Exploring the Concept of Sin: Questions and Stories

[Padford]

Have posted this in the philosophical section, but would be interesting to see replies from here, in a true conroversial style. the questions are:
Does sin exist?
What is your understanding of sin?
Is sin the same as the concept of wrong?
Where did your understanding of right and wrong come from?
Are the seven deadly sins a good moral code...are they relevant today?
If we don't have the concept of sin now, what is it replaced by?
Who has the right to judge?
Is the concept of fear and punishment a good idea?
What about confessionals? Are they relevant?
also, if you have any anecdotes, confessions! please, feel free; it's all in the name of art!
Padford

 

[Evo]

Have posted this in the philosophical section, but would be interesting to see replies from here, in a true conroversial style. the questions are:
Does sin exist?
What is your understanding of sin?
Is sin the same as the concept of wrong?
Where did your understanding of right and wrong come from?
Are the seven deadly sins a good moral code...are they relevant today?
If we don't have the concept of sin now, what is it replaced by?
Who has the right to judge?
Is the concept of fear and punishment a good idea?
What about confessionals? Are they relevant?
also, if you have any anecdotes, confessions! please, feel free; it's all in the name of art!
Padford

Double posts (posting the same thing in more than one forum) is not allowed.

 

[R0man]

The concept of sin has been a controversial and heavily debated topic for centuries. Some believe that sin is a real and tangible concept, while others argue that it is a man-made construct used to control and manipulate individuals. In order to explore this idea further, we must first define what sin is and where our understanding of it comes from.

For some, sin is a religious concept that refers to actions or thoughts that are deemed to be against the laws or will of a divine being. It is often associated with guilt and shame, and the idea of being punished for these transgressions. However, there are others who view sin as a societal construct, with its definition and consequences being determined by cultural norms and values.

Regardless of how one defines sin, it is clear that it is closely linked to the concept of wrong. In many cases, the two are used interchangeably, with sin being seen as a moral wrong and wrong being seen as a sin against societal norms. However, there are also those who argue that sin goes beyond just being a moral or societal wrong, and encompasses a deeper spiritual or metaphysical dimension.

The understanding of right and wrong, and by extension sin, is heavily influenced by one's upbringing, culture, and personal beliefs. For some, it may come from religious teachings, while for others it may come from their family or community values. It is a complex and subjective concept that varies from person to person.

The seven deadly sins, also known as the cardinal sins, have been used as a moral code in many religions and societies. These include pride, greed, lust, envy, gluttony, wrath, and sloth. While they may have been relevant in the past, their relevance in today's society is up for debate. Some argue that these sins are still relevant and can serve as a guide for moral behavior, while others see them as outdated and restrictive.

If we were to move away from the concept of sin, what would replace it? Some may argue that it would be replaced by the concept of personal responsibility and accountability. Others may argue that it would be replaced by a more nuanced understanding of actions and their consequences, rather than labeling them as inherently good or bad.

The question of who has the right to judge is a complex one. In many religions, it is believed that only a divine being has the ultimate authority to judge one's sins. However, in society, we often see individuals and institutions taking on this role, whether it be through