Good calculus textbook for physics, and vice versa?

In summary, the conversation discusses the individual's interest in two textbooks each of calculus and physics. They have spent countless hours on Stewart's Precalculus and are looking for a calculus textbook to complete before moving on to physics. They mention their preference for Larson's textbook and also ask for recommendations for physics textbooks. They express their willingness to learn both subjects simultaneously and mention their interest in linear algebra. They also discuss the affordability of textbooks and their preference for older editions.
  • #1
Zaqiqu
10
0
There are two textbooks each of calculus and physics which interest me. I am almost finished Stewart's Precalculus, which I have spent countless hundreds of hours on over these last couple of months in autodidactic zeal; and I am intent upon doing over a calculus textbook before moving on to physics.
I make sure to answer correctly at least 50% of the questions in the book, which is probably about 90% of what I attempt. The state of my mathematical education prior to three months thence was abysmal. I do not give up, and I do not care for ease. I want what is best, but also accessible to my level.
There are two calculus books which appeal to me: Stewart's, which I feel is probably the best to go with after having completed his precursor text; and Larson's, which, as I browse through it, gives me a faintly stronger appeal - that and the auxiliary resources that accompany Larson's. Ultimately, my intention is to go on to either Young & Freedman's University Physics with Modern Physics Technology, or perhaps Bauer & Westfall's University Physics with Modern Physics; thus I should prefer that the calculus book recommended be the most suitable for going on to whichever physics text you would also suggest. I am also open to ideas regarding other legitimate alternatives, my primary criterion being that each chapter should abound in examples with which I might hone my skill.

Zaqiqu thanks you for your contributions to his long-lasting internal debate. If you go and take the field of an enemy, the enemy will come and take your field.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Stewart, Larson, Anton, Thomas calculus books are preaty much identitical. Choosing either one doesn't really matter. Choose the book you find easier to read.

You can learn both calculus and physics at the same time. Most introductory calculus physics book introduce calculus rarely in the mechanics portion. Starting from EM portion of the book and onwards, the calculus becomes more involved( nothing crazy).

I would recommend you purchase an older edition of Stewart Calculus and Thomas Calculus 3rd ed. Make sure you get the 3rd ed, These books supplement each other really well. Thomas has a lot of geometric intuition and the book layout does not have 7 diagrams and colors on every page.

After doing the equivalent of calculus 2, you may wana start learning linear algebra.
 
  • #3
MidgetDwarf said:
Stewart, Larson, Anton, Thomas calculus books are preaty much identitical. Choosing either one doesn't really matter. Choose the book you find easier to read.

You can learn both calculus and physics at the same time. Most introductory calculus physics book introduce calculus rarely in the mechanics portion. Starting from EM portion of the book and onwards, the calculus becomes more involved( nothing crazy).

I would recommend you purchase an older edition of Stewart Calculus and Thomas Calculus 3rd ed. Make sure you get the 3rd ed, These books supplement each other really well. Thomas has a lot of geometric intuition and the book layout does not have 7 diagrams and colors on every page.

After doing the equivalent of calculus 2, you may wana start learning linear algebra.

Just curious, is there a reason you're suggesting an older edition of Stewart's Calculus?
 
  • #4
It's cheaper and their practically all the same.
 
  • Like
Likes TheCanadian
  • #5
I love matrices, so I do look forward to Linear Algebra. Larson's or Clay's, I figure.
I started Bauer and Westfall's Physics maybe six months ago, worked for a week before I realized that there was no way I'd get through the third chapter without calculus, and so here I've been, sitting right here for 10 hours each day glued to Stewart's Precalculus.
Cost is irrelevant. I've long collected books from thrift stores, I have more books than you could imagine, far from the smallest category of which is the university textbook. I live in a city with no less than four post-secondary institutes, so there is no lack of used textbooks floating around.
The one complaint I notice most people have with Stewart is that his books are unduly expensive (are not all new textbooks? a most enjoyable hobby is to buy a bunch of used textbooks, 2 or 3 bucks a pop, go home and check Amazon to see that they each sell for no less than $240) While I am sure that that is so, cost has no bearing upon my decision and so I want only the best when it comes to preparation for physics.
 
  • #6
an older edition of stewart can be had for 5 bucks shipped (the full book).
 
  • #7
"Vector Calculus" by Marsden/Tromba is a good book that focuses both on the applied (particularly in the physics) and theoretical aspects of vector calculus.
 

Related to Good calculus textbook for physics, and vice versa?

1. What makes a calculus textbook suitable for physics?

A good calculus textbook for physics should cover topics that are relevant to physics, such as derivatives and integrals in the context of motion and forces. It should also include examples and problems that are related to real-world physics applications.

2. Is it necessary for a physics textbook to include calculus?

While not all physics textbooks require a strong foundation in calculus, it is highly recommended for a deeper understanding of the subject. Many fundamental concepts in physics, such as velocity and acceleration, are described using calculus equations.

3. Can a calculus textbook be used for self-study in physics?

Yes, a calculus textbook can be a useful resource for self-studying physics. However, it is important to also supplement with a physics textbook to ensure a comprehensive understanding of the subject.

4. Are there any specific calculus techniques that are important for physics?

Some important calculus techniques for physics include integration by parts, substitution, and partial fractions. These techniques are commonly used to solve equations and problems in physics.

5. Are there any recommended calculus textbooks for physics and vice versa?

There are many great calculus textbooks that are suitable for physics, such as "Calculus: Early Transcendentals" by James Stewart and "Calculus for Scientists and Engineers" by William Briggs and Lyle Cochran. As for physics textbooks that incorporate calculus, "University Physics" by Young and Freedman is a highly recommended option.

Similar threads

  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
22
Views
4K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
28
Views
2K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
19
Views
940
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
10
Views
1K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
27
Views
17K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
26
Views
3K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
12
Views
2K
Back
Top