Amazon Turk woes: BOTS the software we love to hate?

In summary, there has been a recent concern among psychologists about the quality of data collected from Amazon's Mechanical Turk platform. This was sparked by a graduate student's observation of nonsense answers and duplicate GPS locations in his own survey results. Other researchers have also reported similar issues, leading to speculation about the use of bots on the platform.
  • #1
14,788
9,124
https://www.wired.com/story/amazon-mechanical-turk-bot-panic/

FOR THE PAST week, psychologists all over America have been freaking out.

The cause of their agita was an observation by a psychology graduate student from the University of Minnesota named Max Hui Bai. Like many researchers, Bai uses Amazon’s Mechanical Turk platform, where individuals sign up to complete simple tasks, such as taking surveys for academics or marketers, and earn a low fee. On Tuesday, August 7, he posed a simple question in a Facebook group for psychology researchers: "Have anyone used Mturk in the last few weeks and notice any quality drop?"

As he would later elaborate in a blog post, Bai had found that the surveys he conducted with MTurk were full of nonsense answers to open-ended questions and respondents with duplicate GPS locations. He said he had to throw out nearly half of the data in his most recent survey, a sharp increase from what he was used to seeing. His Facebook post garnered 181 comments, with other researchers describing similar signs of low-quality data in their own recent work. A number of them wondered if the culprit was bots—automated programs mimicking human behavior, not the actual human labor MTurk is supposed to supply.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Really? [sarcasm]Surprise, surprise. Social scientists.[/sarcasm] :rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
  • Like
Likes jedishrfu

1. What is Amazon Turk?

Amazon Turk is an online platform that allows businesses and researchers to outsource small tasks, known as Human Intelligence Tasks (HITs), to a large pool of workers, known as Turkers. These tasks can range from data entry to image labeling and are completed for a small payment.

2. What are "BOTS" in the context of Amazon Turk?

"BOTS" refers to software programs that are designed to automatically complete HITs on Amazon Turk without any human involvement. These programs are created to take advantage of the quick and easy tasks on the platform and can complete them at a much faster rate than human workers.

3. Why are BOTS a problem on Amazon Turk?

BOTS are a problem on Amazon Turk because they can disrupt the fair and competitive nature of the platform. They can complete tasks faster than human workers, leading to unfair advantages for requesters and creating a disadvantage for legitimate Turkers.

4. How do BOTS impact the Amazon Turk community?

BOTS can negatively impact the Amazon Turk community by decreasing the availability of HITs for human workers, leading to fewer opportunities for them to earn money. They also contribute to a decrease in the quality of work on the platform, as BOTS are not able to perform tasks as accurately as human workers.

5. What measures are being taken to address the BOTS issue on Amazon Turk?

Amazon Turk has implemented various measures to combat the use of BOTS, such as implementing CAPTCHAs and IP address restrictions. They also encourage requesters to use quality control tools to detect and reject BOTS' submissions. Additionally, the community itself has created tools and forums to help identify and report BOTS to Amazon Turk.

Similar threads

  • MATLAB, Maple, Mathematica, LaTeX
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top