What are the disadvantages of increasing the diameter of a cylinder?

[blue_print101]

Homework Statement

A larger diameter cylinder produces more force. Can you suggest several disadvantages of increasing the diameter of a cylinder?

The Attempt at a Solution

All I can think of is that there's limited range of motion meaning the cylinder wouldn't be able to move that much of an distance, so if a car was to be hoisted up really far, the cylinder with a smaller diameter be better because even though more air pressure KPa is required, it wouldn't be able to move much due to it's size, and usually the cylinder that doesn't have a big diameter would have a longer height which contributes to more rang of motion and the speed of it's movement would be much slower since it would be heavy due to its mass.

 

[LightHero]

Another disadvantage is that it would require more physical strength to move the larger cylinder compared to the smaller one, and it might be difficult to control the movement of the cylinder. Additionally, a larger diameter cylinder may require more energy to operate and may require more maintenance than smaller cylinders.

 

[Mene]

One disadvantage of increasing the diameter of a cylinder is that it would require more energy to operate. This is because a larger diameter cylinder has a larger surface area, which means more air pressure or force would be needed to move it. This can result in higher energy costs and potentially make the system less efficient.

Another disadvantage is that a larger diameter cylinder may be more difficult to control and maneuver. This is because the larger surface area makes it more susceptible to external forces and can make it harder to maintain precise movements. This could be a safety concern in certain applications.

Additionally, a larger diameter cylinder may also be more expensive to manufacture and maintain. The larger size would require more materials and resources, which can drive up the cost. It may also be more difficult to find replacement parts for a larger cylinder, leading to longer downtimes for maintenance and repairs.

Furthermore, a larger diameter cylinder may also have limitations in terms of space and installation. It may not fit into certain spaces or require modifications to existing systems, which can be time-consuming and costly.

Overall, while a larger diameter cylinder may provide more force, it also comes with disadvantages such as higher energy costs, difficulty in control and maintenance, and limitations in space and installation. These factors should be carefully considered when deciding on the appropriate cylinder size for a specific application.