Recent content by mathwonk

  1. M

    Linear Algebra Determinant proof

    note that geometrically this is the fact that the area of a parallelogram equals that of the rectangle with same height and base.
  2. M

    What are Good Books on Tensors for Understanding Einstein's Field Equation?

    Orodruin to the rescue! As Orodruin makes clear, a map from T to T*, (where T is the tangent space), corresponds to a tensor of type (0,2), say by rule 1), post #31, since L(T,T*) ≈ T*(tens)T*. Thus its inverse is a map from T* to T, and by the isomorphism L(T*,T) ≈ T**(tens)T ≈ T(tens)T, the...
  3. M

    What are Good Books on Tensors for Understanding Einstein's Field Equation?

    To someone like me, i.e. me, who knows nothing of this, and never heard of Einstein's field equations before, wikipedia looks actually useful. It is an equation between two tensors of type (0,2). (I have been calling them type (2,0)), i.e. 2-covariant tensors, linear combinations of...
  4. M

    What are Good Books on Tensors for Understanding Einstein's Field Equation?

    Ok, so I think of it this way now: in physics there are various operations on (fields of) vectors taking them linearly or multi-linearly to other (fields of) vectors, and it is useful for calculations to represent these operations as tensor fields, hence entirely in terms of tensor products of...
  5. M

    What are Good Books on Tensors for Understanding Einstein's Field Equation?

    Ah yes, proceeding from Orodriuin's guidance, we can see what kind of tensor the Riemann curvature should be: We need the basic insight that the map VxV-->V(tens)V sending <v,w> to v(tens)w, is bilinear, and that thus composing with any linear map out of V(tens)V yields another bilinear map...
  6. M

    What are Good Books on Tensors for Understanding Einstein's Field Equation?

    You are reminding me of how stunned I was when my professor asked why I was so sure, when given a function f(x), that x was the variable and f the function. Why not define x(f) to be f(x), and then f was the variable? I.e. if F is the space of all k valued functions on the set X, then we have...
  7. M

    What are Good Books on Tensors for Understanding Einstein's Field Equation?

    well I was enjoying the excerpt of Biennow on amazon https://www.amazon.com/Mathematical-Methods-Physics-Engineering-Mattias-ebook/dp/B086H3LMZF/?tag=pfamazon01-20 until it ran out just starting tensors, but discovered that physicists like tensors so much they use them to represent objects that...
  8. M

    What are Good Books on Tensors for Understanding Einstein's Field Equation?

    Well a quick look at Wikipedia shows that the output of a tensor can be more general than a function, e.g. the Riemann curvature tensor ( a slight elaboration on the formula in post #21) takes a triple of vector fields and outputs a vector field. Namely the commutator of two vector fields is...
  9. M

    What are Good Books on Tensors for Understanding Einstein's Field Equation?

    I am a mathematician, and to me, if you already know what the tangent bundle is, and its dual the cotangent bundle, and hence know what tangent and cotangent vector fields are, then the 20 page explanation in Spivak's chapter 4, of his Comprehensive introduction to differential geometry, is as...
  10. M

    Proving well ordering principle from Peano Axioms

    quantifiers are actually essential for precise statements. recall existential quantifiers affirm a statement for at least one element of a given set, while universal quantifiers do so for all such elements. although it may sound otherwise, existential statements are often stronger than...
  11. M

    Proving well ordering principle from Peano Axioms

    Excellent, except to be picky, you have omitted some existential quantifiers, e.g. in line minus 17, it should say "there exists h such that". Of course also in line -16 there is an implied universal quantifier. nice work overall.
  12. M

    Other What's the point of a thesis?

    I agree especially with points made by Choppy and CrysPhys: first of all, the purpose of writing the thesis, for most of us, is to strengthen the author's research chops to the point of being ready to do, and write up, competitive research - i.e. it is a learning experience for the author of...
  13. M

    Quantum Math Textbooks to Read Before Starting QFT

    When I was a young researcher (in pure mathematics), incompletely trained (by my own fault), I learned to use information I did not understand. I was happy to find out that was possible, as it helped me make research progress in less time. There was some loss of mental security since I had to...
  14. M

    I General Linear Group GL(n) on Vector Spaces and canonical pairing invariance

    In my opinion, GL(n) acts, not on V, but on k^n, so it acts on the n dimensional space V only after choosing an ordered basis for V, (and thus also an ordered dual basis for V*). Then if a is a covector in V*, represented by a row vector, and v is a vector in V, represented by a column vector...
  15. M

    Conjugate vs Complex Conjugate

    some more detail: let F = Q(t) where t^2 =2. then elements of F have form z = a+bt, for rational a and b. define z’ = a-bt to be the conjugate of z. then claim if z = a +bt and w = c+dt, then z’w’ = (zw)’, i.e. the conjugate of a product of elements of F equals the product of their...
Back
Top