What is Bohmian mechanics: Definition and 69 Discussions

The de Broglie–Bohm theory, also known as the pilot wave theory, Bohmian mechanics, Bohm's interpretation, and the causal interpretation, is an interpretation of quantum mechanics. In addition to the wavefunction, it also postulates an actual configuration of particles exists even when unobserved. The evolution over time of the configuration of all particles is defined by a guiding equation. The evolution of the wave function over time is given by the Schrödinger equation. The theory is named after Louis de Broglie (1892–1987) and David Bohm (1917–1992).
The theory is deterministic and explicitly nonlocal: the velocity of any one particle depends on the value of the guiding equation, which depends on the configuration of the system given by its wave function; the latter depends on the boundary conditions of the system, which, in principle, may be the entire universe.
The theory results in a measurement formalism, analogous to thermodynamics for classical mechanics, that yields the standard quantum formalism generally associated with the Copenhagen interpretation. The theory's explicit non-locality resolves the "measurement problem", which is conventionally delegated to the topic of interpretations of quantum mechanics in the Copenhagen interpretation.
The Born rule in Broglie–Bohm theory is not a basic law. Rather, in this theory, the link between the probability density and the wave function has the status of a hypothesis, called the "quantum equilibrium hypothesis", which is additional to the basic principles governing the wave function.
The theory was historically developed in the 1920s by de Broglie, who, in 1927, was persuaded to abandon it in favour of the then-mainstream Copenhagen interpretation. David Bohm, dissatisfied with the prevailing orthodoxy, rediscovered de Broglie's pilot-wave theory in 1952. Bohm's suggestions were not then widely received, partly due to reasons unrelated to their content, such as Bohm's youthful communist affiliations. De Broglie–Bohm theory was widely deemed unacceptable by mainstream theorists, mostly because of its explicit non-locality. Bell's theorem (1964) was inspired by Bell's discovery of Bohm's work; he wondered whether the theory's obvious nonlocality could be eliminated. Since the 1990s, there has been renewed interest in formulating extensions to de Broglie–Bohm theory, attempting to reconcile it with special relativity and quantum field theory, besides other features such as spin or curved spatial geometries.The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy article on quantum decoherence groups "approaches to quantum mechanics" into five groups, of which "pilot-wave theories" are one (the others are the Copenhagen interpretation, objective collapse theories, many-worlds interpretations and modal interpretations).
There are several equivalent mathematical formulations of the theory, and it is known by a number of names. The de Broglie wave has a macroscopic analogy termed Faraday wave.

View More On Wikipedia.org
  1. M

    Status of Relativistic Bohmian Mechanics: What Open Questions Remain?

    I am curious about recent progress in relativistic Bohmian mechanics. Finding a review is proving difficult (The closest I can find is a conference paper by H. Nikolic). My understanding is a set of dynamical variables are identified as "real" (beables), and their (usually deterministic)...
  2. P

    Thoughts on Bohmian Mechanics?

    Hi, I'm an undergraduate in college, majoring in physics, and I just finished a course in Quantum Mechanics. I was left very disappointed with the interpretation presented, and this winter I am starting to do research with a professor in the field of Bohmian Mechanics. However, I am finding...
  3. atyy

    Must position be continuous in Bohmian mechanics?

    Here I'm thinking of a single free particle obeying the Schroedinger equation. The ensemble refers to multiple experiments with a single particle in which the initial wave function is the same. If I naively imagine that there is such a thing as a wave function that is delta function, in...
  4. bohm2

    Legget's inequality and Bohmian mechanics

    Leaving aside the debatable point about whether bell's violation rules out all local theories or just local realism, is there general agreement that if the assumptions are valid, violation of Leggett's inequalities rules out any non-local model that treats properties other than position as real...
  5. bohm2

    Is Bohmian Mechanics incompatible with free will/choice?

    There has been some back and forth debate between Colbeck et al. vs. Ghirardi et al. on whether a recent no-go theorem by Colbeck and Renner would imply that Bohmian Mechanics is incompatible with free will/choice. I don't fully understand all the arguments but I thought I'd post them here in...
  6. H

    Bohmian mechanics as 'complete' theory

    Hello, forum! I am puzzling my way through some interpretation. In the famous EPR paper, the authors ask whether quantum mechanics is a 'complete' theory in the sense of whether or not the wave function completely describes the physical circumstances in question. EPR conclude that it is not...
  7. atyy

    Is Bohmian Mechanics deterministic?

    I've also heard that Bohmian mechanics is deterministic (eg. http://arxiv.org/abs/1206.1084, quote from Bell, p17). But in all presentations (eg. http://arxiv.org/abs/1206.1084, p30) I've come across so far, Bohmian mechanics needs an initial probability distribution. If probability over the...
  8. M

    Do the SQUID experiments falsify Bohmian mechanics?

    In the experiments done with superconducting rings by Delft and Stony Brook, currents are shown to be moving in both directions simultaneously. Doesn't this falsify the idea that a pilot wave detemines a single evolution of the states? Can that be explained without the addition of multiple...
  9. StevieTNZ

    Bohmian Mechanics - One Quick Question

    Can you consider the particles in Bohmian Mechanics mixtures?
  10. R

    The Refutation of Bohmian Mechanics

    Bohmian Mechanics conflicts with so many observational facts: 1. Bohmian Mechanics severely violates Lorentz Invariance because the wave function is simultaneously aware of all configuration changes of all matter in all locations in the entire universe at once (instantaneously and nonlocality...
  11. C

    Quantum Potential in Bohmian Mechanics?

    What is the meaning of quantum potential in de broglie-bohm theory? Is that the "hidden variable"? Or are the positions of particles "hidden variables"? As far as I see, some references explains theory with quantum potential (Bohm, Holland) but some references explains it with guiding...
  12. Demystifier

    Feynman and Bohmian mechanics (at the macroscopic level)

    I have just found out that Feynman also (re)discovered (some essential aspects of) Bohmian mechanics a long time ago, in his "Feynman Lectures on Physics" part III. Namely, in the last chapter devoted to superconductivity as macroscopic manifestation of quantum mechanics, he derives equations...
  13. P

    Bohmian Mechanics and the two slit experiment

    I am trying to understand the essentials of the Bohmian interpretation of quantum mechanics (BI),and my (many) difficulties start with his description of the two slit experiment.As I understand it,Bohm asserts that every quantum particle has associated with it a quantum potential or guiding...
  14. PRODOS

    Bohmian Mechanics: Do photons travel faster than c in double slit experiment?

    In the double slit experiment, Bohmian Mechanics http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-bohm/#2s" the paths of real particles traveling from the two slits to the detector to look like something like this: The above image shows particles traveling in non-straight paths. The diagram below...
  15. U

    New Developments in Bohmian Mechanics

    recently,i read some papers about bohmian mechanics.i want someone to introduce me the newest developments in this filed,thank you
  16. DrChinese

    The Pros and Cons of Bohmian Mechanics

    This is a discussion aimed towards gaining a better understanding of Bohmian Mechanics (BM) - at least on my part. I would like to see BM in the best light possible. My starting point in this journey is a reference to Sheldon Goldstein's summary in the Stanford Encyclopedia: Bohmian...
  17. E

    Path integral formulation of Bohmian mechanics

    If Bohmain mechanics is true then the path integral: \int{d[\phi]}e^{(i/\hbar)\int_{a}^{b}Ldt where the Lagrangian is: L=(1/2)m(dx/dt)^{2}-V(x)+(\hbar^{2}/2m)\nabla^{2}\rho should be equal to its semiclassical expansion...(as in both cases are trajectories) my question is how would one...
  18. G

    Bohmian Mechanics: Recent Readings & Experimental Evidence

    Recently, I read Bohm's articles explaining his interpretation of Quantum Mechanics. I did not find anything "bad" with it, so why didn't anybody pursue it further? Any experimental evidence against its predictions?
  19. E

    Does Bohmian Mechanics Offer a True Alternative to Quantum Mechanics?

    in fact i think bell,s theorem says no, but i do not know if there are another thing that would allow it to be true..is bohmian mechanics true?...if not why people continues working on it...?
Back
Top