures on gas giants are too great for life to survive, making them less exciting for people. Some speculate that there may be a depth-zone in Saturn's atmosphere that could potentially sustain life.
  • #1
Simfish
Gold Member
823
2
It certainly seems like it. People are far more excited about Titan than they are about Saturn. And the same is true for several other Saturnian moons.

Same with Jupiter and its 4 biggest moons. People seem to care more about its 4 moons than Jupiter itself.

I'm no exception. But certainly, I sometimes wonder why. It's not just the prospect of life. The moons just seem more exciting for some reason. Strength in numbers is one thing.
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
It's because moons are terrestrial bodies, and traditionally what we think of when we think "worlds". Possibilities of a base on a Jovian planet? Nil. It doesn't exactly inspire much in most people. It doesn't even have a surface. Whereas the moons are well defined terrestrial bodies which we can imagine colonizing and settling. That's why they get much more attention in the mainstream press than do their Jovian masters: they're simply more familiar.
 
  • #3
Nabeshin said:
It's because moons are terrestrial bodies, and traditionally what we think of when we think "worlds". Possibilities of a base on a Jovian planet? Nil. It doesn't exactly inspire much in most people. It doesn't even have a surface. Whereas the moons are well defined terrestrial bodies which we can imagine colonizing and settling. That's why they get much more attention in the mainstream press than do their Jovian masters: they're simply more familiar.

I agree 100% Those photos from Titan were awe inspiring. So terrestrial, in fact, that if shown without explanatory captions they'd be taken for scenes on earth. Apparent shorelines with what appear to be river tributaries, mountain ranges, peaks, methane lakes, sufficeient atmospheric pressure to make spacesuite compression unnecessary. You name it and Titan has it. Then we have IO with its volcanically active surface and the ice covered moons with their tantalizing subsurface hidden seas and possible life.


In contrast the gas giants are merely inhospitable, roiling atmospheres covering an inaccessible surface under unimaginable pressures.
 
  • #4
The pressures on gas giants are so great, life can't survive. Hell, does anyone have the information on how deep probes get when they fall into the atmosphere before they're crushed by the pressure? They're basically stars that can't ignite in some cases.
 
  • #5
Pengwuino said:
The pressures on gas giants are so great, life can't survive. Hell, does anyone have the information on how deep probes get when they fall into the atmosphere before they're crushed by the pressure? They're basically stars that can't ignite in some cases.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galileo_( spacecraft )#Galileo.27s_atmospheric_entry_probe" This is the best data we've got about this sort of thing, the specifics are a bit vague however. So, although the signal stopped after going down 140km, it is thought that the actual body of the probe survived for much longer.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #6
Simfish said:
It certainly seems like it. People are far more excited about Titan than they are about Saturn. And the same is true for several other Saturnian moons.

Same with Jupiter and its 4 biggest moons. People seem to care more about its 4 moons than Jupiter itself.

I'm no exception. But certainly, I sometimes wonder why. It's not just the prospect of life. The moons just seem more exciting for some reason. Strength in numbers is one thing.

Quite simple really.Of the above mentioned planets,they both happen to be gas giants and hence don't share the typical "ideal Earth like planet look" so these get neglected.
 
  • #7
IMHO, the only way you could 'reside' on a Jovian is riding a balloon.

IIRC, though I am unable to confirm, there may be a depth-zone in Saturn's atmosphere where the temperature is 'temperate'. The pressure is probably elevated to several Bar, but no more than scuba gear could handle...
 

Related to Do moons always get more attention than the gas giant planets they orbit?

1. Why do moons often get more attention than the gas giant planets they orbit?

This is because moons are often more accessible and easier to study than the gas giant planets themselves. Also, some moons are considered potential candidates for extraterrestrial life, making them of great interest to scientists.

2. Are moons more interesting than gas giant planets?

It depends on the perspective of the scientist. Moons may be more interesting for those studying the possibility of extraterrestrial life, while gas giant planets may be more interesting for those studying their unique atmospheres and magnetic fields.

3. Do all moons receive the same amount of attention?

No, not all moons receive the same amount of attention. Moons that are closer to their gas giant planet and have unique characteristics, such as active volcanoes or subsurface oceans, tend to receive more attention from scientists.

4. How do scientists study moons and gas giant planets?

Scientists use various methods to study moons and gas giant planets, including spacecraft missions, telescopes, and computer simulations. Each method provides different types of data and insights into these celestial bodies.

5. Can moons provide information about their gas giant planet?

Yes, moons can provide valuable information about their gas giant planet, such as its mass, composition, and magnetic field. Studies of moons can also give insights into the formation and evolution of their gas giant planet.

Similar threads

Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
767
Replies
31
Views
5K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
34
Views
6K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
4
Views
2K
Back
Top