Buoyancy in Compressed Air: Can Objects Float or Will They Fall Due to Gravity?

[Boy@n]

If air would be compressed to have equal pressure to that of water would objects which are buoyant in water be buoyant in such compressed air too or would they still fall down due to Earth gravity?

Or asking differently, what would have to be the pressure of air (lower, equal or higher than that of water) to make, say wooden ball, stop falling in it and instead go up with the same speed as if it were in water?

 

[tuoni]

I don't think it's really a matter of pressure, but density. So for a wooden ball to float in air as it would in water, you would have to compress air (according to the ideal gas law) until it reaches the same density as water.

[tex]p = \rho \cdot \frac{RT}{M}[/tex]

p -- pressure (Pa)
ρ -- density (kg/m^3) [= 1000]
R -- specific gas constant (J/[kg·K]) [~ 286.9]
M -- molar mass (kg/mol) [~ 28.97e-3]
T -- temperature (K) [= 288.15]

The answer would be approx. 2.854 GPa (more than 28,000 times the normal atmospheric pressure!).

Someone correct me if I'm wrong.

 

[jgm340]

At the surface of anybody of water, the pressure of the air is actually equal to the pressure of the water!

What makes an object float in water has to do with the density. The high density of water causes a very large pressure gradient. It turns out that the pressure only a foot down is so much greater than the pressure at the surface that the resulting force (buoyancy) is enough to counteract the force of gravity.

If you were to compress a gas to have the same density as water, then it would form the same pressure gradient, and any object which could float in water could float in the gas too. However, this would require huge amounts of pressure!

Now, there's a stumbling block that would prevent you from getting air at exactly the same density as water. It would need to be in the liquid phase to be so dense, and that liquid would likely not be very compressible.

EDIT: ninja'd!

 

[Boy@n]

In relation I'd ask this...

Aren't there submarines with the same internal pressure of air as the outside water pressure, so when deep under water a diver can go in/out of water through opening?

Or is that solved in a different manner? So that pressure and density of internal air is lower than the pressure and density of external water, but if so, how is water prevented from filling up submarine with water?

 

[DaveC426913]

In relation I'd ask this...

Aren't there submarines with the same internal pressure of air as the outside water pressure, so when deep under water a diver can go in/out of water through opening?

Yes.

 

[Boy@n]

And this...

Imagine a tube in 'U' shape being closed on both ends. Left side of tube is filled with air, right side with water. To keep air and water separate exactly at the bottom-middle what would need to be the pressure / density of air?

 

[Boy@n]

Yes.

And how that works? Can you describe it shortly or point me to some website covering that? (I've googled it but no luck...)

When a diver jumps in water, through that opening, is as much water as the diver's weight pushed inside the submarine and perhaps they just pump surplus of water out?

 

[Boy@n]

I don't think it's really a matter of pressure, but density.

Thought so, but increase in density can be easily done by increassing pressure.

The answer would be approx. 2.854 GPa (more than 28,000 times the normal atmospheric pressure!).

Interesting, especially since water is 'just' about 1000 times denser than the 'normal' air.

 

[tuoni]

And this...

Imagine a tube in 'U' shape being closed on both ends. Left side of tube is filled with air, right side with water. To keep air and water separate exactly at the bottom-middle what would need to be the pressure / density of air?

Assuming a gravitational frame of reference, you would need to equate the pressure of the air and water column.

[tex]p_{air} = p_{water}[/tex]

[tex]\left( \frac{F}{A} \right)_{air} = \left( \frac{F}{A} \right)_{water}[/tex]

[tex]a_{g} \left( \frac{m}{A} \right)_{air} = a_{g} \left( \frac{m}{A} \right)_{water}[/tex]

[tex]a_{g} \left( \frac{\rho V}{A} \right)_{air} = a_{g} \left( \frac{\rho V}{A} \right)_{water}[/tex]

[tex]a_{g} \left( \rho s \right)_{air} = a_{g} \left( \rho s \right)_{water}[/tex]

[tex]a_{g} \left( \frac{pMs}{RT} \right)_{air} = a_{g} (\rho s)_{water}[/tex]

[tex]p_{air} = \rho_{water} \cdot \frac{s_{water}}{s_{air}} \cdot \left( \frac{RT}{M} \right)_{air}[/tex]

 

[Boy@n]

Thanks tuoni.

At normal/usual conditions how many times would the pressure of that air have to be higher than normal atmospheric pressure?

 

[tuoni]

Thanks tuoni.

At normal/usual conditions how many times would the pressure of that air have to be higher than normal atmospheric pressure?

That depends on the amount of water you have. In this case, the U-shaped tube, the area is identical for both, so it only depends on the height of each column. If identical, it would be over 28,000 times the normal atmospheric pressure. If the water column was twice as high, it would be double that, over 56,000 times the normal atmospheric pressure.

 

[Boy@n]

... it would be over 28,000 times the normal atmospheric pressure.

Is such pressure for air even possible?

 

[Yeti08]

What I don't think tuoni is considering is that air will be far from an ideal gas at such high pressures. From my data the pressure at which air and water will have the same density is about 517 MPa or about 5100 atmospheres at 25C. Of course this would be a supercritical fluid, and I'm not sure how a mixture like air would actually behave under these conditions.

 

[Boy@n]

From my data the pressure at which air and water will have the same density is about 517 MPa or about 5100 atmospheres at 25C. Of course this would be a supercritical fluid, and I'm not sure how a mixture like air would actually behave under these conditions.

Would a wooden object still free fall, due to Earth gravity, in such dense air (517 MPa)?

Also, why such difference from other two posters who said that density of air, to equal that of water, would have to be 28000 atmospheres?

 

[DaveC426913]

Would a wooden object still free fall, due to Earth gravity, in such dense air (517 MPa)?

Also, why such difference from other two posters who said that density of air, to equal that of water, would have to be 28000 atmospheres?

5100 and 28000 differ by less than one order of magnitude. Seeing as both are more than 4 orders of magnitude above ambient, do the details really matter?

 

[Yeti08]

Would a wooden object still free fall, due to Earth gravity, in such dense air (517 MPa)?

Also, why such difference from other two posters who said that density of air, to equal that of water, would have to be 28000 atmospheres?

At that density things that would normally float in water would float on air - though as I said before it is supercritical and actually more dense than liquid air at most temperatures. The difference between my answer and the previous is that mine uses real gas information rather than ideal gas - as gases are compressed they become less ideal and the ideal gas law becomes less accurate.

 

[Boy@n]

I see. Thanks to all for detailed explanations.