Recent content by john baez

  1. john baez

    A Supersymmetry: A Fundamental Principle or Just Bookkeeping?

    The principle is that the laws of nature should have symmetries that unify bosons and fermions. Since bosons describe forces - generally speaking - while fermions describe matter, this would mean a unification of forces with matter. It's surprisingly tricky to come up with laws that unify...
  2. john baez

    A Can the geodesic equation be derived from the EFE in a certain limit?

    Yes, and that's why Einstein wanted to derive the geodesic equation for point particles as a limiting case of a deeper field-theoretic description: Einstein's equations describing the motion of "black holes" (though he didn't know they were black holes). Naively, it should be true that if you...
  3. john baez

    I Cosmic Censorship: Does it Hold?

    Whoops, I'll fix that in the FAQ. The paper by Christodoulou is too technical for the FAQ, btw. Happy New Year!
  4. john baez

    I Cosmic Censorship: Does it Hold?

    I seem to be getting pulled into the project of updating this FAQ: https://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/General/open_questions_new.html. The more I look at it, the bigger the job gets. I started out rewriting the section on neutrinos, and now I'm doing the part on cosmic censorship. There...
  5. john baez

    A Can the geodesic equation be derived from the EFE in a certain limit?

    Wow, I forgot after only 15-20 years? My memory must be getting really bad! Thanks! That's not surprising - things often get clearer after a few tries. I'll check out those Kerr papers someday. Maybe in 15-20 years. Just to help myself remember: Roy Kerr, The Lorentz-Covariant...
  6. john baez

    A Can the geodesic equation be derived from the EFE in a certain limit?

    I haven't actually read the Einstein-Infeld-Hoffman papers, but in my post I quoted Einstein as saying So that was certainly his goal: to model particles as singular solutions of Einstein's equations.
  7. john baez

    A Can the geodesic equation be derived from the EFE in a certain limit?

    I think that's at least one of the things they did. Einstein and Infeld wrote three papers on this stuff, and I haven't read them. That sounds hard except in the limit where the masses of the particles are very small, since otherwise they are finite-sized black holes and you have to worry...
  8. john baez

    A Can the geodesic equation be derived from the EFE in a certain limit?

    On another thread, now closed, Intrastellar asked: Unfortunately it seems that thread is closed before anyone pointed out Einstein's papers on this question: A. Einstein, L. Infeld and B. Hoffman, The gravitational equations and the problem of motion, Annals of Mathematics 39 (1938), 65-100...
  9. john baez

    I Open Questions about Neutrinos Today

    No. That's a fun puzzle! Here are some facts that may help you solve it: We shouldn't mix up energy and mass. ##E = mc^2## is only true for particles at rest, which is why another name for mass is "rest mass". As far as we can tell, neutrinos have only 3 possible values for their mass...
  10. john baez

    I Open Questions about Neutrinos Today

    It all depends on how nitpicky people are. A grumpy pedant will point out that however close to the speed of light it moves, it's possible for a left-handed particle to be observed spinning counter-clockwise along its direction of motion. But I should probably not aim to please the grumpy...
  11. john baez

    I Open Questions about Neutrinos Today

    Okay, so I'm not missing anything obvious! I actually think it's pretty good to take advantage of the fact that chirality reduces to helicity in the ultrarelativistic limit, since everyone can imagine a neutrino zipping along near the speed of light spinning clockwise along its axis of motion...
  12. john baez

    I Open Questions about Neutrinos Today

    Thanks! Especially thanks for emphasizing how "heavily blended" the flavor eigenstates are, as linear combinations of mass eigenstates. By the way, I'm not talking about a blog, where it's easy to spend lots of time explaining stuff properly. I'm talking about the Physics FAQ, and I'm trying...
  13. john baez

    I Open Questions about Neutrinos Today

    I meant the three mass eigenstates that most closely line up with the electron, muon, and tau flavor eigenstates. I need some nontechnical way to say what I mean. This is for ordinary folks, so words like "eigenstate" are not allowed. I guess the best way is something like this: "Is there...
  14. john baez

    I Open Questions about Neutrinos Today

    Merry Christmas! Neutrinos are mysterious. I just blogged about some of the big open questions involving neutrinos: Neutrino puzzles. In brief, nontechnical terms they are these: What is the correct theory of neutrinos? Why are they almost but not quite massless? Do all three known...
  15. john baez

    A Octonions and the Standard Model

    We can think of the exceptional Jordan algebra as a funny sort of spacetime. This spacetime is 27-dimensional, with light rays through the origin moving on a lightcone given by a cubic equation instead of the usual $$ t^2 - x^2 - y^2 - z^2 = 0 $$ in 4-dimensional Minkowski spacetime. But...
Back
Top