Calculating Partial Fractions find A, B and C

[lubo]

Homework Statement

For the equation shown below:

x²+2x+3 / (x²+9)(X-3) = Ax+B/(x²+9) + C/(x-3)

Find A, B and C

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

C = 1
B = 2
A = ?

Find C which = 1 by putting x=3 and working out x²+2x+3/(x²+9),

then multiply out equation to find A and B

x²+2x+3 = C(X²+9) + (Ax+B)/(X-3)

Combine terms to give:


x²+9+Ax²-3Ax+Bx-3B

= x²(1+A)+ x(B-3A) + 9 -3B

if coefficients = 0 then x² = 0 then A = -1
9-3B = 3 therefore B = 2

B-3A = 0 therefore A = 2/3 but I think this answer is wrong? I now have 2 answers for A?

Any ideas please and thanks.

 

[micromass]

Homework Statement

For the equation shown below:

x²+2x+3 / (x²+9)(X-3) = Ax+B/(x²+9) + C/(x-3)

Find A, B and C

Ok, so what do you mean exactly? The way you wrote it is

[tex]x^2 + 2x + \frac{3}{x^2 + 9}(x-3) = Ax + \frac{B}{x^2 +9} + \frac{C}{x-3}[/tex]

Is this what you meant?

If not, can you please please please please please please add brackets.

 

[lubo]

Homework Statement

For the equation shown below:

(x²+2x+3) / (x²+9)(X-3) = (Ax+B)/(x²+9) + C/(x-3)

Find A, B and C

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

C = 1
B = 2
A = ?

Find C which = 1 by putting x=3 and working out (x²+2x+3)/(x²+9),

then multiply out equation to find A and B

(x²+2x+3) = C(X²+9) + (Ax+B)(X-3)

Combine terms to give:


x²+9+Ax²-3Ax+Bx-3B

= (x²(1+A))+ (x(B-3A)) + 9 -3B

if coefficients = 0 then x² = 0 then A = -1
9-3B = 3 therefore B = 2

B-3A = 0 therefore A = 2/3 but I think this answer is wrong? I now have 2 answers for A?

Any ideas please and thanks.

I have changed it to reflect what you mean, thanks.

 

[HallsofIvy]

Homework Statement

For the equation shown below:

x²+2x+3 / (x²+9)(X-3) = Ax+B/(x²+9) + C/(x-3)

I presume you mean
[tex]\frac{Ax+ B}{x^2+ 9}+ \frac{C}{x- 3}[/tex]

Find A, B and C

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

C = 1
B = 2
A = ?

Find C which = 1 by putting x=3 and working out x²+2x+3/(x²+9),

I take it you meant that you first multiplied both sides by x- 3 so you had
[tex]\frac{x^2+ 2x+ 3}{x^2+ 9}= \frac{Ax+ B}{x^2+ 9}(x- 3)+ C[/tex]
Taking x= 3, this is [tex]\frac{9+ 6+ 3}{9+ 9}= 1= C[/tex].

then multiply out equation to find A and B

x²+2x+3 = C(X²+9) + (Ax+B)/(X-3)

Combine terms to give:

On the right side you mean? And (Ax+ B)(x- 3), not (Ax+ B)/(x- 3).

x²+9+Ax²-3Ax+Bx-3B

= x²(1+A)+ x(B-3A) + 9 -3B

if coefficients = 0 then x² = 0 then A = -1

The way you have it set up the coefficients are not equal to 0- they are equal to 1, 2, and 3, the coefficients on the left side of the equation. A+ 1= 1 gives A= 0. 9- 3B= 3 gives B= 2.
With A= 0, B= 2, B- 3A= 2 automatically.

9-3B = 3 therefore B = 2

B-3A = 0 therefore A = 2/3 but I think this answer is wrong? I now have 2 answers for A?

Any ideas please and thanks.

 

[micromass]

Thank you!

Homework Statement

For the equation shown below:

(x²+2x+3) / (x²+9)(X-3) = (Ax+B)/(x²+9) + C/(x-3)

Find A, B and C

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

C = 1
B = 2
A = ?

Find C which = 1 by putting x=3 and working out (x²+2x+3)/(x²+9),

then multiply out equation to find A and B

(x²+2x+3) = C(X²+9) + (Ax+B)(X-3)

Combine terms to give:


x²+9+Ax²-3Ax+Bx-3B

= (x²(1+A))+ (x(B-3A)) + 9 -3B

I agree until here, but

if coefficients = 0 then x² = 0 then A = -1
9-3B = 3 therefore B = 2

The coefficients shouldn't be equal to ##0##. What you have is

[tex]x^2 + 2x + 3 = (1+A)x^2 + (B-3A)x + (9 - 3B)[/tex]

 

[Ray Vickson]

Homework Statement

For the equation shown below:

x²+2x+3 / (x²+9)(X-3) = Ax+B/(x²+9) + C/(x-3)

Find A, B and C

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

C = 1
B = 2
A = ?

Find C which = 1 by putting x=3 and working out x²+2x+3/(x²+9),

then multiply out equation to find A and B

x²+2x+3 = C(X²+9) + (Ax+B)/(X-3)

Combine terms to give:


x²+9+Ax²-3Ax+Bx-3B

= x²(1+A)+ x(B-3A) + 9 -3B

if coefficients = 0 then x² = 0 then A = -1
9-3B = 3 therefore B = 2

B-3A = 0 therefore A = 2/3 but I think this answer is wrong? I now have 2 answers for A?

Any ideas please and thanks.

Do not make any assumptions about A,B and C: just write your function f(x) as
[tex] f(x) =\frac{x^2+2x+3}{(x^2+9)(x-3)} = \frac{Ax+B}{x^2+9}+\frac{C}{x-3} =
\frac{(A+C)x^2 +(B-3A)x + (9C-3B)}{(x^2+9)(x-3)} [/tex]
and so get three equations for the three parameters A,B,C. Solve them and see what you get.

 

[lubo]

micromass

The coefficients shouldn't be equal to 0. What you have is


x2+2x+3=(1+A)x2+(B−3A)x+(9−3B)

HallsofIvy

The way you have it set up the coefficients are not equal to 0- they are equal to 1, 2, and 3, the coefficients on the left side of the equation. A+ 1= 1 gives A= 0. 9- 3B= 3 gives B= 2.
With A= 0, B= 2, B- 3A= 2 automatically.

How did you find the Coefficients as I thought you could automatically say that they are equal to Zero?

 

[micromass]

micromass



HallsofIvy



How did you find the Coefficients as I thought you could automatically say that they are equal to Zero?

You have found the correct equation

[tex]x^2+2x+3 = C(x^2+9) + (Ax+B)(x-3)[/tex]

which must be satisfied for all ##x##. In particular, it must be satisfied for ##x=3##. Using that, we get ##C=1##. Thus we have that the following equation

[tex]x^2+2x+3 = x^2+9 + (Ax+B)(x-3)[/tex]

must be satisfied for all ##x##. So what you did is work out the right-hand side, to get

[tex]x^2 + 2x + 3 = x^2 + 9 + Ax^2 - 3Ax + Bx - 3B[/tex]

which is

[tex]x^2 + 2x + 3 = (1 + A)x^2 + (B - 3A)x + (9-3B)[/tex]

which again must be satisfied for all ##x##. Thus we get the equations

[tex]1 = 1+A,~2 = B-3A,~3=9-3B[/tex]

 

[lubo]

You have found the correct equation


[tex]x^2 + 2x + 3 = (1 + A)x^2 + (B - 3A)x + (9-3B)[/tex]

which again must be satisfied for all ##x##. Thus we get the equations

[tex]1 = 1+A,~2 = B-3A,~3=9-3B[/tex]

Why should 1 = 1+A

Why 2 = B-3A

Why 3=9-3B

I found 9-3B = 3 because I put x = 0 in (x^2 + 2x + 3)

This is what I am failing to understand i.e. why choose these and not just Zero?

Thanks again as I realize this must be obvious to you.

 

[micromass]

Why should 1 = 1+A

Why 2 = B-3A

Why 3=9-3B

I found 9-3B = 3 because I put x = 0 in (x^2 + 2x + 3)

This is what I am failing to understand i.e. why choose these and not just Zero?

Thanks again as I realize this must be obvious to you.

OK, that is a good question. So assume that there exist ##A## and ##B## such that

$$x^2+2x+3=(1+A)x^2+(B−3A)x+(9−3B)~~~~(1)$$

are true all ##x##. In particular, it must be satisfied for ##x=0##. This gets us the equation

[tex]3 = 9-3B~~~~(2)[/tex]

But it must also be true for ##x=1##, which gets us

[tex]1^2 + 2\cdot 1 + 3 = (1+A) + (B-3A) + (9 - 3B)~~~~(3)[/tex]

And it must also be true for ##x=-1##, which gets us

[tex](-1)^2 + 2\cdot (-1) + 3 = (1+A) -(B-3A) +(9 - 3B)~~~~(4)[/tex]

Subtracting ##(2)## from ##(3)## and ##(4)## leaves us with the two equations

[tex]1 + 2 = (1+A) + (B-3A)~~~~(3^\prime)[/tex]

and

[tex]1 - 2 = (1+A) - (B-3A)~~~~(4^\prime)[/tex]

Adding up these two gets us

[tex]2 = 2(1+A)[/tex]

or just ##(1+A) = 1## which I call ##(5)##. Subtracting ##(5)## from ##(3^\prime)## then gets us

[tex]2 = B-3A[/tex]

So we finally see that we have the equations

[tex]1+A = 1,~2= B-3A,~3=9-3B[/tex]

Of course, I didn't do all that just to find these equations. What I said was simply that since

$$x^2+2x+3=(1+A)x^2+(B−3A)x+(9−3B)$$

must be true for all ##x##, then all the coefficients must equal. So the coefficients of ##x^2## must equal, which gets us ##1+A=1##. The coefficients of ##x## must equal, which gets us ##2 = B-3A##, and the constant terms must equal, so ##3 = 9-3B##.
But then you can ask why must the coefficients equal? Well, my above (long) arguments proves it. In general, whenever you are in the situation that

[tex]Ax^2 + Bx + C = \alpha x^2 + \beta x + \gamma[/tex]

you can apply my argument above and get that ##A=\alpha##, ##B=\beta## and ##C=\gamma##. So all coefficients equal.

 

[LCKurtz]

. In general, whenever you are in the situation that

[tex]Ax^2 + Bx + C = \alpha x^2 + \beta x + \gamma[/tex]

you can apply my argument above and get that ##A=\alpha##, ##B=\beta## and ##C=\gamma##. So all coefficients equal.

Or, when you have ##f(x)\equiv g(x)## you can use that ##f(0) = g(0),
~f'(0) = g'(0),~ f''(0) = g''(0)## to get the constants equal in this example.

 

[micromass]

Or, when you have ##f(x)\equiv g(x)## you can use that ##f(0) = g(0),
~f'(0) = g'(0),~ f''(0) = g''(0)## to get the constants equal in this example.

Yes, but this is in the precalculus forum, so I didn't want to use the easier way of derivatives.

 

[LCKurtz]

Yes, but this is in the precalculus forum, so I didn't want to use the easier way of derivatives.

I assumed that. But since they post all kinds of calculus and beyond stuff in that forum anyway, and students don't usually encounter partial fractions for anything before calculus, I'm guessing the OP is in a calculus course and might appreciate the derivative method.

 

[SammyS]

Equating coefficients (of any particular power of x) is a method that's often used per-calculus.

Two polynomials are equivalent only if their coefficients "match up" .