Distribution of Position in classical & quantum case

In summary, the difference between the classical and quantum cases is that in the classical case, the distribution of positions over time refers to the distribution of x values that we would find if we repeatedly sampled the position of one oscillator at different times. In the quantum case, the distribution over time refers to the distribution of x values from multiple identically prepared systems, since we cannot sample the same oscillator multiple times. Both cases result in a probability distribution of x values that can be plotted on a graph.
  • #1
WeiShan Ng
36
2
I am confused about the difference between the two
1.png

In Griffith's 2.3 The Harmonic Oscillator, he superimposes the quantum distribution and classical distribution and says
In the classical case we are talking about the distribution of positions over time for one oscillator, whereas in the quantum case we are talking about the distribution over an ensemble of identically prepared systems.

What I understand for quantum case is that ##|\Psi_{100} (x)|^2## gives the probability we will measure the particle at position ##x##. So if we were given a large set of the particles we will have a probability distribution of the measured ##x## and this distribution is what shown on the graph. However I don't quite understand what the distribution over time means in the classical case. I don't really see how the dependence of time fit in, since the graph is only x-dependence.
 

Attachments

  • 1.png
    1.png
    28.1 KB · Views: 902
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
WeiShan Ng said:
However I don't quite understand what the distribution over time means in the classical case. I don't really see how the dependence of time fit in, since the graph is only x-dependence.
It is the distribution of x values that we will find if we sample the position of the one and only particle in our one and only classical oscillator repeatedly at many different times.

In the quantum mechanical case, we can't do repeated sampling on the same oscillator, so we get one sample from each of many oscillators instead of many samples from one oscillator. But either way, we end up with a large number of x values so that we can plot their distribution.
 
  • Like
Likes WeiShan Ng

Related to Distribution of Position in classical & quantum case

1. What is the difference between classical and quantum distribution of position?

In classical physics, the distribution of position refers to the probability of finding a particle at a certain position in space. This probability is continuous and can take on any value. In contrast, in quantum physics, the distribution of position is described by a wave function, which gives the probability amplitude of finding a particle at a particular position. This probability amplitude is quantized, meaning it can only take on certain discrete values.

2. How is the distribution of position measured in classical and quantum systems?

In classical systems, the distribution of position is measured using tools such as rulers, measuring tapes, and other physical objects. In quantum systems, the distribution of position is measured using a particle detector, which interacts with the particle and gives information about its position.

3. What role does uncertainty play in the distribution of position in quantum systems?

In quantum physics, there is a fundamental principle known as the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, which states that the more precisely we know a particle's position, the less precisely we can know its momentum and vice versa. This means that in quantum systems, the distribution of position is inherently uncertain and can only be described probabilistically.

4. Can the distribution of position be described using classical mechanics?

No, the distribution of position in quantum systems cannot be described using classical mechanics. Classical mechanics breaks down at the quantum level and is unable to accurately predict the behavior of particles. The distribution of position in quantum systems must be described using the principles of quantum mechanics.

5. How does the distribution of position affect the behavior of particles in quantum systems?

The distribution of position in quantum systems has a direct impact on the behavior of particles. The wave function, which describes the distribution of position, determines the probability of a particle being in a certain position. This, in turn, affects the probability of a particle interacting with other particles or being measured in a certain position.

Similar threads

Replies
6
Views
861
Replies
26
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
805
Replies
10
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
757
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
903
Back
Top