Can Mirrors Create a Window to See into the Past?

  • Thread starter baker27marine
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Future
In summary, by setting up a perfect environment with two mirrors at a great distance apart, it is possible to create a window to see one minute into the past. However, it is much easier to see into the past by simply looking at the stars, as they are thousands of years old and their light has just reached us. This can be proven by comparing the image of a clock in a mirror to the actual time, but there is no independent proof for the stars.
  • #1
baker27marine
2
0
Let's say theoretically we can setup a perfect environment with two mirrors at a great distance apart. The distance is great enough to allow light to reflect off one mirror and not reach the other mirror until a full minute has elapsed. Could this in "theory" create a window to see one minute into the past?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Sure, but using this definition it's much easier to see into the past. Just look up at the stars and you're seeing them as they were thousands upon thousands of years ago.
 
  • #3
baker27marine said:
Let's say theoretically we can setup a perfect environment with two mirrors at a great distance apart. The distance is great enough to allow light to reflect off one mirror and not reach the other mirror until a full minute has elapsed. Could this in "theory" create a window to see one minute into the past?
Why do you need two mirrors? You could put just one mirror at a distance of 30 light-seconds away and then watch yourself as you were one minute earlier. You'd need one powerful telescope to resolve anything though. But you could easily prove that it worked by comparing the image of your clock in the mirror to what it says when you look at it directly.
 
  • #4
Vorde said:
Sure, but using this definition it's much easier to see into the past. Just look up at the stars and you're seeing them as they were thousands upon thousands of years ago.
Yes, using the definition of simultaneity that the stars we see in the sky are as they were thousands of years ago, we can look up in the sky and see them as they were thousands of years ago. There is no independent proof like there is in my previous post.
 
  • #5


While this idea may seem intriguing, it is not possible to create a window to see into the past using mirrors. Light travels at a fixed speed, so even with a large distance between the mirrors, the light would still reach the second mirror in less than a second, not a full minute. Additionally, even if the light did take a minute to reach the second mirror, it would simply be a delayed reflection of the present moment, not a glimpse into the past. The concept of time is complex and cannot be manipulated in this way. Scientifically, it is not possible to see into the past in this manner.
 

Related to Can Mirrors Create a Window to See into the Past?

1. Can we actually see the past?

Yes, we can see the past through various methods such as studying historical records, artifacts, and fossils, as well as using scientific techniques like radiocarbon dating and DNA analysis.

2. How is it possible to see the past if time travel is not yet possible?

Time travel in the traditional sense is not yet possible, but we can see the past through the use of telescopes, microscopes, and other scientific instruments that allow us to observe events that occurred in the past.

3. Can we see the past in real-time?

No, we cannot see the past in real-time. The speed of light is finite, so it takes time for light to travel from objects in the past to reach us in the present. Therefore, what we see is always a delayed version of events that occurred in the past.

4. Are there any limitations to seeing the past?

There are limitations to seeing the past, as some events may not have been recorded or preserved in a way that allows us to see them. Additionally, our understanding of the past is limited by the information that is available to us.

5. How does seeing the past help us understand the present and future?

Studying the past allows us to learn from past mistakes and successes, providing insight into how certain events and processes have shaped our world today. This understanding can inform our decisions and actions in the present, potentially impacting the future.

Similar threads

  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
29
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
58
Views
3K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • Special and General Relativity
3
Replies
89
Views
5K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
967
Replies
5
Views
674
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
8
Views
726
Back
Top