Recent content by msumm21

  1. M

    B Intuition for time dilation in a cesium clock

    Let me try to word this another way. I'm trying to see how, when viewing a process (transition between energy levels) from a relatively moving frame, the process appears to occur slower. I know you could answer "because time dilates," but I'm looking for a slightly deeper explanation. Again...
  2. M

    B Intuition for time dilation in a cesium clock

    My question boils down to seeing how time dilation manifests in spontaneous transitions between energy levels (i.e. why looking at spontaneous transitions in a moving frame would appear to slow). Some good surrounding info in above posts, the link below might give the answer I'm looking for...
  3. M

    B Intuition for time dilation in a cesium clock

    For the 4-force in SR you need a 1/gamma in the spring constant, the result is gamma^2 under the sqrt, hence the gamma overall, matching the time dilation equation.
  4. M

    B Intuition for time dilation in a cesium clock

    Thanks all. Some of you mentioned a spring mass system and I can see how time dilation for that would naturally follow from relativistic mass increase, analogous to the light clock using constant c. There are many posts about time itself changes and therefore everything changes, understood...
  5. M

    B Intuition for time dilation in a cesium clock

    I know SR says experimental results are = in all frames and hence the transitions (and everything) must slow like the "light clock", but what I'm looking for is something analogous to the light clock argument, you might call it a more "direct" explanation (if it exists). Edit: might also call...
  6. M

    B Intuition for time dilation in a cesium clock

    A common way to introduce time dilation is to show the example of a "light clock" which bounces photons back/forth and ticks each time a photon passes a certain point. Wikipedia does it this way, for example. From such a clock, it's easy to see why the constancy of the speed of light would...
  7. M

    I From our reference frame, how would a black hole ever form?

    Copy, thanks. I am thinking in our proper time, so in our proper time the BH never forms, right. Understand your point with some time coordinates it does form.
  8. M

    I From our reference frame, how would a black hole ever form?

    Looking at Kruskal diagrams, it seems to me we should not be able to see evidence of black holes. Assuming our frame is a hyperbola of roughly constant ##r## in such a diagram, as the black hole's constituent mass comes together time slows (from our POV) to the extent that it never crosses the...
  9. M

    I Minkowski metric and proper time interpretation

    Oh yes I think I'm getting it now, thanks!
  10. M

    I Minkowski metric and proper time interpretation

    The book I'm reading (General Relativity: The Theoretical Minimum by Susskind) says the metric is approximately ##d\tau^2 = (1+2gy)dt^2 - dy^2## where the grav potential is ##gy## but yes I see this doesn't jive with stuff I see on Wikipedia. I must have misunderstood what this metric was...
  11. M

    I Minkowski metric and proper time interpretation

    Using an example of 1 space dimension and 1 time dimension, consider the metric ##d\tau^2 = a dt^2 - dx^2## near a heavy mass (##a>1##). From what I've read a clock ticks slower near a heavy mass, as viewed from an observer far away. A clock tick would be representative of ##d\tau## right...
  12. M

    I Alternative Ways to Realize Invariance: Lorentz Transformation

    The Lorentz transformation ensures different inertial observers measure the same speed of light. Are there other transformations, or other ways to setup a "space-time" that also have this property of invariance? Is the Lorentz transformation the unique solution?
  13. M

    I States of equal energy are equally probable

    Thanks for the response. It seems like that argument, applied to a weighted die, would say that each side is equally probable. If I know the system (die), but not the state it is in (side faced up after rolling), then the condition of max uncertainty is a function of the weighting, not...
  14. M

    I States of equal energy are equally probable

    I'm reading "Statistical Mechanics: A Set of Lectures" by Feynman. On page 1 it says that, for a system in thermal equilibrium, the probabilities of being in two states of the same energy are equal. I'm wondering if this is an empirical observation or if it can be derived from QM?
  15. M

    I Do Bell Experiments Show Local Overlap of Wave Functions Before Measurement?

    I think I understand. I realize that calling the entangled pair local to one another (because the wave function overlaps) is a bit satisfying at first, but of course there's still something "nonlocal" in a sense to "spread the information around the wavefunction's spatial extent." Since the...
Back
Top