How negative energy solution has positive energy in lab?

In summary, QFT equations account for both positive and negative energy solutions, and in the lab, the energies of particles and antiparticles are measured as positive. This is because the negative energy solutions are interpreted as creating positive energy antiparticles instead of annihilating negative energy particles. Therefore, particle-antiparticle annihilation does not result in a cancellation of energies, but rather a creation of energy in the form of gamma rays.
  • #1
mings6
11
0
In QFT equations, there are not only positive energy solutions, but negative ones as well.

Dirac had the hole theory. But the sea may have infinite charges and gravity effects.
And then QFT textbooks just explain the negative solution as anti-particle.

But in the lab, we measure the energies of particle and anti-particle.
Both have positive energies.

So my question is, how to explain that
anti-particle has negative energy eigen value,
but in lab observed positive energy?

If anti-matter had negative energy,
particle-antiparticle annihilation
will cancel each other's energies out
as Energy+(-Energy)=0.
But in fact we observed Energy+Energy=2 Energy(of gamma).

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
In QFT, both particles and antiparticles have positive energy. This solves the issue with Dirac's equation.
 
  • #3
mings6 said:
So my question is, how to explain that anti-particle has negative energy eigen value, but in lab observed positive energy?
In the original interpretation of the Dirac equation as a single-particle wave equation, negative energy solutions did appear. Dirac's hole theory attempted to remedy this, but lasted only a year or two before it was shown to be inconsistent by Heisenberg.

In QFT, Ψ is no longer a wavefunction, it's an annihilation operator. And its negative-frequency part is reinterpreted, not as annihilating a negative energy particle but as creating a positive energy antiparticle. The Hilbert space for QFT contains no negative energy states, only positive energy particles and positive energy antiparticles.
 

Related to How negative energy solution has positive energy in lab?

1. How is it possible for negative energy solutions to have positive energy in a lab?

The concept of negative energy solutions in quantum mechanics is based on the idea that energy can be "borrowed" from the vacuum state. This borrowed energy can then be used to create particles with positive energy, resulting in a net positive energy solution.

2. What experiments have been conducted to demonstrate the existence of negative energy solutions?

One of the most well-known experiments in this field is the Casimir effect, where two parallel plates in a vacuum experience an attractive force due to the presence of negative energy particles in the space between them. Other experiments involve manipulating electromagnetic fields to create negative energy states.

3. How is negative energy different from negative mass?

Negative energy and negative mass are two separate concepts. Negative energy refers to energy that is below the vacuum state, while negative mass refers to a hypothetical type of matter with negative gravitational mass. The two are often confused, but they are distinct and have different implications in physics.

4. What are the potential applications of negative energy solutions?

Some scientists believe that negative energy solutions could potentially be harnessed for practical applications, such as creating new sources of energy or improving the efficiency of existing energy sources. However, much more research and experimentation is needed before these possibilities can be fully explored.

5. Is there any evidence that negative energy solutions exist in our everyday lives?

Currently, there is no concrete evidence that negative energy solutions exist in our everyday lives. The effects of negative energy are only observable on a very small scale, such as in the Casimir effect. However, continued research and experimentation may eventually lead to a better understanding of negative energy and its potential applications.

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
605
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
866
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
1
Views
688
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Back
Top