Confusion with Nodal Analysis w/ Sources

In summary, the conversation discusses nodal analysis and the confusion of using the correct signs when there is a voltage source in the loop. The problem is ultimately solved with the understanding that the reference point (GND) determines the voltage polarity, not the direction of the currents. This is demonstrated through the use of a 24V voltage source with a positive terminal connected to GND and a minus terminal connected to a 6 ohm resistor. The conversation concludes with the understanding that this principle applies regardless of the direction of the currents.
  • #1
RiceKernel
17
0
Hi , I'm currently stuck on a problem that requires to be solved with nodal analysis.

I'm confused to what signs should I use when there's a voltage source in the loop.

The problem:
lol2-1.png


I already know the answer from the solutions but what I found is at V_0 :

(V0 - 60V)/12 + V0/12 + (V0 -24V)/6 = 0

This is horrendously incorrect but I can't understand why . I know current flows from higher potential to lower so if that was the case then my first term would be correct (matches solution) ; the 2nd term is also correct (V0-0V)/12 but the last term is incorrect. The correct term would be (VO - (-24V))/6 and I really don't know why? Can someone explain that to me? Even for the first term, I just got lucky by putting the correct sign but I want to know why and how does the sign vary.

Oh and if anyone wants the answer , V0= 3V. Power in resistors are easy to find once the currents and voltages are found.

Thanks,
GT
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
Because 24V voltage source has a positive terminal connected to gnd and the minus terminal to 6 ohm resistor.
And this is why voltage at right side of a 6 ohm resistor is -24V ( 24 voltages lower than voltage at GND).

The reference point determines whether we have a positive or negative voltage.
See this example
32.PNG
 
Last edited:
  • #3
Does this apply regardless of the direction of the current(s) ?
 
  • #4
RiceKernel said:
Does this apply regardless of the direction of the current(s) ?
In this case the current direction doesn't matter here. Because only the voltage source and the reference point (GND) determines the voltage polarity.
And this is why we have -24V and 60V regardless of the direction of the currents.
 
  • #5


Hello GT,

I can understand your confusion with nodal analysis when there are voltage sources in the loop. The key thing to remember is that voltage sources are always assumed to have a fixed voltage, regardless of the direction of current flow. This means that the voltage at a node connected to a voltage source will always be the same as the voltage of the source.

In your problem, you correctly identified the currents flowing into the node connected to the voltage source as (V0-0V)/12 and (V0-24V)/6. However, for the last term, you need to consider the direction of current flow in the loop. Since current flows from higher potential to lower potential, the current flowing through the voltage source will be in the opposite direction, from -24V to V0. Therefore, the correct term would be (V0-(-24V))/6, which simplifies to (V0+24V)/6.

I hope this explanation helps you understand the sign variation in nodal analysis. It's important to keep in mind the direction of current flow and the fixed voltage of voltage sources when setting up the equations. Good luck with your problem!
 

Related to Confusion with Nodal Analysis w/ Sources

1. What is nodal analysis with sources?

Nodal analysis with sources is a method used in circuit analysis to determine the voltage and current at various nodes (connection points) in a circuit. It takes into account both voltage sources (such as batteries) and current sources (such as resistors).

2. How is nodal analysis with sources different from regular nodal analysis?

Nodal analysis with sources is an extension of regular nodal analysis. The main difference is that regular nodal analysis only considers voltage sources, while nodal analysis with sources also takes into account current sources. This makes it more useful for analyzing circuits with both types of sources.

3. What are the steps for performing nodal analysis with sources?

The steps for performing nodal analysis with sources are as follows:

  1. Identify and label all the nodes in the circuit.
  2. Choose a reference node and assign it a voltage of 0.
  3. Write Kirchhoff's Current Law (KCL) equations for each node, using the reference node as a starting point.
  4. Substitute the values for any known currents or voltages from the sources into the KCL equations.
  5. Solve the resulting system of equations for the remaining unknown node voltages.

4. What are the limitations of nodal analysis with sources?

Nodal analysis with sources can become complex and time-consuming for circuits with a large number of nodes. It also assumes that all the components in the circuit are linear, which may not always be the case in real-world circuits.

5. When should I use nodal analysis with sources?

Nodal analysis with sources is most useful when analyzing circuits with multiple sources, such as voltage dividers, current mirrors, or transistor circuits. It is also helpful for circuits with non-linear elements, as long as they can be approximated as linear within the range of interest.

Similar threads

  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
942
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
945
Replies
20
Views
2K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
650
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
7K
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
8
Views
1K
Back
Top