Science Journal Editor in Turkey Fired over Darwin Cover Story

In summary, the article discusses the controversy surrounding the alleged censorship of a feature about evolution in a Turkish science journal, Bilim ve Teknik. The incident has sparked outrage among secular Turks and raised questions about the influence of the conservative Islamic-oriented government in Turkey. However, some argue that the issue is a matter of choice and faith, rather than being offensive. The conversation also touches upon the potential for technological advancements in the future and the role of religion in scientific progress.
  • #1
Mk
2,043
4
Surprised I didn't find a discussion on this here...
http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,613768,00.html
No issue divides Turks more than the country's alleged creeping Islamization. Early last week, the Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey (Tubitak) sparked an international controversy after it prevented the publication of a cover story about Charles Darwin's evolution theory in Bilim ve Teknik (Science and Technology), one of the country's leading science journals. The publication's editor-in-chief, 41-year-old Cigdem Atakuman, claims she was fired as a result of the incident.

Secular Turks are outraged and the world is watching. Did Tubitak, which publishes Bilim ve Teknik, censor a feature about the theory of evolution under pressure from the conservative Islamic-oriented AKP-led government because it couldn't be reconciled with Muslim religious beliefs?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
We did our part already, we extended our lending hand, as a brother to a brother would, yet they still reject the greatest gift that can be given to a human being: "knowledge." I think it's time to leave them alone.

In 30 years we are going to be building bases on the moon, while they will still be making annual pilgrimages to Mecca. Which is kind of ironic since the crescent moon is on the Turkish flag.
 
  • #3
waht said:
We did our part already, we extended our lending hand, as a brother to a brother would, yet they still reject the greatest gift that can be given to a human being: "knowledge." I think it's time to leave them alone.

In 30 years we are going to be building bases on the moon, while they will still be making annual pilgrimages to Mecca. Which is kind of ironic since the crescent moon is on the Turkish flag.

going on annual pilgrimages to Mecca has nothing to do with being backwards in thought. I think you should choose your words more carefully as they seem easy to offend.
 
  • #4
Oerg said:
going on annual pilgrimages to Mecca has nothing to do with being backwards in thought. I think you should choose your words more carefully as they seem easy to offend.

It absolutely does have entirely to do with being backwards. How apt to quote that bumper stick that says "Sciences flies you to the moon, Religion flies you into buildings"
 
  • #5
waht said:
We did our part already, we extended our lending hand, as a brother to a brother would, yet they still reject the greatest gift that can be given to a human being: "knowledge." I think it's time to leave them alone.

In 30 years we are going to be building bases on the moon, while they will still be making annual pilgrimages to Mecca. Which is kind of ironic since the crescent moon is on the Turkish flag.

You should familiarize yourself in population structure changes. In 30 years it may be that the technology for the trip to the moon is made in the West, but it will be their flag waving in there.
 
  • #6
Oerg said:
going on annual pilgrimages to Mecca has nothing to do with being backwards in thought. I think you should choose your words more carefully as they seem easy to offend.

Muslims are not backward. They are as capable of understanding science as any other human being. And Mecca is a great symbol of Islam, that every Muslim should at least once visit in their life time because of their deep faith. So by analogy, as they are visiting Mecca, they are practicing Islam which is a driving force that rejects science, (great) while the rest of the world will pick up and do wonderful things with technology. So this is rather a choice, than an offense.
 

Related to Science Journal Editor in Turkey Fired over Darwin Cover Story

1. What is the story about?

The story is about a science journal editor in Turkey who was fired after publishing a cover story about Charles Darwin and his theory of evolution.

2. Why was the editor fired?

The editor was fired because the cover story about Darwin and evolution was seen as controversial and went against the government's stance on the topic.

3. How does this impact the scientific community in Turkey?

This incident raises concerns about the freedom of scientific research and expression in Turkey. It may also discourage scientists from publishing controversial or politically sensitive topics.

4. Is this an isolated incident in Turkey?

No, there have been previous cases of censorship and suppression of scientific research in Turkey, particularly on topics related to evolution and creationism.

5. What can be done to prevent similar incidents in the future?

To prevent similar incidents, there needs to be a strong support system for scientific freedom and protection of researchers' rights. Additionally, the government should promote open and critical discussions on controversial scientific topics rather than censoring them. International pressure and advocacy may also help to bring attention to these issues.

Similar threads

Replies
12
Views
3K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • General Discussion
2
Replies
65
Views
8K
Back
Top